Bogle: Most difficult investment conditions I've ever seen
Morningstar US  |  06/11/2012Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  

Benz: If people are going through their year-end exercises with their portfolios, they might see that stocks have had a really great run; it might be time to rebalance out of stocks, which would mean moving money into bonds. What would you say to investors? Should they go ahead and do it given the meager outlook for fixed income? What's your take on that question?

Bogle: Well, I am not basically a rebalancer. In the long run, rebalancing is going to cost you because the higher-yielding, the higher-returning, asset is going to get to be a bigger and bigger part of the portfolio, and if you suppress it by rebalancing, you will almost definitely have a lower return over the long run.

In the short run, that's something else, and I think if people want to rebalance, that's fine. And I think if people think about it [not] as an annual exercise, but if your target equity ratio is at 60 per cent, think about rebalancing when it gets to 70 per cent or when it gets to 50 per cent, but not slavishly looking at, oh my god, I'm at 60.5 per cent and doing something, because there is too much other noise in the system to make that work.

So, to each his own on this. I don't myself. My personal account is about 80 per cent Vanguard municipal bond funds and 20 per cent Vanguard index funds, and in my retirement plan account, I'm about 50-50. So, I'm very comfortable there. I don't rebalance the retirement plan accounts ... for probably, let me say, 50 per cent at the beginning of the year. I don't do this with any exactitude. Maybe they are 55 per cent now. I don't see any reason to change that.

But you are correct in the implications of your question that this is a really difficult time to invest. I told a New York Times reporter on an article he wrote, [these are] the most difficult investment conditions I've ever seen. And by that I'm not talking about huge risk. I'm talking about the impossibility of getting the kind of returns we've gotten in the past. It is not going to happen, period.

That long-term return on stocks from Jeremy Siegel is around 9 per cent and nominal, and the long-term return on bonds is about 5 per cent, and I'm telling you, let's think about 7 per cent, and let's think about 2.5 per cent - half of those rates.

So, what are you supposed to do? Well, I do not think it's a good idea to take risks beyond that to increase your return, I just don't believe it. That's become an article of faith.

In our municipal bond group ... for years I was in every meeting that they ever held just to warn them, don't reach for income. So what's the first thing you are going to do? Well, most of the alternatives aren't really very palatable, from leaving the market. I do think you can maybe emphasize corporates more than Treasuries. I think that would be an intelligent thing for people to do - separate out the bond market into those two components and maybe take a little more maturity risk, which is not credit risk, just volatility risk.

But what are the other options? Well, you can cut back your standard of living - it's very hard - as my father used to say, no matter how painful. And you can also start to spend a little capital every year, but you can't do that forever. Maybe a year or two wouldn't hurt too much if the numbers weren't too large. You can, as a lot of people are talking about today, go into high-yielding stocks, but you are taking a volatility risk that you are not taking in the bond. Or you can go to high-yield bonds, junk bonds, but you are taking a credit risk. So there is a pro for every con.

Benz: Not a palatable set of decisions.

Bogle: So, I'm a "stay the course" guy. I do think importantly that we ought to be thinking more about the difference between government bonds and corporate bonds, because those spreads are very, very large compared to historical norms.

Benz: And you could see a case for overweighting the corporates.

Bogle: Yes. The corporate bond yields are pretty close to 3 per cent, and the Treasury yield is 1.6 per cent, and Treasuries are such an important part of total bond market index, the yield on that is only 1.7 per cent. And if you ... realize that that means you are going to get a 1.7 per cent return on the highest probability in the next 10 years, it just seems you shouldn't accept that. Not jumping off the deep end of the pool, but just getting a toe wet with maybe instead of 70 per cent governments and 30 per cent corporates, maybe 60 per cent corporates and 40 per cent governments or even 70/30.

Video Archive...

Avoiding a falling stock market
14/04/2015  Want to maximise portfolio returns and minimise losses? Stick to a value approach and resist the urge to be backward looking when it comes to performance
Navigating your portfolio amid volatility
09/04/2015  Westpac's David Simon talks about rebalancing a portfolio as investors continue to confront a number of risks.
Identifying stocks that will beat the market
31/03/2015  Think risk assets deliver the greatest returns? A new paper dispels this myth and instead proves that the equities that deliver the greatest profit are the unpopular ones
Protect your portfolio from losses
25/03/2015  Risk is not volatility - risk is the potential an investor has for loss, says Oaktree's Howard Marks. Recognising this is the first step in protecting your portfolio from losing money.
Revisiting the sole purpose test
19/03/2015  It’s important that trustees are reminded about their obligations under the sole purpose test – a key requirement in SMSF compliance.
Macro trinity underpinning eurozone
12/03/2015  Three key forces have ensured strong growth from most European markets so far this year, explains Morningstar's Jose Garcia Zarate, but structural flaws still need to be addressed
Taxing times for trustees?
05/03/2015  The government may have moved to address the tax concessions into super but trustees face a number of potential taxing issues.
Trustees under the spotlight
--  SMSF Association’s Andrea Slattery talks about the growing professionalism of the industry and what it means for trustees.
An insight into 4 top managers
02/03/2015  Morningstar’s Tom Whitelaw outlines the qualities behind this year’s fund manager of the year awards.
1 top stock set to open doors
27/02/2015  Morningstar's Peter Warnes shares his thoughts on results from the likes of QBE, BHP, Ramsay Health Care and Woolworths as the curtains close on the half-year earnings season.
Telstra picks right man for top job
20/02/2015  Morningstar's Peter Warnes gives his take on the most recent batch of corporate earnings, while also sharing his views on the appointment to the top job at Telstra.
2 stocks in earnings sweet spot
13/02/2015  Morningstar's Peter Warnes takes a look at the latest results from two big names in healthcare, as well as earnings from CBA and Telstra.
A further rate cut?
11/02/2015  Further rate cuts are expected while the Australian dollar will remain overvalued, according to Ibbotson’s Brad Bugg.
What's in store for listed investments?
05/02/2015  While the growth in LICs is more cyclical, ETFs continue to develop from stronger structural growth.
Key issues for SMSFs
02/02/2015  A government inquiry and tax concessions are among the key issues confronting trustees.
Emerging supermarket competitors
22/01/2015  Recent increased sales numbers from global supermarket chain Aldi continues to add competitive pressure on Australia’s big players.
Top SMSF tips for 2015
21/01/2015  Keeping up-to-date on legislative changes, avoiding excess contributions and ensuring sufficient cash flow is in place are just some of the simple things trustees can do to get a better handle on their SMSF.
Overcoming home bias
15/01/2015  Beyond Australia's borders and within the global investment universe lies a much more diverse range of opportunities across multiple sectors.
3 investment ideas for 2015
09/01/2015  What are the key themes investors should be aware of over the next 12 months? We identify the red flags and opportunities facing investors in 2015
Get your game on with this stock pick
05/01/2015  Crown's long duration licenses will allow the casino operator to continue to earn returns above its cost of capital over the next decade and beyond.