Are we heading for another recession?

Emma Wall  |  21/06/2016Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  

Emma Wall: Hello, and welcome to the Morningstar series "Why should I invest with you?" I'm Emma Wall and I'm joined today by Marcus Brookes, head of multi-manager for Schroders.

Hello, Marcus.

Marcus Brookes: Hi.

Wall: So, a bit of bad news today. I have been hearing from many multi managers, multi-asset managers, like yourself, that actually the good times are over. The significant rallies that we've seen across numerous asset classes over the last five years are no more and we should be moving into gold and cash and sort of hunkering down. What's your position on that?

Brookes: It may seem a bit dull, but I have to say I agree with a large part of that. I mean, if you just look at the S&P 500, the US stock market started rallying March 2009. All the way through today it has done really, really well, so over 300 per cent. And it's the second longest bull market in history. Now, you could say, well, so what? Why can't it be the longest? Why can't it do even more from here?

But we're now at a stage where the economic tailwinds that that economy has had is starting to fade slightly. That doesn't mean that we go into recession straightaway, but it does mean that all the really, really good stuff that helped corporates make excessive profits, they are starting to wane and as a result, you've got what appears to be relatively expensive market at peak profitability where everyone is fully invested, it's really hard to see how it makes progress from here.

Wall: It's quite difficult to call though market timing, isn't it? Because I know that a number of managers, very successful long-term managers, made the call too early around 2010-2011 and actually missed out on a rally. So, I can understand how investors might be quite nervous about doing that again.

Brookes: Yeah. Well, I think actually when we look back in history, the 2009 through to 2011 was actually probably a full market cycle in its own right because the rebound at that stage was led by value sectors that we would describe today, mining, energy companies and to a degree the victims of the great financial crisis, the financials, the banks in particular. And then from 2011 onwards, it's been a totally different profile. So, all the emerging market type names, the energy companies and the mining, they've had a dreadful, dreadful time since 2011.

So, I would almost define there's two different market moves; the first one, the recovery; the second one, the maturation of the market cycle, which this time is not being led by really cyclical value things. It's being led by super safe stuff and this is really bizarre. It's not like we're saying, oh, well, you know, the economy is doing fantastically well; consumers are making more money, they are spending more money; they're going and buying new cars. Those are not the sort of companies are benefiting from those sort of trends. The sort of companies that are doing well are pharmaceuticals, utilities, tobacco ...

Wall: Defensive stocks.

Brookes: ... defensive stocks. So, I think when you can characterise the last seven years, two stages, the second stage is really being a bull market in safety because I don't think we have really got over the great financial crisis. I don't think the enormous levels of debt that led to it ever really got taken away and therefore, the sort of slight recovery is where we all hoped that this was a return to trend economic growth that then disappointed and then we all thought, oh, my gosh, it's going to be another great financial crisis. And through that phase I think investors thought, well, if I've got to be invested in anything, I want to be invested in safe stuff and if you get enough people doing the same thing, those are the assets that do really well.

Wall: Now, the problem is, those assets have now become extremely expensive. So, how do you manage both that cautious stance with diversification?

Brookes: Well, this is where all gets really tough now. So, if you were to suggest that we're towards the end, we're late cycle, we're towards the end of an economic cycle that we may be somewhere near therefore the end of a market cycle. The sort of portfolio you would traditionally have would be to start going by those dull, sensible utilities; tobaccos, pharmaceuticals.

But as you say, that is now a very expensive part of the market. So, we got a quandary as all investors that the safe stuff is actually pretty expensive. Now the risky stuff historically, mining, energy, financial, is the stuff that you would absolutely avoid, at this point, looks outstandingly cheap. To the degree you could base a case--now I wouldn't necessarily want to be too firm about this--but you could base a case that because they are under-owned because they are so cheap even if the bad stuff does happen, they could be okay this time. They may not necessarily make you money, but they could outperform the safe stuff. Now, that could be a very weird outcome for a lot of investors. I don't think they are positioned for that at all.

Wall: Marcus, thank you very much.

Brookes: Thank you very much.

Wall: This is Emma Wall for Morningstar. Thank you for watching.

Video Archive...

Shifting fortunes for ANZ, more of the same for CBA in 2017
12/01/2017  Australian banks are well-positioned as they head into 2017, with ANZ moving from least profitable in 2016 to become one of the sector's top performers and CBA remaining an investor favourite.
Is Trump a threat to emerging markets?
12/01/2017  Is President Donald Trump a threat to emerging market returns? Paul Jackson from the UK-based Source ETF considers the outlook for sector and where investors can find the best opportunities.
Platinum, Aussie banks and Peter Warnes among top interviews of 2016
22/12/2016  We look back on some of our most notable interviews of the year, as Morningstar analysts and external experts helped us delve into some of the biggest events that shaped Australian and global markets in 2016.
Oil price finds sweet spot, while mining hits rock bottom
20/12/2016  The rise in oil prices should see improved performances from Australian producers in 2017, while mining services companies will continue to struggle amid weaker Chinese demand, says Morningstar equity analyst Mark Taylor.
How Greek mythology can make you a better investor
07/12/2016  Don't be over confident or follow the herd, and like Odysseus, learn to have yourself "tied to the mast" when it comes to long-term investing.
Supermarket headwinds prompt fair value cut for majors
06/12/2016  Growing competitive pressures and a declining revenue outlook for Australia's two grocery giants now look to be part of a longer-term, structural shift.
What returns should you expect from markets?
01/12/2016  As market risks rise, investors must adjust their profit expectations--gone are the days of 8 per cent returns. But there are still growth opportunities out there if you know where to look.
Why healthcare stocks got a bump from Trump
28/11/2016  Australian healthcare and pharmaceutical companies continue to enjoy a purple patch, and for various reasons including the recent US election result, explains Morningstar's healthcare equities analyst Chris Kallos.
Equity and hybrid investors react as bond prices tumble
24/11/2016  The negative correlation between bonds and equities is reasserting itself following the US election of Donald Trump, according to John Likos, Morningstar's senior credit analyst.
2 global themes that are finding favour among ETF investors
15/11/2016  Australian retail investors are increasingly turning to ETFs for specific tactical exposures to global themes, particularly in the context of large-scale market events such as US election 2016.
Maintain discipline and stick to fundamentals when selecting stocks
14/11/2016  Steer clear of fads, maintain a disciplined approach and focus on company fundamentals in building and maintaining your investment portfolio, says Anton Tagliaferro, investment director, Investors Mutual
How Trump could impact economic growth
10/11/2016  Slowdowns in trade and immigration could hold back the US, and infrastructure spending could boost GDP, but it's too early to make any major changes to our economic forecast, says Morningstar's Bob Johnson.
President Trump: What should you do?
10/11/2016  Donald Trump has beaten Hillary Clinton to become the 45th US president. What should investors do?
Software companies worth watching amid tech deployment phase
08/11/2016  Kate Howitt, portfolio manager at Fidelity International discusses some of the core phases in technological disruption and identifies software companies among those currently presenting opportunities.
Kerr Neilson hot, cold and tepid on Europe, US and China
07/11/2016  Platinum co-founder and CEO Kerr Neilson explains his views on the major global markets and outlines where he sees opportunities--and where he doesn't.
Is Inghams a moat-worthy investment?
02/11/2016  Morningstar's Ravi Reddy discusses the upcoming float of poultry product producer Inghams, and whether it's in investors' interests to subscribe for shares in the IPO.
3 best ideas in healthcare
26/10/2016  Morningstar's Chris Kallos looks at some of the most compelling ideas in Australian healthcare, while also reaffirming the importance of the uncertainty rating and how it pertains to the sector.
Exercise caution and let some cash build
24/10/2016  Morningstar's Peter Warnes provides a near-term outlook for equities markets, while also sharing his thoughts on the upcoming Ingham's IPO.
Bogle forecasts low stock and bond market returns
21/10/2016  Warning of "much lower market returns" ahead, Vanguard founder Jack Bogle urges investors to seek low-cost investment products. From Morningstar US.
Finding the right flavour ETF amid expanding ETP menu
13/10/2016  From a relatively vanilla selection of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) on offer in the early 2000s, Australian investors can now choose from a wide range of exchange-traded products to suit various tastes.