Are term deposits risky?
Christine St Anne  |  30/11/2012Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  

Christine St Anne: It's not surprising that many investors flocked to term deposits during the global financial crisis, given their perceived safety. But how safe are these assets? Today I am joined by Ibbotson's Brad Bugg to discuss the volatility behind term deposits. Brad, welcome.

Brad Bugg: Nice to be here.

St Anne: Brad, term deposits are perceived as safe assets. Are they actually more volatile than investors think?

Bugg: Well, I think, from a risk perspective, term deposits have done a very good job of preserving your capital, and post the GFC I think that has been the number one concern of investors.

But one thing I think they have ignored is the volatility of the income, which comes from a term deposit. We are at now in an environment where the RBA is starting to cut the cash rate, and as a consequence the banks are starting to bring those term deposit rates down. The RBA has cut cash rates by 1 per cent over the last 12 months and term deposits have come down to a similar degree.

So, investors who were investing in term deposit 12 months ago, the income which they are going to get from the new term deposit could be anywhere from 20 per cent lower to a third lower. So, we think that's a big risk for pensioners who are relying on that income to survive.

St Anne: You mentioned the volatility of income, are there any other risks behind term deposits?

Bugg: I think one of the biggest risk is complacency. In 2007 investors could get term deposit rates of 7 per cent to 8 per cent, and they could lock that in for five years. So, that was an easy decision for investors because it gives you that capital preservation and the nice income going forward. But now sort of we are in a period where sort of term deposit rates are quite low and people have gone back to term deposits because they've given the outcomes that they wanted in the past, but that's meant they've ignored some good opportunities where they could have protected their capital, but still get a better return and from that you could have look to Australian or global government bonds, for instance, which gave you a return of more than 10 per cent over the last 12 months.

So, I think, there is that complacency that people go back to what they know, but there are other opportunities that they are missing out on. So, we think investors need to take a more dynamic approach where they look to vary their allocation to different assets, depending on the opportunities that are present at the time.

St Anne: So, how does the risks behind term deposits impact the retirement plans for investors?

Bugg: Well, retirees look to the income that's coming from these term deposits to pay the bills whether to pay the water bill, the utility bill. These bills are going up at some quite alarming rate in many instances. And with reinvestment of term deposits probably for the last 12 to 18 months, each time they've rolled over term deposit they've been getting lower income from that term deposit.

So, just to give you an example, Westpac offered a five-year term deposit at 8 per cent many years ago. Had you locked that in that would be fantastic, but now you are looking at rolling that term deposit over in a couple of years time at a rate which could be half that. So, if for instance you had all your money in that, you are going to see the income that you rely on to live halved, which I don't think is an outcome a pensioner would look to.

St Anne: Brad, you mentioned bonds, what other assets can investors look at besides term deposits and bonds that can give them some sense of capital protection?

Bugg: Well, I think, term deposits have been very good from that perspective in protecting investor capital. Bonds have also done a good job in a falling interest rate environment, and we don't think that's going to be the case going forward.

So, we look to just plain vanilla cash, having money in the bank account because that does preserve your capital, but it also gives you that flexibility to capitalize on opportunities should other assets fall and start to present some interesting valuation.

So, we think that sort of cash gives you a good option value which you are not getting with term deposits because your money is locked up for the life of that term deposit.

St Anne: Brad, so ultimately is there a role for term deposits?

Bugg: I think so, because term deposits do give you a certainty of income, but we wouldn't recommend that you have all your investments in term deposits. We recommend sort of having a diversified portfolio and varying those allocations over time, and having the biggest allocations to those assets which give you the best reward for your risk, and at the moment West is starting to see the reward for risk portfolio from term deposit being not as advantageous as some other asset classes out there at the moment.

St Anne: Brad, thanks so much for your time today.

Bugg: Not a problem.

Video Archive...

Protect your portfolio from losses
25/03/2015  Risk is not volatility - risk is the potential an investor has for loss, says Oaktree's Howard Marks. Recognising this is the first step in protecting your portfolio from losing money.
Macro trinity underpinning eurozone
12/03/2015  Three key forces have ensured strong growth from most European markets so far this year, explains Morningstar's Jose Garcia Zarate, but structural flaws still need to be addressed
An insight into 4 top managers
02/03/2015  Morningstar’s Tom Whitelaw outlines the qualities behind this year’s fund manager of the year awards.
A further rate cut?
11/02/2015  Further rate cuts are expected while the Australian dollar will remain overvalued, according to Ibbotson’s Brad Bugg.
Emerging supermarket competitors
22/01/2015  Recent increased sales numbers from global supermarket chain Aldi continues to add competitive pressure on Australia’s big players.
Overcoming home bias
15/01/2015  Beyond Australia's borders and within the global investment universe lies a much more diverse range of opportunities across multiple sectors.
3 investment ideas for 2015
09/01/2015  What are the key themes investors should be aware of over the next 12 months? We identify the red flags and opportunities facing investors in 2015
Will QE boost European stocks?
28/11/2014  As ECB members hint quantitative easing could come sooner than expected in the Eurozone, we examine the prospects for European stock markets. From Morningstar UK.
Quality stocks, sustainable yields
26/11/2014  Anton Tagliaferro of Investors Mutual shares his outlook for the market at last month's Morningstar Individual Investor Conference.
Key risks in bond investing
21/11/2014  There are a number of risks investors need to consider in bond investing.
Confronting volatility and low growth
18/11/2014  Given issues such as recent volatility, rising global debt levels and the threat of European deflation, there are steps investors can take to safeguard their portfolios.
Opportunities in fixed income
28/10/2014   Bentham Asset Management principal and portfolio manager Richard Quin provides investors with some insights into fixed-income investment and the role that short-duration credit can play in a portfolio.
Key investor risks
21/10/2014  Voted among the 50 most influential people in finance today, author and former banker Satyajit
Finding value in small companies
14/10/2014  A portfolio of "terrific value" can still be achieved despite the stretched valuations in the smaller end of the Australian equities market.
Choosing quality businesses
07/10/2014  Credit investors adopt a different approach to equity investors when assessing a quality business, according to PIMCO's Tracy Chin.
Don't panic about PIMCO
30/09/2014  Morningstar's Tim Murphy talks about the recent portfolio manager changes at the global bond manager and why investors should not panic.
A better deal for investors
24/09/2014  Morningstar’s Anthony Serhan outlines what the government’s Financial System Inquiry will mean for investors.
Europe growth: Gone for good?
18/09/2014  Facing entrenched structural issues, the eurozone’s days of robust growth are likely over, but there are some reasons for hope, says Morningstar's Bob Johnson.
Will the ECB cuts boost growth in Europe?
09/09/2014  The European Central Bank (ECB) has taken measures to ward off deflation and boost growth in the eurozone. Will these interest rate cuts be effective?
How diversified is your portfolio?
31/07/2014  Morningstar’s Tim Murphy talks about an effective investment tool that helps investors achieve a diversified portfolio.
Seeking small-cap opportunities
30/07/2014  Morningstar's Tom Whitelaw shares some insights gained from recent talks with small-cap fund managers and provides some tips for those looking to increase their exposure to the smaller end of the market.
Key insights into quality stock-pickers
31/07/2014  Morningstar’s Julian Robertson talks about recent research into Australian large-cap managers and how some quality managers are approaching the market.
Quality emerging-markets investments
25/06/2014  Morningstar fund research analyst Alex Prineas equips investors with what they need to know when it comes to getting quality exposure to emerging markets.
Quality emerging-markets investments
25/06/2014  Morningstar fund research analyst Alex Prineas equips investors with what they need to know when it comes to getting quality exposure to emerging markets.
Giving investors access to the world
19/06/2014  By investing in companies outside the banking and resources sector, investors can get a diversified portfolio that will perform across a variety of market cycles.
Emerging investment opportunities
16/06/2014  Ibbotson’s Daniel Needham talks about the need to confront existing investment thinking in order to improve investment outcomes for investors.
Reliable growth from property
04/06/2014  AMP Capital's Wholesale Australian Property Fund aims to provide SMSF trustees with both reliable income and some steady capital growth.
Finding value in a bull market
29/05/2014  Perpetual’s Matt Williams talks about where he is finding the opportunities and the growth outlook for the market.
Top portfolio tilts
28/05/2014  Portfolio manager John Grace discusses some of the exposures and opportunities the Ausbil Australian Active Equity Fund can offer investors.
Reflections of a former central banker
23/05/2014  Former RBA governor shares his views on China and how central bankers have influenced global markets.
Making money with microcaps
13/05/2014  Microequities Asset Management's Carlos Gill explains how quality microcap stocks can offer investors compelling long-term investment returns.
Don't forget diversification
30/04/2014  Ibbotson Associates' Chris Galloway explores one of the key risks faced by investors and suggests some asset classes that offer some fundamental diversification.
Increasing income from property
16/04/2014  While they may not be front of mind for many investors, there are smaller Australian property players that can provide both a quality asset and a high yield.
Stellar returns for the long term
06/03/2014  Perpetual chief executive Geoff Lloyd talks about the competitive advantage behind the company’s unrivalled performance and the transformation of the business.
Finding value in small companies
03/02/2014  Morningstar's Tom Whitelaw gives us an insight into where managers are seeing value based on the latest Australian Small Companies Sector report.
Picking the right stocks
30/01/2014  NovaPort Capital's Sinclair Currie offers investors some insights into his team's stock-picking process.
Investment prospects in 2014
16/01/2013  Ibbotson Associates' Brad Bugg outlines what investors should expect in 2014 and which markets he thinks present the best opportunities.
Is cash the current king?
13/12/2013  Ibbotson Associates Australia managing director Chris Galloway gives investors his ideas on how portfolios should be positioned as we head into 2014.
4 behavioural traits of investors
10/12/2013  There is a psychological aspect to decision-making and that makes us in some ways deviate from rational decision-making, according to Vanguard's Stephen Utkus.
Insights from a top manager
03/12/2013  Perpetual's Nathan Parkin shares his insights into how the fund manager has been able to achieve a strong track record and prospects in a "frothy market".
What have we learned in 2013?
05/11/2013  Westpac’s David Simon gives us an insight into what investors have learned this year.
Market returns and volatility
24/10/2013  Morningstar’s Julian Robertson looks at how market volatility has impacted the global markets.
How do equity-income funds stack up?
21/10/2013  Morningstar's Kathryn Young explores whether income funds have delivered the juice on income for investors following the release of our Australian Large Companies Sector Wrap-Up.
5 lessons for investors
--  Morningstar CEO Anthony Serhan previews the upcoming Morningstar Individual Investor Conference and discusses key themes that will help investors build a winning portfolio.
Assessing active share managers
11/10/2013  Research manager Tom Whitelaw shares some insights, changes and discoveries from Morningstar's Australian Large Companies Sector Wrap-Up.
A closer look at investor flows
25/09/2013  Investors have been largely favouring international equities while bond funds experienced outflows, according to the latest Morningstar report on asset flows.
Morningstar's fund research process
06/09/2013  Morningstar’s Tim Murphy provides an overview of our approach to fund research.
China's risky rebalancing act
26/08/2013  The investment-led economic model has run so long in China that transitioning to a consumption model could be very risky, says Morningstar analyst Dan Rohr.
What the election means for super
19/08/2013  Although no changes are mooted, superannuation remains a key policy battleground for both the major parties.
3 market headwinds
12/08/2013  Advance Asset Management's Felix Stephen outlines key market themes that will impact the way people manage their money.
Market outlook remains shaky
01/08/2013  Investors still confront volatile markets but the birth of a prince offers some market cheer, according to the latest economic update.
How have Australian shares performed?
30/07/2013  A recent joint survey by Russell and the Australian Securities Exchange looked at the performance of Australian shares over the long-term.
Moving back into the market
18/07/2013  As more investors re-enter the market, Westpac’s David Simon urges caution and says investors to understand their risk appetite.
A wider growth perspective
16/07/2013  Fidelity manager Steve Wymer makes the growth case for some well-known companies.
What is value investing?
11/07/2013  Morningstar's Daniel Needham explains how investors can use a value strategy to dictate their asset allocation over time
Navigating the volatile markets
08/07/2013  The markets remain challenging for investors but there are some glimmers of hope, according to Morningstar’s latest economic update.
Where investors are putting their money
25/06/2013  Morningstar's latest quarterly report on asset flows highlights the types of funds that are attracting investor attention.
Last minute tax tips
20/06/2013  There are still a number of strategies that you can use to maximise your income and minimise your tax as the end of June draws closer.
Outperforming equities
14/06/2013  Investors need to shift their focus overseas as global equities continue to outperform Australian equities.
Strengthening your portfolio's defences
07/06/2013  Ibbotson Associates' Brad Bugg gives investors an idea of what to expect from markets in fiscal 2014 and where he thinks the best income opportunities will come from.
Finding growth in Australian equities
31/05/2013  Good quality companies can still grow in the current market, according to Fidelity’s Paul Taylor.
Fixed income in a falling interest rate market
20/05/2013  What opportunities are there in fixed income as interest rates in Australia continue to ease?
Boosting super contributions
30/04/2013  Investors can look at a number of strategies to boost their superannuation contributions prior to June 2013.
Gearing strategies in the new world
23/04/2013  A prudent approach to gearing strategies can enhance portfolio returns in a post-GFC world.
Outperforming global equities
11/04/2013  Global companies offer investors a number of high-growth prospects but it is important to be selective.
Top-performing global equity managers
04/04/2013  Morningstar’s latest international equities wrap-up has found a number of fund managers who have outperformed the global market.
Rethinking income needs
26/03/2013  Income remains a big focus for retirees, but many remain invested in conservative portfolios with minimum returns.
Finding value in fixed income
22/03/2013  Despite a low-yield environment there is still value to be found in fixed income, with bonds playing an important role in an investor's portfolio.
Getting income from equity funds
20/03/2013  A number of equity funds are using derivatives to boost the income in their portfolio. Morningstar’s Tom Whitelaw explains what investors need to look for when choosing these funds.
Investing beyond banks and resources
15/03/2013  Hyperion Asset Management's equities portfolio has delivered stellar returns despite its lack of exposure to the mining and banking sectors.
An insight into Perpetual Investments: Fund Manager of the Year
05/03/2013  Perpetual’s Charlie Lanchester offers us an insight into the investment processes behind Morningstar’s Fund Manager of the Year.
5 challenges for the eurozone
22/02/2013  Despite the optimism following the European Central Bank’s decision to do "whatever it takes" to preserve the eurozone, key issues remain over the economic and structural reform challenges facing the region.
Cash loses shine against growth assets
11/02/2013  Analysis from Russell Investments has found that growth assets recovered in 2012, outperforming cash.
Introducing the Morningstar Awards 2013
07/02/2013  We take a closer look at the Morningstar Awards 2013 and what it takes to be a good fund manager.
A closer look at your super
31/01/2013  Morningstar's Darren Cunneen explains how the various investment options of superannuation funds meet the different risk profiles of an investor.
Managed funds bounce back
25/01/2013  Morningstar’s latest managed funds survey has found that fund managers ended 2012 with healthy returns.
Navigating the fixed-income maze
24/01/2013  With rates expected to ease, fixed-income managers are expecting greater inflows from investors. However, investors are faced with a plethora of choices when it comes to fixed-interest.
Bankers and miners under pressure
16/01/2013  Miners and bankers will face a challenging year, however, there are emerging opportunities in other sectors of the Australian economy.
Making cash work for you
12/12/2012  There are a number of strategies investors can use within their cash portfolio despite falling cash rates.
Is it time for a portfolio review?
05/12/2012  As the year comes to the end, it may be time for investors to rethink their investment objectives and their portfolio.
Are term deposits risky?
30/11/2012  As term deposits purchased during their peak of 2008 mature, investors are discovering these investments are far from perfect.
Getting back into the market
27/11/2012  As the year draws to a close and interest rates continue to fall, it may be time for investors to move out of cash and back into the market.
Bogle: Investing wins, speculation loses
19/11/2012  Speculation continues to dominate stockmarket activity, but investors need to wake up to the long-term consequences, says Vanguard's founder. From Morningstar US.
Are all value managers the same?
09/11/2012  Morningstar's Tom Whitelaw discusses the reasons behind the significant divergences in the returns of value-style Australian share funds in recent years.
Bogle: Most difficult investment conditions I've ever seen
06/11/2012  The Vanguard founder says the kind of returns we've gotten in the past are not going to happen - period. From Morningstar US.
Bogle's outlook for the market
01/11/2012  The Vanguard founder expects muted returns of less than 5 per cent for stocks and 0 per cent for bonds after inflation. From Morningstar US.
Mining tax deceitful: Hockey
26/10/2012  Shadow treasurer Joe Hockey has labelled the mining tax deceitful following allegations that the tax will generate no revenue.
Does being ethical give you good returns?
15/10/2012  Ethical investing may sound like a ‘feel good’ strategy but does this approach deliver investment returns?
How are managed funds tracking?
09/10/2012  Morningstar’s quarterly report on Australian asset flows highlights which funds are getting the inflows and which funds are being hit by outflows.
Getting income investing right
05/10/2012  Income is a critical component in an investment portfolio but investors need to consider other aspects such as growth and inflation protection.
Overcoming a ‘star culture’ in funds management
03/10/2012  Morningstar’s Darren Cunneen discusses key person risk in managed funds and how it can be managed.
Understanding infrastructure investing
28/09/2012  Morningstar’s Kathryn Young looks at the income characteristics in global infrastructure and whether it can play a defensive role in a portfolio.
Looking at the impact of recent policy measures
26/09/2012  Policymakers have recently announced a number of big initiatives but what does this mean for markets around the world?
I'm a China optimist: Swan
21/09/2012  There are plenty of reasons to be optimistic about China’s future, according to Federal Treasurer Wayne Swan.
6 biases of fund investing
20/09/2012  Investors can often allow their emotions to dictate their investment decisions. Morningstar’s Darren Cunneen outlines six common pitfalls in behavioural investing and some handy sidestepping tips.
Investor sentiment improving
12/09/2012  Chief investment officers see a brighter outlook for markets but China remains a key concern.
Active, passive, or both?
05/09/2012  A successful portfolio might include components of both indexing and active fund management, which is what local investors may take away from this interview from Morningstar US.
The case for economic rebalancing
30/08/2012  Investors need to look at allocating more of their portfolio to emerging markets.
Top client concerns about the market
28/08/2012  Westpac’s David Simon talks about how his clients are grappling with the market and what it means for their portfolio.
Overcoming a concentrated portfolio
22/08/2012  A portfolio that is not sufficiently diversified could lead to inappropriate asset allocation decisions.
Emerging risks in the new financial year II
03/08/2012  In the second part of our market insight series, Bell Direct's Julia Lee gives us her views on the financial year ahead.
Good resource prospects in tough markets
02/08/2012  Although the resources sector is under pressure, there are still investment opportunities to be found.
Emerging risks in the new financial year
31/07/2012  In the first of our series on the market, City Index’s Peter Esho gives us his views on the financial year ahead.
Performing in volatile markets
25/07/2012  Despite a drop in revenue, Wilson Asset Management Capital has outperformed the market boosting dividends to shareholders.
Dividends and global equities
19/07/2012  PM Capital’s Tim McGowen talks about strategies that can boost the income return from global equities.
Is the two-speed race over?
18/07/2012  Australia’s two-speed economy may ease as commodity prices fall. Does this mean investors will have to revise their expectations of returns from local stocks?
Keeping sane in insane markets
12/07/2012  Investors need to keep a rational approach to investing despite the volatile markets.
What is in an income bond fund?
13/07/2012  Income-focused bond funds give investors that extra yield kick to their portfolios, however, understanding the risks are important.
Income certainty through annuities
03/07/2012  Retirees can now have access to annuity bonds through the NSW Government giving them certainty of income and security.
View from Madrid: The cost of saving the euro
19/06/2012  Morningstar Spain's Fernando Luque explains the reaction in Madrid to news of a bank bailout, further problems facing European governments, and a potential outcome for the eurozone.
Time to revisit fixed income?
07/06/2012  With falling interest rates fixed interest assets are becoming more attractive but what are the best ways investors can access this asset class?
What to do with falling super contribution caps
--  With the government limiting how much you can contribute to super, a number of other wealth creation strategies are available.
Will the Australian dollar rise or fall?
31/05/2012  Outlook for the Australian dollar and what it means for the two-speed economy.
Insuring against a long life
24/05/2012  You may live longer than you think. Can annuities insure your money doesn't run out before you do?
Treasury secretary defends budget surplus
18/05/2012  The secretary of the federal treasury Martin Parkinson spoke out against criticism regarding the budget surplus at a recent Australian Business Economists forum.
Getting better returns from growth companies
16/05/2012  Wilson Asset Management’s Geoff Wilson talks about the companies he chooses to his listed investment companies (LICs).
A wrap-up of small cap managers
14/05/2012  Small cap managers remain under pressure but a number of them are outperforming the market.
Time to boost your bond exposure?
09/05/2012  With interest rates easing on term deposits, bonds could play a bigger role in an investor’s portfolio.
The case of overseas investing
07/05/2012  Ibbotson’s Daniel Needham gives us his take on the outlook for equities and why investors need to look offshore.
A closer look at hybrids
03/05/2012  In a low-return environment, investors may be tempted to invest in higher-yielding securities like hybrids without understanding the risks.
Managers bullish on equities
17/04/2012  Russell’s quarterly fund manager survey shows a positive shift in manager sentiment with a strong swing in favour of growth assets.
Can we depend on China?
30/03/2012  China's demand for Australian resources may soon slow as the country winds back debt says author Satyajit Das.
Gold to shine again
29/03/2012  Worried inflation will erode paper currencies such as the US dollar? Ric Spooner from CMC Markets says investing in gold may be a good hedge.
Time to boost your Australian equities portfolio?
13/03/2012  Fidelity’s Kate Howitt who says that the biggest gamble for investors is not to hold equities
Will the mining tax slow the resources boom?
22/03/2012  HSBC’s Paul Bloxham discussed the continued strength of Australia’s mining boom and the newly legislated mining tax.
Are mortgage rates on the way down?
21/03/2012  Banks may find it cheaper to borrow on overseas capital markets. UBS' Matthew Johnson explains how that might translate into lower mortgage rates.
How do you make money in a volatile market?
15/03/2012  We pick the brains of Philip Parker, managing director of Parker Asset Management, and try to unlock some of the secrets of his success.
How global companies are managing the volatility
14/03/2012  While the international markets remain risky, there are a number of global companies navigating these markets.
The changing role of fixed interest
21/09/2010  An inevitable rise in global bond yields may expose investors to negative returns - unless they prepare now.
Super's good, bad and the ugly
23/09/2010  We're not doing ourselves any favours by clinging to a lump-sum mentality when it comes to super.
Keeping your long-term focus
21/02/2012  Westpac's David Simon looks at the key principles that keep investors focused on their long-term goals.
Huntley & Needham: China and the world
09/01/2012  In part two of our series, Morningstar's Ian Huntley and Daniel Needham debate China's dominance in 2012 and the outlook for US and Europe.
Huntley & Needham: Banking outlook for 2012
13/01/2012  In the final part of our series, Morningstar's Ian Huntley and Daniel Needham offer contrasting views on the impact of Europe on the big four.
Top investment mistakes to avoid
18/01/2012  Westpac's David Simon outlines some key investment pitfalls to steer away from this year.
There is more that glitters than gold
24/01/2012  Gold is not the only precious metal that can add sparkle to your portfolio.
What makes a good manager?
14/02/2012  With the Morningstar Awards 2012 on the horizon, co-head of research Tim Murphy discusses the three factors behind a good fund manager.
Will the dollar continue its highs in 2012?
25/01/2012  City Index's Kara Ordway gives us her predictions for the Australian dollar as well as an outlook for a number of major currencies.
Huntley & Needham: Market rally in 2012?
21/12/2011  In part one of three interviews, Morningstar's Ian Huntley and Daniel Needham participate in a lively discussion about the direction of the markets for 2012.
New global rating scale for funds
31/01/2012  Morningstar co-head of fund research Tim Murphy explains the new analyst ratings for funds and the rationale behind the changes.
Investing in low-growth markets
05/12/2011  The world might be turning Japanese as it faces a decade of lost growth, says international author Satyajit Das.
Managers' outlook for 2012
15/12/2011  Despite market volatility, investment managers are still seeing opportunities.