Mining tax deceitful: Hockey

Christine St Anne  |  26/10/2012Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  
Christine St Anne: The mining tax has set a new benchmark in public policy by being the first tax to raise no money. Shadow treasurer, Joe Hockey, said at the recent Financial Services Council Breakfast in Sydney.  

Joe Hockey: This is a new benchmark in public policy around the world. Not even the Greeks could achieve that.

St Anne: Mr. Hockey also slammed the structure of the tax as being incompetent. 

Hockey: I'd say to you the spin from the government is classic. Yesterday, they said, oh, look, the deductions are upfront. They don't even understand their own tax. If they paid nothing on Monday then they expect to pay nothing in three months, nothing three months after that and nothing three months after that. And if they get it wrong, they get charged penalties. But wait, it gets even better. You know what, royalties are credited against their mining tax liability. Royalties are credited, state royalties. So, if they don't have a mining tax liability, there is a contingent liability for the common wealth to rebate the royalties. Here is the mining tax that not only doesn't raise a dollar, it owes money. Only the labor party could develop a taxation policy that cost the government money. It is quite extraordinary. 

St Anne: Given the lack of revenue generated by the mining tax promised government initiatives were in jeopardy. Mr. Hockey labeled these as the deceitful.

Hockey: The tears start flying when you realize that they've committed billions and billions of dollars of expenditure against the mining tax revenue they claim they are going to have. Regional infrastructure, billions of dollars; increasing superannuation from 9 per cent to 12 per cent, billions of dollars cost to the budget; school kids bonuses. Remember the budget they said they were going to share the benefits of the mining boom around, all paid for out of the mining tax. Everything you can think of is virtually being paid for out of the mining tax. The sad part is, there is no mining tax. The worst part of it is, it is an act of deceit by the government. They brought forward the midyear statement to less than four months into the financial year because they knew that on Monday on the other side of camera at the Australian taxation office the mining companies would be lodging a remittance on the mining tax of nil. It's a con. I have never seen anything more deceitful out of the government; they knew it. They haven't explained why they brought it forward to October. The only two previous occasions, you've ever had a media statement released in October was when there was an election called in November and they had to be an election in those years. And yet the government did this totally aware they were not going to raise a dollar from the mining tax, which would have blown a $2 billion hole in their budget, this year alone.

St Anne: Speaking to an audience largely made up of executives working in financial services, Mr. Hockey said that as an incoming treasurer he would make financial services a better export industry. He maintained his bearish views on both the European and US economies. As an incoming treasurer he would also launch a review in financial services in order to prepare for this ongoing market volatility.

Hockey: We need to prepare and we need to prepare now for what was going to be a capital market volatility, in my view, of fairly extreme proportions for the next 20 years. That's why we want to have a financial system review, a full financial system review. The son of Wallace, granddaughter of Campbell, whatever you may call it, this is one of the recommendations I made in the Coalition's nine-point plan on banking back in October 2010. I don't want you to think this is just another review. I know everyone has reformed fatigue. So what we are going to do is we are going to give you a commitment during the course of the review. We are not going to undertake any significant change and unless it is to the benefit of the financial services industry.

St Anne: Mr. Hockey was urged the financial services industry to keep its commitment to trust and transparency as the industry continues to remain a critical role in Australia's economy.

Hockey: I want to say to you, thank you. I know how hard it's been over the few years with the enormous volatility, with the massive amount of regulation, with consumer pressure and competition. But I just want to say to all of you who employ so many people, who help to create so much wealth, who work so incredibly hard, I want to say thank you. Thank you for being so successful. Thank you for being overwhelmingly one of the most honest financial services industries in the world, one of the most innovative financial services industries in the world. I want us to be better. We can be better. We can be the best. And if we are the best in the fastest growing region in the world there's blue sky opportunity and not only you benefit from that, but the whole of our country benefits from that. Thank you very much.

St Anne: Christine St Anne for Morningstar.

Video Archive...

Helping SMSF trustees negotiate super complexities
19/08/2016  Peter Hogan, head of technical at the SMSF Assocation, shares his insights on the changing super environment and how it will affect SMSF trustees.
Chasing income in a low return world
10/08/2016  Paul Reisz, Pimco's executive vice president and income product manager head, gives his insights on where bond investors may find yield in the difficult global market environment.
US stocks offer most attractive income, says Investec
03/08/2016  Investec's UK-based global equity income investor Blake Hutchins says despite the stock-market rally raising valuations, the US offers the most attractive options for income investors.
US stocks which will continue to rally
28/07/2016  The US stock market looks fairly valued as a whole, admits JP Morgan's Dennis Ruhl--but there are some sectors which will deliver further growth.
Xero underlines returning popularity of technology stocks
19/07/2016  The success of accounting software company Xero is part of a broader resurgence of technology companies, contrasting with the shifting fortunes of Australia's resources sector.
Zurich Investments Global Thematic
18/07/2016  Morningstar's Kathryn Young explains what sets Zurich Investments Global Thematic apart from rival global equities strategies.
Gold Managers: Platinum International Fund
15/07/2016  Morningstar's Kathryn Young explains what makes Platinum International a standout strategy and the rationale behind the fund's Gold rating.
Gold Managers: Magellan Global Fund
15/07/2016  Morningstar's Tim Wong explains why the Magellan Global Equities was upgraded to Gold and why there is more to the strategy than Hamish Douglass.
Is this graph to blame for Brexit?
13/07/2016  Britain's vote to leave the European Union seems to tie in with a feeling across the Western world--a rebellion against globalisation and those in power.
Global equities versus Aussie equities
11/07/2016  While global equities may be attractive on a relative valuation basis, it's important not to blindly follow a benchmark, Morningstar Investment Management's Brad Bugg says.
Forecast 2016-17: Exercise caution
08/07/2016  Morningstar's Peter Warnes shares his thoughts on the past year, his expectations for the year ahead, as well as a few important recommendations.
Breaking from the pack in asset allocation
04/07/2016  Morningstar Investment Management's Andrew Lill explains the benefits of long-term, valuation-driven asset allocation, while also elaborating on his team's definition of "risk".
A permanent state of distorted reality
30/06/2016  Hamish Douglass, chief executive officer, Magellan Financial Group, explains why he believes we are at an odd point in history with the Brexit vote, ineffectual central bank policies and volatile currencies.
How should investors react to Brexit result?
28/06/2016  Dan Kemp of Morningstar UK says investors need to keep cool, calm heads amid political and financial uncertainty as to what happens next, following the Brexit vote.
Behavioural finance and how it hits your bottom line
28/06/2016  Understanding how your thought patterns drive investment decisions could amount to hundreds of thousands of dollars over your lifetime, explains behavioural finance expert Simon Russell.
Bogle on Brexit and other threats to global markets
21/06/2016  We have more borrowing, more leverage, more government debt relative to GDP than we have ever had with no attempt to get it down, says Vanguard founder Jack Bogle.
Are we heading for another recession?
21/06/2016  After an incredible rally across developed market equities and global bonds, the good times may be over. Should investors be selling up for cash and gold?
Buy the world in a couple of trades
20/06/2016  As the popularity of ETFs continues to skyrocket in Australia, Morningstar asks Jon Howie, head of iShares Australia how ongoing market volatility affects investors in this space.
2 asset classes presenting value
16/06/2016  While most asset classes may be a bit on the expensive side, Schroders' Simon Stevenson believes pockets of reasonable value can still be found.
Combining active and passive investment management
08/06/2016  Active investing versus index investing isn’t necessarily a prescriptive “one or the other” approach, explains Stephen van Eyk.