Mining tax deceitful: Hockey
Christine St Anne  |  26/10/2012Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  
Christine St Anne: The mining tax has set a new benchmark in public policy by being the first tax to raise no money. Shadow treasurer, Joe Hockey, said at the recent Financial Services Council Breakfast in Sydney.  

Joe Hockey: This is a new benchmark in public policy around the world. Not even the Greeks could achieve that.

St Anne: Mr. Hockey also slammed the structure of the tax as being incompetent. 

Hockey: I'd say to you the spin from the government is classic. Yesterday, they said, oh, look, the deductions are upfront. They don't even understand their own tax. If they paid nothing on Monday then they expect to pay nothing in three months, nothing three months after that and nothing three months after that. And if they get it wrong, they get charged penalties. But wait, it gets even better. You know what, royalties are credited against their mining tax liability. Royalties are credited, state royalties. So, if they don't have a mining tax liability, there is a contingent liability for the common wealth to rebate the royalties. Here is the mining tax that not only doesn't raise a dollar, it owes money. Only the labor party could develop a taxation policy that cost the government money. It is quite extraordinary. 

St Anne: Given the lack of revenue generated by the mining tax promised government initiatives were in jeopardy. Mr. Hockey labeled these as the deceitful.

Hockey: The tears start flying when you realize that they've committed billions and billions of dollars of expenditure against the mining tax revenue they claim they are going to have. Regional infrastructure, billions of dollars; increasing superannuation from 9 per cent to 12 per cent, billions of dollars cost to the budget; school kids bonuses. Remember the budget they said they were going to share the benefits of the mining boom around, all paid for out of the mining tax. Everything you can think of is virtually being paid for out of the mining tax. The sad part is, there is no mining tax. The worst part of it is, it is an act of deceit by the government. They brought forward the midyear statement to less than four months into the financial year because they knew that on Monday on the other side of camera at the Australian taxation office the mining companies would be lodging a remittance on the mining tax of nil. It's a con. I have never seen anything more deceitful out of the government; they knew it. They haven't explained why they brought it forward to October. The only two previous occasions, you've ever had a media statement released in October was when there was an election called in November and they had to be an election in those years. And yet the government did this totally aware they were not going to raise a dollar from the mining tax, which would have blown a $2 billion hole in their budget, this year alone.

St Anne: Speaking to an audience largely made up of executives working in financial services, Mr. Hockey said that as an incoming treasurer he would make financial services a better export industry. He maintained his bearish views on both the European and US economies. As an incoming treasurer he would also launch a review in financial services in order to prepare for this ongoing market volatility.

Hockey: We need to prepare and we need to prepare now for what was going to be a capital market volatility, in my view, of fairly extreme proportions for the next 20 years. That's why we want to have a financial system review, a full financial system review. The son of Wallace, granddaughter of Campbell, whatever you may call it, this is one of the recommendations I made in the Coalition's nine-point plan on banking back in October 2010. I don't want you to think this is just another review. I know everyone has reformed fatigue. So what we are going to do is we are going to give you a commitment during the course of the review. We are not going to undertake any significant change and unless it is to the benefit of the financial services industry.

St Anne: Mr. Hockey was urged the financial services industry to keep its commitment to trust and transparency as the industry continues to remain a critical role in Australia's economy.

Hockey: I want to say to you, thank you. I know how hard it's been over the few years with the enormous volatility, with the massive amount of regulation, with consumer pressure and competition. But I just want to say to all of you who employ so many people, who help to create so much wealth, who work so incredibly hard, I want to say thank you. Thank you for being so successful. Thank you for being overwhelmingly one of the most honest financial services industries in the world, one of the most innovative financial services industries in the world. I want us to be better. We can be better. We can be the best. And if we are the best in the fastest growing region in the world there's blue sky opportunity and not only you benefit from that, but the whole of our country benefits from that. Thank you very much.

St Anne: Christine St Anne for Morningstar.

Video Archive...

to Morningstar Premium Membership

Market outlook for 2015
18/12/2014  Morningstar's Peter Warnes gives investors an idea of what to expect from the Australian share market over the coming year, while also providing some tips for a stronger portfolio.
Morningstar's new ETF ratings
10/12/2014  Morningstar’s Tim Murphy discusses the new ETF analyst ratings and reports that are now available to investors.
Top opportunities in hybrids
09/12/2014  After a recent broad widening in pricing, investors may find opportunities in some of the older-style bank notes and high-quality corporate issuers.
Iron ore's changing landscape
03/12/2014  With small, high-cost miners set to struggle, Chinese growth to flatten and the low-cost majors pushing hard on expansion, the face of iron-ore mining is set to look very different.
Will QE boost European stocks?
28/11/2014  As ECB members hint quantitative easing could come sooner than expected in the Eurozone, we examine the prospects for European stock markets. From Morningstar UK.
Quality stocks, sustainable yields
26/11/2014  Anton Tagliaferro of Investors Mutual shares his outlook for the market at last month's Morningstar Individual Investor Conference.
Key risks in bond investing
21/11/2014  There are a number of risks investors need to consider in bond investing.
Confronting volatility and low growth
18/11/2014  Given issues such as recent volatility, rising global debt levels and the threat of European deflation, there are steps investors can take to safeguard their portfolios.
Medibank: A quality business at the right price?
13/11/2014  The health insurer is a quality business but it will all come down two the price, according to two fund managers.
Telstra and sustainable returns
12/11/2014  The Australian telecoms giant has some exciting growth opportunities ahead of it and will continue to provide sustainable returns over the longer term.
Bank earnings wrap-up
07/11/2014  Morningstar sector head of financials David Ellis gives investors the lowdown on the most recent batch of earnings from Australia's major banks.
Medibank IPO Report
29/10/2014  While there were a few "surprises" in the prospectus, health insurer Medibank Private is still on track to deliver growth, according to Morningstar's Peter Warnes and David Ellis.
Opportunities in fixed income
28/10/2014   Bentham Asset Management principal and portfolio manager Richard Quin provides investors with some insights into fixed-income investment and the role that short-duration credit can play in a portfolio.
Key investor risks
21/10/2014  Voted among the 50 most influential people in finance today, author and former banker Satyajit
Finding value in small companies
14/10/2014  A portfolio of "terrific value" can still be achieved despite the stretched valuations in the smaller end of the Australian equities market.
Choosing quality businesses
07/10/2014  Credit investors adopt a different approach to equity investors when assessing a quality business, according to PIMCO's Tracy Chin.
Don't panic about PIMCO
30/09/2014  Morningstar's Tim Murphy talks about the recent portfolio manager changes at the global bond manager and why investors should not panic.
Medibank IPO Preview
25/09/2014  Morningstar's Peter Warnes and David Ellis preview the upcoming initial public offering of health insurance giant Medibank Private.
A better deal for investors
24/09/2014  Morningstar’s Anthony Serhan outlines what the government’s Financial System Inquiry will mean for investors.
Europe growth: Gone for good?
18/09/2014  Facing entrenched structural issues, the eurozone’s days of robust growth are likely over, but there are some reasons for hope, says Morningstar's Bob Johnson.