Earnings season winners and losers
Nicholas Grove  |  08/02/2013Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  

Nicholas Grove: This week saw the likes of Telstra, Cochlear and Transurban release their results for the first half of the 2013 financial year, while NAB and Macquarie provided first-quarter trading updates. Here to give investors an idea of which companies impressed and which did not, I'm joined by Morningstar head of equities research Peter Warnes.

Peter, thanks for joining us.

Peter Warnes: Thanks, Nick. It's always great to be here.

Grove: First of all, Peter, let's start with Telstra. Did the company deliver as you expected and were there any surprises, either positive or negative?

Warnes: No, Nick. Telstra delivered as expected and then reaffirmed guidance for the full year in all the benchmarks - in other words, in revenue, in EBITDA, and free cash flow, and also more importantly, the dividend. So, no surprises in terms of the result.

In terms of the operations, positive certainly in mobile - what the market expected. Another 607,000 mobiles added, 14.4 million mobiles in service. They continue to take market share. It is the growth engine of Telstra now. The negatives - and the market expect them and there is nothing to get worried about - were a 10.8 per cent fall in PSTN or the traditional fixed-line operations and Sensis was under some pressure, as was expected. But importantly for Telstra, we are now less than five months away from going into 2014 financial year and that should bring a higher dividend, paying $0.28 currently. We expect it to move to $0.30, maybe $0.31 for FY14.

Grove: Peter, moving on to NAB and Macquarie, was there anything in their quarterly updates that caught your eye or was a cause for concern?

Warnes: Nick, NAB was a relief, if you like, given the bad news that came out on their downgrades earlier. Lower bad debts obviously helped good cost control. Their Australian franchise is still doing very well. I'd love to see the exit of the UK, but that probably will take a little time, but no, overall, positive from the NAB, looking like a $6-billion impact for the full year. So, no, we're comfortable there.

In terms of Macquarie, it's a little disappointing that the guidance came in at a 10 per cent increase year-over-year for their FY13 number. That was below consensus and that's not surprising given that we're going through some pretty ordinary conditions, particularly in the market-facing operations, albeit that they are improving.

And so, I would say to you that probably the worst is over for Macquarie Bank. The engine room, if you like, of their operation is the asset management and funds management operation, which is annuities-style income. That's going very well, but the market-facing operations are where you do get some leverage. So, Macquarie Equities and some M&A, they could now start really kicking some goals as the equity markets move higher. So, I'm expecting a better fourth quarter - in other words, the March quarter, which finishes the year, has some nice tailwinds.

Grove: Peter, what did you think of the results from Cochlear and Transurban, and do you have any concerns about these businesses?

Warnes: Two very, very distinctly different businesses there. Cochlear - again, it was disappointing, and mind you, the stock has had a very, very big run through the $80 mark. The disappointment was that it appears they have lost market share in the non-Chinese or excluding Chinese sales, so in the sales to the US, Europe and the rest of the world, which have much more higher margin than the Chinese sales, they seem to have lost market share. And don't forget, they are coming off a comparative period last year where there was a major recall that cost them about $130 million. That's where the market did have some concern. I would suspect that it's only of a short-term nature. The aggressive R&D is important, and I think that you'll see more innovation, more new products come on there, and we are not concerned about the long term for Cochlear overall. It's basically an immature market that still got a plenty of growth.

Transurban - the result was in line with expectations, there's nothing surprising, a couple of positives and a couple of negatives, and negatives were what was happening in the Sydney market, if you like, M2 and M5 upgrades, car parks rather than freeways, and so, therefore, the revenue was under pressure there, albeit that there was some price rises or toll increases offsetting that. Melbourne CityLink helped and they got some upgrades there in terms of both volume and some toll increases.

In the US, there are a couple of problems there that, albeit in terms of the portfolio were small, but niggling. The upgrade of the 495 Express Lanes isn't working and looks like it could have to be written down to zero. That's coming off the back of a disappointing investment in Pocahontas. And if you get a couple of those things back-to-back, the market might say: "Well, this is what you are doing." So, look, we're comfortable with Transurban. The free cash flow is still not covering the distribution, albeit, only by a small margin, but we're still okay.

Grove: Finally, Peter, earnings season can be an overwhelming time for investors as they feel like they are bombarded with information from all sides. What do you think is the most important thing investors should keep front of mind so that cooler heads prevail?

Warnes: It's a good question, Nick. They'll get bombarded and the analysts get bombarded as well. So, my advice to both the analysts and to the investor is try to keep a cool head and don't panic. Figure out why you bought the stock - why is it in your portfolio, and look at the reports that are coming at you, and say with a cool and calm demeanor, say, "Is it doing what I expected it to do?" If it is, don't worry about it. If it's not, then dig deeper. So, in the cool climate, no panic, sit back and say, "Do I stay with that stock, because it's not delivering what I expected it to do? That's the reason I bought it - should I exit?"

It's a good time to have a look at the portfolio and say: "Do I need to do anything with it?" And if you do, do it with the equipment, that is, the result just fresh in your mind. So, don't panic, look at it in a relaxed manner and maybe do some tidying up. Leave the winners - the good ones. Leave them alone, you don't have to worry about them. If they're delivering, leave them alone. Just be concerned about the ones that aren't matching what you expect them to do.

Grove: Peter, thanks very much for your time today.

Warnes: Pleasure Nick.

Video Archive...

5 big market themes
30/06/2015  Investors should watch the velocity of rate increases, keep Greece in perspective, and mind diversification in a world with very few good values.
Where are the new global opportunities?
29/06/2015  Global fund managers discuss emerging opportunities beyond the local market.
3 key risks for retirees
24/06/2015  Accurium SMSF technical services manager Melanie Dunn discusses three factors trustees should be aware of as they move from the accumulation to the retirement phase.
What the Greek crisis means for investors
22/06/2015  With most of the debt now being held by institutions, contagion is no longer a concern, says Morningstar's Bob Johnson.
5 questions for a top bond manager
17/06/2015  PIMCO’s Rob Mead discusses interest rates, the global economy and where the best opportunities are over the next 12 months.
4 keys to fixed-income investing
16/06/2015  Morningstar's John Likos scrutinises the risks that hybrids, bonds and other forms of credit carry and suggest ways in which investors can choose quality assets.
Grading the fund investor experience
09/06/2015  Morningstar’s Anthony Serhan takes a look at the experiences of fund investors around the world.
Understanding valuation risk
09/06/2015  Morningstar Investment Management's Chris Galloway discusses the important role annuities can play within a portfolio, as well as the key risk faced by all investors.
Big banks: As good as it gets?
--  Perpetual's Paul Skamvougeras maintains his view on being underweight the banks while favouring stocks with sound balance sheets and good management.
Uncovering quality undervalued stocks
03/06/2015  Companies with sustainable earnings can still be found despite an expensive market, according to Ausbil’s Paul Xiradis.
Seeking income and growth
29/05/2015  Cash generating stocks with a focus on creating shareholder value can be found across the global universe.
Where are the best global opportunities?
29/05/2015  Platinum’s Andrew Clifford discusses where he is finding well-priced opportunities in the global markets.
Good values are harder to find
28/05/2015  A run-up in European stocks has left the region moderately overvalued, while Asia market valuations are even more stretched; according to Morningstar's fair value metrics.
A stock with a unique growth opportunity
25/05/2015  The largest law firm in Australia provides a good investment opportunity for long-term investors.
Growth prospects in emerging markets
20/05/2015  Emerging market guru Mark Mobius talks about bull markets and viable growth opportunities at the recent Morningstar Investment Conference in the UK.
Be selective, exercise caution
18/05/2015  While value may not seem to be in abundance there are still opportunities to be found in the local market, as Morningstar's Peter Warnes explains.
A better deal for retail investors
14/05/2015  Enduring dividend imputation is not abolished and fairer capital raisings are among the items on the policy agenda for the Australian Shareholders’ Association.
The growth outlook for Wesfarmers
11/05/2015  Wesfarmers' Richard Goyder talks about managing a diverse business and the growing number of "serious players" in the supermarket sector.
Big bank earnings wrap
08/05/2015  Morningstar's David Ellis gives investors the lowdown on the half-year results from Westpac, ANZ and NAB, as well as his view on CBA's trading update.
Where Buffett sees value
06/05/2015  Morningstar's Matt Coffina discusses Buffett's view of stock valuations, cost-cutting, and more while attending the recent Berkshire Hathaway annual general meeting.