Are all value managers the same?

Christine St Anne  |  09/11/2012Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  
Christine St Anne: Morningstar's Tom Whitelaw recently wrote a paper on fund managers who adopt the investment process value investing. He joins us today to give us an insight into what this process is and why all value fund managers are not necessarily the same. Tom, welcome.

Tom Whitelaw: Thank you.

St Anne: Tom, first of all, what is value investing?

Whitelaw: Value investing was popularized by Benjamin Graham, and then obviously taken forward by Warren Buffett, but really the premise has been around, since we've traded goods, essentially it's the desire to buy something for less than you believe it's worth. So, investors are talking about buying stocks for less than their intrinsic value and trying to get a good deal basically.

St Anne: So, Tom, are all value fund managers the same?

Whitelaw: No, I mean that's the thing. There is a number of different ways you can skin this cat. So, you've got the relative value guys, I suppose, and then the more sustainable value guys, if you want to put them into two broad buckets. The relative value guys; they're really looking for stocks that are cheap relative to history, so that are trading at a discount to what they've previously traded at or cheap within their own industry or sector, and maybe less bothered about fundamentals than maybe the sustainable value guys are.

The sustainable value guys are all about sum-of-the-parts. So they want strong management teams, they want strong franchise quality; those kind of attributes, but where those sum-of-the-parts aren't reflected in the overall valuation. So, somebody like Investors Mutual would be a key sustainable value manager we could say, whereas Perennial Value, for example, might be more in that relative value field.

St Anne: Tom, what are the typical value stocks and how did they perform?

Whitelaw: Well, again, typical value stocks, because there are different kinds of value managers, so the typical stocks can kind of cover a really broad spectrum, I suppose. So, you take the banks for example. I mean, most Australian investors will own some of the banks, so the relative value guys will be more interested in the likes of NAB or ANZ where there's kind of been problems with their growth. I guess the cynic would say the value stocks are growth stocks gone wrong, whereas as the sustainable value guys; they are more interested in the likes of Westpac or CBA, where again those kind of franchises are strong, they're kind of perceived to have stronger management teams, have had fewer missteps, but still they see that there's the pricing there that's kind of moving forward.

St Anne: Given that all value fund managers are not the same, Tom, what should investors look for when choosing a value manager?

Whitelaw: They really need to look for anything that they normally look for in a traditional manager. So, you talk about the people; so they want to have strong people, those managements have experience, have a strong team, and kind of really to understand the process that kind of moves on to process, making sure that the process they're using kind of fits with their strengths and that is going to be consistent. So an investor can look at a strategy, really understand how it's going to fit within their portfolio.

Then you move on to the parent company, so you want a parent company that really understands the managers that are working for them and he is able to support them, and he isn't going to have too much – too many demands on that time to go out marketing this product, for example.

Then price; I mean you want to make sure that you're paying a reasonable price for it. You don't want to overpay. And then I guess, finally, performance, kind of making sure that all of those four things we just discussed kind of bear out in the performance; so how is the performance you'd expect given the qualities that you perceive. And that's the job we do at Morningstar. We kind of pick those guys that we think are a good fit for your portfolio and then that they're going to outperform over time.

St Anne: Tom, thanks so much for your insights today.

Whitelaw: Thank you.

Video Archive...

Shifting fortunes for ANZ, more of the same for CBA in 2017
12/01/2017  Australian banks are well-positioned as they head into 2017, with ANZ moving from least profitable in 2016 to become one of the sector's top performers and CBA remaining an investor favourite.
Is Trump a threat to emerging markets?
12/01/2017  Is President Donald Trump a threat to emerging market returns? Paul Jackson from the UK-based Source ETF considers the outlook for sector and where investors can find the best opportunities.
Platinum, Aussie banks and Peter Warnes among top interviews of 2016
22/12/2016  We look back on some of our most notable interviews of the year, as Morningstar analysts and external experts helped us delve into some of the biggest events that shaped Australian and global markets in 2016.
Oil price finds sweet spot, while mining hits rock bottom
20/12/2016  The rise in oil prices should see improved performances from Australian producers in 2017, while mining services companies will continue to struggle amid weaker Chinese demand, says Morningstar equity analyst Mark Taylor.
How Greek mythology can make you a better investor
07/12/2016  Don't be over confident or follow the herd, and like Odysseus, learn to have yourself "tied to the mast" when it comes to long-term investing.
Supermarket headwinds prompt fair value cut for majors
06/12/2016  Growing competitive pressures and a declining revenue outlook for Australia's two grocery giants now look to be part of a longer-term, structural shift.
What returns should you expect from markets?
01/12/2016  As market risks rise, investors must adjust their profit expectations--gone are the days of 8 per cent returns. But there are still growth opportunities out there if you know where to look.
Why healthcare stocks got a bump from Trump
28/11/2016  Australian healthcare and pharmaceutical companies continue to enjoy a purple patch, and for various reasons including the recent US election result, explains Morningstar's healthcare equities analyst Chris Kallos.
Equity and hybrid investors react as bond prices tumble
24/11/2016  The negative correlation between bonds and equities is reasserting itself following the US election of Donald Trump, according to John Likos, Morningstar's senior credit analyst.
2 global themes that are finding favour among ETF investors
15/11/2016  Australian retail investors are increasingly turning to ETFs for specific tactical exposures to global themes, particularly in the context of large-scale market events such as US election 2016.
Maintain discipline and stick to fundamentals when selecting stocks
14/11/2016  Steer clear of fads, maintain a disciplined approach and focus on company fundamentals in building and maintaining your investment portfolio, says Anton Tagliaferro, investment director, Investors Mutual
How Trump could impact economic growth
10/11/2016  Slowdowns in trade and immigration could hold back the US, and infrastructure spending could boost GDP, but it's too early to make any major changes to our economic forecast, says Morningstar's Bob Johnson.
President Trump: What should you do?
10/11/2016  Donald Trump has beaten Hillary Clinton to become the 45th US president. What should investors do?
Software companies worth watching amid tech deployment phase
08/11/2016  Kate Howitt, portfolio manager at Fidelity International discusses some of the core phases in technological disruption and identifies software companies among those currently presenting opportunities.
Kerr Neilson hot, cold and tepid on Europe, US and China
07/11/2016  Platinum co-founder and CEO Kerr Neilson explains his views on the major global markets and outlines where he sees opportunities--and where he doesn't.
Is Inghams a moat-worthy investment?
02/11/2016  Morningstar's Ravi Reddy discusses the upcoming float of poultry product producer Inghams, and whether it's in investors' interests to subscribe for shares in the IPO.
3 best ideas in healthcare
26/10/2016  Morningstar's Chris Kallos looks at some of the most compelling ideas in Australian healthcare, while also reaffirming the importance of the uncertainty rating and how it pertains to the sector.
Exercise caution and let some cash build
24/10/2016  Morningstar's Peter Warnes provides a near-term outlook for equities markets, while also sharing his thoughts on the upcoming Ingham's IPO.
Bogle forecasts low stock and bond market returns
21/10/2016  Warning of "much lower market returns" ahead, Vanguard founder Jack Bogle urges investors to seek low-cost investment products. From Morningstar US.
Finding the right flavour ETF amid expanding ETP menu
13/10/2016  From a relatively vanilla selection of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) on offer in the early 2000s, Australian investors can now choose from a wide range of exchange-traded products to suit various tastes.