Bogle: Investing wins, speculation loses
Christine Benz  |  19/11/2012Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  

Christine Benz: Jack, I want segue and talk a little bit about your most recent book, The Clash of the Cultures, and the clash is between a long-term investment culture and one that is based on short-term speculation. Let's talk about how that culture clash unfolded. What has driven the increasing focus on more speculative styles of investing?

Jack Bogle: Well, first of all, it comes around I think by and large, the kind of thing we had in the late 1990s - the information age and all that kind of thing - where the price of the stock became more important than the intrinsic value of a company. And when you focus on prices and pretty much disregard intrinsic values, you are just gambling.

Will people take your stock from you at a higher price than you paid for it, or you are buying and hoping to sell at a higher price. That's kind of the spirit of the thing; that's where the turnover comes from. And it's very, very dangerous. Add to that, stock prices became especially important during the '80s when we had executive-compensation options and corporations were judging themselves on the price of the stock. And the security analysts were judging the price of the stock. They wanted a short-term earnings guidance, short-term quarterly guidance, or something. And it just gradually turned bigger and bigger, inflamed - if that's the right word and I think is - by the huge boom we had in the '80s and '90s. Stocks looked like easy street. There is no easy street. And so it all kind of accumulated to the point where speculation has crowded out a lot of investment.

One example I used in the book is, how do you measure this? Well, if you call investment fulfilling the basic function of the financial system, and that is directing capital to its highest and best uses, you're talking about money gets directed in new ventures, existing companies, innovative companies, whatever it might be. And that has been running about $250 billion a year. How do you measure speculation? [You do so] by the amount of trading that goes on in the market, and that's around $33 trillion a year. So, if you want to look at it hard-nosed, 99.2 per cent of what goes on in the market is speculation and 0.8 per cent is an investment in the stockmarket.

Benz: What in your view would reverse that trend toward speculation? What are some steps that could be taken?

Bogle: Well, first of all, there's a natural tendency for it to blow itself out. If we had good market decline, for example.

Benz: And we did.

Bogle: And we see some of it now. High-frequency trading is distinctly less now and then we'd have to have a big market blowout, of course. There are a number of other factors. [One is] waking up investors - speculators lose, investors win, by definition. I mean think of this example. There are 500 stocks in the S&P 500, and let's assume that half of the number of shares outstanding of each are owned by long-term investors who never trade. The other half is owned by speculators who trade with a frenzy. The investors by definition will capture the market return, investors as a group, and the speculators by definition will capture the market return, too, but only before deducting the cost of all that speculation.

So, it's a mathematical tautology that investing wins and speculating loses. And if we could ever get investors to focus on that simple fact, as Ben Graham said - he has got more good quotes, but I think this maybe his very best - in the short run the stockmarket is a voting machine, but in the long run the stock market is a weighing machine. We have to get back to that. And he was taking this on by the way because it was starting to happen when he was still alive. He died I think in 1949. And it was starting to happen even then, and he was criticizing all the institutional trading. He was talking about these institutions are great big laundries that take in each other's laundry every day and clean it up and send it out to somebody else. He was a wise man.

Video Archive...

1 top stock set to open doors
27/02/2015  Morningstar's Peter Warnes shares his thoughts on results from the likes of QBE, BHP, Ramsay Health Care and Woolworths as the curtains close on the half-year earnings season.
Telstra picks right man for top job
20/02/2015  Morningstar's Peter Warnes gives his take on the most recent batch of corporate earnings, while also sharing his views on the appointment to the top job at Telstra.
2 stocks in earnings sweet spot
13/02/2015  Morningstar's Peter Warnes takes a look at the latest results from two big names in healthcare, as well as earnings from CBA and Telstra.
A further rate cut?
11/02/2015  Further rate cuts are expected while the Australian dollar will remain overvalued, according to Ibbotson’s Brad Bugg.
What's in store for listed investments?
05/02/2015  While the growth in LICs is more cyclical, ETFs continue to develop from stronger structural growth.
Key issues for SMSFs
02/02/2015  A government inquiry and tax concessions are among the key issues confronting trustees.
Emerging supermarket competitors
22/01/2015  Recent increased sales numbers from global supermarket chain Aldi continues to add competitive pressure on Australia’s big players.
Top SMSF tips for 2015
21/01/2015  Keeping up-to-date on legislative changes, avoiding excess contributions and ensuring sufficient cash flow is in place are just some of the simple things trustees can do to get a better handle on their SMSF.
Overcoming home bias
15/01/2015  Beyond Australia's borders and within the global investment universe lies a much more diverse range of opportunities across multiple sectors.
3 investment ideas for 2015
09/01/2015  What are the key themes investors should be aware of over the next 12 months? We identify the red flags and opportunities facing investors in 2015
Get your game on with this stock pick
05/01/2015  Crown's long duration licenses will allow the casino operator to continue to earn returns above its cost of capital over the next decade and beyond.
Opportunities in internet stocks
23/12/2014  Focused on sustainable competitive advantages, Morningstar StockInvestor's Matt Coffina sees potential in a handful of Internet stocks today.
Market outlook for 2015
18/12/2014  Morningstar's Peter Warnes gives investors an idea of what to expect from the Australian share market over the coming year, while also providing some tips for a stronger portfolio.
Morningstar's new ETF ratings
10/12/2014  Morningstar’s Tim Murphy discusses the new ETF analyst ratings and reports that are now available to investors.
Top opportunities in hybrids
09/12/2014  After a recent broad widening in pricing, investors may find opportunities in some of the older-style bank notes and high-quality corporate issuers.
Iron ore's changing landscape
03/12/2014  With small, high-cost miners set to struggle, Chinese growth to flatten and the low-cost majors pushing hard on expansion, the face of iron-ore mining is set to look very different.
Will QE boost European stocks?
28/11/2014  As ECB members hint quantitative easing could come sooner than expected in the Eurozone, we examine the prospects for European stock markets. From Morningstar UK.
Quality stocks, sustainable yields
26/11/2014  Anton Tagliaferro of Investors Mutual shares his outlook for the market at last month's Morningstar Individual Investor Conference.
Key risks in bond investing
21/11/2014  There are a number of risks investors need to consider in bond investing.
Confronting volatility and low growth
18/11/2014  Given issues such as recent volatility, rising global debt levels and the threat of European deflation, there are steps investors can take to safeguard their portfolios.