Good values are harder to find
Jason Stipp  |  28/05/2015Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  

Jason Stipp: I'm Jason Stipp for Morningstar. It's International Investing Week on, and today we're taking a look at valuation levels across the globe with Morningstar markets editor Jeremy Glaser.
Jeremy, thanks for being here. Jeremy Glaser: You are welcome, Jason.

Stipp: Before we tour the world from a valuation perspective, let's talk about how we measure global valuations, the way we can extend our Analyst Ratings so that we can cover more of the world.

Glaser: Like you mentioned, we do have these analyst ratings--we have analysts who are covering stocks in the United States and Europe and Asia. Our research team has created a quantitative model that extends those ratings and tries to extrapolate what they think our ratings would be for stocks that we don't cover - markets that we don't have analysts for or stocks that are just too small for us to have full analyst coverage on. And using that data, we're able to get a snapshot of what equity valuations look like across the world.

Stipp: Let's unfold the map and start in Europe. Stock markets there have done pretty well. What do valuations look like, though?

Glaser: This has been one of the big turnarounds. Europe was trading at a pretty big discount to the United States in terms of valuations for a while, and that gap has disappeared. In fact, Europe looks more expensive right now. Overall, we think it's trading at a 4.6% premium versus a 1.2% premium in the United States.

Stipp: What was driving some of that outperformance that we were seeing in Europe?

Glaser: A lot of it was just a better outlook for European growth. We've seen signs that a lot of the worries about recession and deflation in Europe have really receded, and that's being caused a lot by exports. The European Central Bank obviously launched its quantitative-easing program. That has really helped keep the euro very low against the dollar. It has boosted export markets, and that has been a big boon for those economies. We are starting to see that in the data. I think that got investors excited. QE also tends to boost asset prices, so that was a big factor there.
Then, also, worries about Greece have become a slightly less pronounced. I think that there is more of a sense that the issues there are really ring-fenced so that if Greece were to exit the euro, it would be something that could be contained and [won't lead to some] sort of systemic risk across the rest of the continent.

Stipp: So, all of Europe is looking somewhat overvalued, but when you dig in, country by country, there is some differentiation.

Glaser: Yes, there is. You look at a country like Germany, which is more than 9 per cent overvalued, and that looks much more stretched than, say, Greece at 5 per cent undervalued. Though, there are obviously some issues [in Greece] that might mean there isn't a big enough margin of safety to really go all in. Emerging Europe looks about fairly valued right now--Poland at 1.5 per cent overvalued and Turkey at 2 per cent overvalued.

Stipp: So, if you are paying up a little bit for Europe as a whole, you are really paying up if you are going to Asia; those markets, on average, look pretty overvalued.

Glaser: Asia looks quite expensive. Eighteen percent overvalued for the entire region, and that's really driven by China. The Chinese market is 38 per cent overvalued, which is even up from where it was a month ago.

Stipp: And why do we think the Chinese market has been doing so well?

Glaser: This is kind of an interesting one, because China's economy has not been doing all that well. We're seeing signs of a pretty significant slowing there. We actually talked to Francisco Torralba about this - he is a senior economist at Morningstar Investment Management. He really thinks a lot of this is being driven by speculation, it's being driven by margin trading, and a lot of what's happening in the mainland Chinese market is not really being driven by fundamentals. It does look quite stretched.

Stipp: Hong Kong and Japan - not quite as overvalued-looking, but they also do look pricey.

Glaser: Hong Kong at more than 11 per cent and Japan at more than 7 per cent don't look cheap. And in Japan in particular, I think there are still a lot of question marks about if Abenomics - this three-pronged approach to restarting Japanese growth - will be successful or not. The market still thinks the answer is yes, but the jury is still very much out.

Stipp: Closer to home, how do valuation levels in Latin America and South America look?

Glaser: Not a lot of particularly great value is there, either. Argentina looks to be more than 7 per cent overvalued; Brazil is at more than 3 per cent. So, there's not a lot of opportunity there, either.

Stipp: So, when you wrap this all together, looking across the globe at where the valuation levels are, where are risks are, what's the takeaway?

Glaser: I think the takeaway is that there is not a region that looks like a great opportunity versus others. That was the case with Europe for some time, and that story is very much done. Asia, as you mentioned, looks quite stretched. So, I think for international-stock investors, they really have to think about why they are investing abroad, because right now valuation is not going to be the primary reason to do that. Is it a diversification benefit that you are looking for? Are there individual firms that you think are undervalued or that you think have great businesses that you want to invest in? I think those are the questions you have to answer. Just going out looking for cheap stocks or thinking a whole region looks cheap, though, based on our research, we just don't think that that is really the strategy that's going to work right now, given how expensive everything looks.

Stipp: Very interesting tour of the world from a valuation perspective. Thanks for joining me, Jeremy.

Glaser: You are welcome, Jason.

Stipp: For Morningstar, I'm Jason Stipp. Thanks for watching.


Video Archive...

Good values are harder to find
28/05/2015  A run-up in European stocks has left the region moderately overvalued, while Asia market valuations are even more stretched; according to Morningstar's fair value metrics.
A stock with a unique growth opportunity
25/05/2015  The largest law firm in Australia provides a good investment opportunity for long-term investors.
Growth prospects in emerging markets
20/05/2015  Emerging market guru Mark Mobius talks about bull markets and viable growth opportunities at the recent Morningstar Investment Conference in the UK.
Be selective, exercise caution
18/05/2015  While value may not seem to be in abundance there are still opportunities to be found in the local market, as Morningstar's Peter Warnes explains.
A better deal for retail investors
14/05/2015  Enduring dividend imputation is not abolished and fairer capital raisings are among the items on the policy agenda for the Australian Shareholders’ Association.
The growth outlook for Wesfarmers
11/05/2015  Wesfarmers' Richard Goyder talks about managing a diverse business and the growing number of "serious players" in the supermarket sector.
Big bank earnings wrap
08/05/2015  Morningstar's David Ellis gives investors the lowdown on the half-year results from Westpac, ANZ and NAB, as well as his view on CBA's trading update.
Where Buffett sees value
06/05/2015  Morningstar's Matt Coffina discusses Buffett's view of stock valuations, cost-cutting, and more while attending the recent Berkshire Hathaway annual general meeting.
Finding value in small companies
01/05/2015  Investing in the small cap-sector can be wealth-destroying. Therefore, it is important that investors make informed decisions.
Top global tech opportunities
30/04/2015  Australia's foremost global investor Kerr Neilson identifies global drivers and those undervalued companies that are positioned for strong growth.
Finding value in volatile markets
24/04/2015  With the Australian market at a six-year high, it is difficult to seek value but investors can still find quality companies at good prices, according to Morningstar’s fund manager of the year.
Europe showing signs of life
23/04/2015  As growth concerns linger in China and the U.S., central-bank policy in Europe appears to be having its desired effect, says Morningstar's Bob Johnson.
Key takeaways from the Murray inquiry, SuperStream
23/04/2015  The SMSF Association's Graeme Colley discusses important points from both the Murray inquiry and the SuperStream initiative, while also giving trustees tips on how to avoid unwanted "gardening leave".
Avoiding a falling stock market
14/04/2015  Want to maximise portfolio returns and minimise losses? Stick to a value approach and resist the urge to be backward looking when it comes to performance
Navigating your portfolio amid volatility
09/04/2015  Westpac's David Simon talks about rebalancing a portfolio as investors continue to confront a number of risks.
Identifying stocks that will beat the market
31/03/2015  Think risk assets deliver the greatest returns? A new paper dispels this myth and instead proves that the equities that deliver the greatest profit are the unpopular ones
Protect your portfolio from losses
25/03/2015  Risk is not volatility - risk is the potential an investor has for loss, says Oaktree's Howard Marks. Recognising this is the first step in protecting your portfolio from losing money.
Revisiting the sole purpose test
19/03/2015  It’s important that trustees are reminded about their obligations under the sole purpose test – a key requirement in SMSF compliance.
Macro trinity underpinning eurozone
12/03/2015  Three key forces have ensured strong growth from most European markets so far this year, explains Morningstar's Jose Garcia Zarate, but structural flaws still need to be addressed
Taxing times for trustees?
05/03/2015  The government may have moved to address the tax concessions into super but trustees face a number of potential taxing issues.