Is the IMF wrong on banks?

Christine St Anne  |  22/11/2012Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  
Christine St Anne: The International Monetary Fund, or IMF, has recently called for greater controls on Australian Banks. Today I'm joined by Morningstar's David Ellis to discuss whether the IMF's concerns are justified. David welcome.

David Ellis: It's a pleasure, Christine.

St Anne: David, the IMF has called for banks to hold more capital. What is your view?

Ellis: Christine, I've got a very strong view and I think the IMF is wrong. I don't think the Australian Banks necessarily need to hold more capital for the reasons outlined by the IMF. Over the last three or four years, the four major Australian banks have increased their capital level significantly for a number of reasons, but the most important was getting over the global financial crisis particularly in 2008 and then in 2009.

The capital levels now are about 1.5 times higher than they were going into the GFC. The new capital global capital rules, applied from the 1st of January 2013, these are far stricter rules and the four major Australian banks have already exceeded the new minimum requirements and the bank regulator, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA), has required the four major Australian banks to be fully compliant on the 1 January 2013 rather than a staged process or a staged period running out for three or four years.

St Anne: David, do you think that banks should implement greater stress testing as suggested by the IMF?

Ellis: Well, the banks always, have always and continue to undertake stress tests. They have done this in conjunction with Australian Regulator, APRA, and they have the details of the testing as confidential, however, I would estimate that the stress testing has become tougher and tougher and more robust. So by itself I don't see a need to say that stress testing needs to be done by the Australian banks. They have always done stress testing. They will always continue to stress test their business models.

Of course, there is good reason to continue to make it tougher, this stress testing. So I don't disagree with the need to continue, but it's not something new. They've always done it. APRA is heavily involved in that process. I think it's an evolving concept that they will continue to do more sophisticated stress testing and that ultimately leads to better and stronger banks.

St Anne: The IMF has also suggested that banks share the cost of the government’s guarantee. Is that justified?

Ellis: Well, that's a tough one. I struggle with that. I think in the end, unfortunately, the consumer will pay, no matter whether the government forces a fee or a charge on to the Australia banks for providing the deposits or guarantee. If the Australian government does go down that path and does raise it, a fee, I would imagine that the banks would pass it through to consumers one way or the other. It may not be a specific standalone charge or fee, but the banks will recoup it from their consumers.
St Anne: Finally, David, do you think that the banks are well placed if we do have another market crisis?

Ellis: Well, the four major banks have never been in a stronger position. Never been in a stronger position. As I mentioned earlier, the capital levels are 50 per cent higher than they were pre-GFC. The funding and liquidity levels are significantly higher. The reliance on short-term wholesale funding has decreased.

Wholesale funding has become longer maturity term in wholesale funding. The proportion of customer deposits to total funding has increased. It's running now between 50 per cent and 60 per cent. So capital levels are higher. So obviously, there is no guarantee we won't have another global financial crisis, but the Australian banks are in a far stronger position. We say with increasing confidence and increasing certainty that the Australian banks, the four major banks will actually have a surplus of capital in maybe 12 to 18 months' time, and we believe that the four major banks will be returning surplus capital to shareholders in 12 to 18 months’ time, which is far, far, far different to the IMF’s position that the Australian banks need additional capitals also.

St Anne: David thanks so much for your insights today.

Ellis: It's a pleasure Christine.  

Video Archive...

Big bank dividends are sustainable
29/04/2016  Westpac, ANZ and National Australia Bank report half-year earnings in the week commencing 2 May and Morningstar's David Ellis gives investors a taste of what to expect.
Don't expect iron ore rally to continue
26/04/2016  Investors are underestimating how much steel demand could decline, says Morningstar's David Wang.
Japan running out of options to boost growth
26/04/2016  Japan's is into its second lost decade. Have central bankers run out of policy tools? JPMorgan's London-based Talib Sheikh says investors should be wary of further easing.
China businesses are unattractive to investors
20/04/2016  China may be the biggest player in the emerging market universe, but there are far more compelling investment opportunities in Africa and South America, according to a UK-based fund manager.
Where should you invest in Australian media?
15/04/2016  MandA fever may be building towards a "Groundhog Day" ahead of a potential relaxation of media ownership laws in Australia, as structural headwinds continue to intensify.
Where should you invest in Australian media?
15/04/2016  M&A fever may be building towards a "Groundhog Day" ahead of a potential relaxation of media ownership laws in Australia, as structural headwinds continue to intensify.
China's debt is not a problem
15/04/2016  The International Monetary Fund has expressed concerns about China's debt levels but Doug Turnbull of the UK-based Neptune Investment Management says the debt is concentrated and not a problem.
Value investing in a low growth environment
07/04/2016  Morningstar's Daniel Needham explains how to buy an equity or bond at less than its intrinsic worth in a world where the reward for risk investing is diminished.
5 demographic trends driving investment profit
06/04/2016  What is the influence of workers and consumers on stock markets? Dr Amlan Roy explains the implications for asset prices and capital flows, emerging markets and sustainability.
The Morningstar Economic Moat Rating
01/04/2016  The Morningstar Economic Moat Rating represents a company's sustainable competitive advantage. A company with an economic moat can fend off competition and earn high returns on capital for many years to come.
Why you should shun popular stocks
31/03/2016  Investors cannot all buy the same stock at the same price--popularity affects price and leads us to buy high and sell low, obliterating any profit we could have gained.
How to break from the crowd and be a successful investor
31/03/2016  Sir John Templeton stated that: "It is impossible to produce superior performance unless you do something different from the majority." James Montier from asset manager GMO explains how.
Is it too late to invest in Japanese equities?
22/03/2016  The easy money has already been made in Japan, the UK-based Polar Capital's James Salter says, but look for those cyclical stocks with depressed prices and you can still make a profit.
Don't lose the overconfidence game
22/03/2016  Investors who are overconfident in their abilities may trade more often and hurt themselves in the end, says UC Berkeley professor Terry Odean.
What's in store for Telstra shareholders?
18/03/2016  Morningstar's Brian Han talks investors through Telstra's half-year result and why the telecoms giant has been trailing the market since the start of 2016.
Preparing for lower long-term returns
10/03/2016  Investors may not be rewarded for risk-taking during the next several years, so they should tweak their spending and saving patterns instead, says US-based financial-planning expert Michael Kitces.
Hyperion named Fund Manager of the Year
07/03/2016  Hyperion Asset Management has received the top award as Morningstar's Australian Fund Manager of the Year.
Why you should not fear a US recession
03/03/2016  The S&P 500 is back into positive territory for the year, although losses in the UK and Europe are still in the high-single-digits, but investors should stay positive.
Are markets overreacting to China?
02/03/2016  Considering the global importance of China's economy, the country's troubled growth prospects are likely to weigh heavily on the world for years to come.
Earnings season better than expected
26/02/2016  Morningstar's Peter Warnes shares his views on the latest batch of results from the likes of QBE Insurance, BHP Billiton and Wesfarmers.