SMSFs - the pros and cons

Christine St Anne  |  26/03/2012Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  

Christine St. Anne: Self-managed superannuation funds or SMSFs, continue to achieve spectacular growth in Australia. To give an idea about what are the pros and cons behind these funds, I�m joined by Westpac�s, David Simon.

David, welcome.

David Simon: Thank you, Christine. Good to be here.

St. Anne: David to begin with, can you give us some idea about this growth?

Simon: Yes, sure. Look, self-managed superannuation, the growth has been nothing short of spectacular. In fact, in 1998, about 12% of Australians owned a self-managed super fund. Yet today around 33% percent of Australian own a self-managed super fund. So by far it�s a growth - the fastest growing sector and we believe that some of that growth has been � catalyst being the global financial crisis.

So people that have had a bad experience with their previous fund have become almost despondent and looked at other areas, where they can effectively manage the money better themselves and are hence being attracted to that sector.

St. Anne: So what are the reasons behind the growth?

Simon: There is a whole array of advantages that have attracted people to owning a self-managed superannuation fund and control and choice is the primary one. So having a self-managed super fund allows people to access various assets that would otherwise not be offered through a public fund. So having access to assets such as direct property, indeed art and collectibles, direct shares, term deposits and manage funds, amongst many others, allows people that choice and that freedom around choosing their assets.

Indeed aspects such as asset transfer is also a really attractive part of a self-managed fund. So indeed that people that own assets in their own names will be paying tax at their own marginal tax rate, but being able to especially transfer these into a self-managed fund means that they are able to enjoy, the lower taxation rates that are available with superannuation and indeed quite often we�ve seen people that run their own businesses, and have a commercial property or business rule property, we�ve even seen people like that move those properties into their self-managed fund to free up the cash flow of their business and obviously, we�ve seen many people transfer assets like shares and managed funds from their own name into a self-managed.

We also find that other areas such as being able to pool - you are managing a self-managed fund, so typically your self-managed fund can have about up to four members. So having four members combine all of their money into one fund, that typically have the signed objectives and characteristics, really gives them scale. So it allows them to access opportunities they otherwise wouldn�t be able to access as an individual and indeed really keep the fees down by having that ability to pool the money.

St. Anne: What about tax advantages?

Simon: In a self-managed super fund, if there is an asset that�s grown and accumulated value through the accumulation phase. If they were to liquidate that asset and realize a capital gain they would need to pay tax. Now, if they are in a self-managed fund, that can effectively migrate that fund into a pension phase and then sell the assets that accrued to capital gain and not pay any capital gains tax at all. So there certainly are some significant advantages that have attracted people to that sector and indeed that�s being represented in those growth rates.

St. Anne: You mentioned a number of advantages, what are the key things that investors need to consider before entering into an SMSF

Simon: So, some of the aspects and some of the considerations that people need to consider are really serious. The first one is the responsibility of running a self-managed fund. Now the trustee of the fund and indeed the corporate director of a corporate trustee are obliged to be able to manage that fund in a compliant manner, and indeed, if the fund is deemed to have breached their compliance and becomes incompliant, then the penalties are rife. One of the penalties is the asset being taxed at the marginal tax rate, so not the actual income of the assets, but the assets that are contained in the fund itself can attract the highest marginal tax rate. I am aware of stories where trustees of self-managed funds have had to pay out hundreds of thousands of dollars in tax because the fund is being deemed incompliant.

There are even other aspects such as fines and even jail terms for extreme beaches of superannuation fund compliance. Another area is expertise. People may open a self-managed fund and roll over their money into cash and then say where do I invest it? So one of the disadvantages and what people often over look is the requirement of the investment expertise in accessing a self-managed fund to ensure that they are managing in a very smart way but also in a strategic fashion. So it's really important that they have the skills and the expertise to do so.

One other thing is time. I mean time is a precious commodity in this day and age, and it takes a lot of time to manage the ongoing concern of a self-managed fund. In fact, there was a recent study where the average trustee needs to spend about five hours every week in managing a self-managed fund. It is not too different to managing a private company, so that certainly one thing that's particularly overlooked as well.

St. Anne: The amount of responsibilities you mentioned David, can investors outsource these?

Simon: Yeah, sure. The whole aspect around time and expertise and indeed the compliance function can all be outsourced, but that would probably beg a question, say, if you're outsourcing all of those, is it a do-it-yourself or is it a self-managed super fund?

St. Anne: Do investors need a minimum balance to start up an SMSF?

Simon: Yeah, certainly Christine. There is a lot of controversy around what would be the reasonable amount that is required before you set up self-managed fund. Look, there�s no hard and fast rule when everybody has their own opinion, but certainly depending on the complexity, the purpose and the structure of a self-managed fund, whether it's a corporate trustee or public trustee or indeed if the purpose of the self-managed fund is to acquire direct property through - borrowing through an instalment loan, the set up cost can become quite material and expensive, and indeed if a fund is typically worth less than $250,000, the additional accounting, audit and legal fees, generally make it more expensive than a public offer fund. So, as a general rule of thumb, about $250,000.

St. Anne: David, thanks so much for your insights today.

Simon: My pleasure, thank you.

Video Archive...

Earnings season FY17 mixed bag so far
18/08/2017  Aside from a few high-profile earnings guidance misses, large-cap stocks are doing okay as FY17 reporting season passes halfway, says AMP chief economist Shane Oliver.
Self-managed super is not Do-it-yourself
03/07/2017  There are a few common pitfalls in running a self-managed super fund that mean trustees shouldn't go it alone entirely, says BT Financial Group's head of financial literacy, Bryan Ashenden.
How to guard against retirement threats
16/06/2017  As retirement approaches, even the best-laid plans can go awry, as Tim Steffen tells Christine Benz, Morningstar US.
No place for set-and-forget asset allocation
04/10/2016  A 2016 company reporting season overview and explanation of why dynamic asset allocation is so important, from Dr Shane Oliver, chief economist and director of investment strategy, AMP Capital.
Helping SMSF trustees negotiate super complexities
19/08/2016  Peter Hogan, head of technical at the SMSF Association, shares his insights on the changing super environment and how it will affect SMSF trustees.
Safe withdrawal rates for retirees
02/02/2016  Morningstar's Anthony Serhan explains why retirees in Australia should use lower initial safe withdrawal rates than those suggested in prior research.
Pitfalls of investing for retirement
30/09/2015  Bad behaviour before and in retirement can take a major hit to your savings. We outline the pitfalls to avoid if you want to maximise your pension pot.
4 retiree to-dos in a turbulent market
02/09/2015  Despite the market swings, retirees can control stuff like checking cash reserves and spending levels.
3 key risks for retirees
24/06/2015  Accurium SMSF technical services manager Melanie Dunn discusses three factors trustees should be aware of as they move from the accumulation to the retirement phase.
Top global tech opportunities
30/04/2015  Australia's foremost global investor Kerr Neilson identifies global drivers and those undervalued companies that are positioned for strong growth.
Key takeaways from the Murray inquiry, SuperStream
23/04/2015  The SMSF Association's Graeme Colley discusses important points from both the Murray inquiry and the SuperStream initiative, while also giving trustees tips on how to avoid unwanted "gardening leave".
Revisiting the sole purpose test
19/03/2015  It’s important that trustees are reminded about their obligations under the sole purpose test – a key requirement in SMSF compliance.
Trustees under the spotlight
--  SMSF Association’s Andrea Slattery talks about the growing professionalism of the industry and what it means for trustees.
Taxing times for trustees?
05/03/2015  The government may have moved to address the tax concessions into super but trustees face a number of potential taxing issues.
Key issues for SMSFs
02/02/2015  A government inquiry and tax concessions are among the key issues confronting trustees.
Top SMSF tips for 2015
21/01/2015  Keeping up-to-date on legislative changes, avoiding excess contributions and ensuring sufficient cash flow is in place are just some of the simple things trustees can do to get a better handle on their SMSF.
7 reasons why SMSFs outperform
22/07/2014  The key advantages to running a self-managed superannuation funds have also translated into strong performance.
What the advice reforms mean for SMSFs
09/07/2014  SPAA’s Graeme Colley outlines what SMSF trustees need to do to ensure the advice they are getting complies with the government’s proposed reforms.
A tax date with your SMSF
02/06/2014  SPAA's Graeme Colley outlines a number of important dates for tax payers as the 30 June deadline looms.
Keeping your SMSF simple
21/05/2014  Oasis Wealth's Barbara Smith offers some thoughts on the property market and some simple advice on how not to get into trouble with the ATO.
Getting SMSF ready for SuperStream
03/04/2014  SMSF members who accept employer contributions will need to prepare for the government’s new measure called SuperStream.
Is your SMSF audit ready?
27/03/2014  SMSF trustees face new audit requirements from the Australian Taxation Office
Key rulings for SMSFs
20/03/2014  AMP's Peter Burgess outlines key legislative considerations for trustees
Do trustees know best?
17/03/2014  --
Getting ready for contribution cap rises
13/03/2014  The indexation of the contribution caps will give people the opportunity to put more into superannuation.
3 key legislative changes for SMSF trustees
07/02/2014  Trustees need to grapple with a number of legislative changes made by the ATO.
5 new year resolutions
23/01/2014  Westpac's David Simon outlines five key new year resolutions that will maximise portfolio performance.
Getting value from your property portfolio
21/01/2014  Property expert Margaret Lomas outlines effective strategies for maximising a property portfolio and managing these assets in retirement.
What can SMSF trustees expect in 2014?
17/12/2013  A new government inquiry into financial services will be among the key issues trustees will have to grapple with in 2014.
Do SMSFs need a minimum balance?
30/10/2013  Should minimum balances be set for SMSFs in order for them to be run effectively?
Understanding new SMSF guidelines
20/09/2013  BT Financial Group’s Bryan Ashenden explains the proposed guidelines for advisers operating in the SMSF market and the implications for trustees.
What the Coalition means for super
13/09/2013  The new government will cut back on concessions for low-income earners and will most likely re-think excess contributions for SMSFs.
Key changes to super caps
25/07/2013  The latest changes to concessional superannuation caps may mean a change of strategy for trustees.
What the budget means for SMSFs
15/05/2013  While there were little in surprises in this week’s budget, there are a number of issues trustees still need to consider.
What to do with falling super contribution caps
--  With the government limiting how much you can contribute to super, a number of other wealth creation strategies are available.
SMSFs - the pros and cons
26/03/2012  Westpac’s David Simon outlines the benefits of SMSFS as well as the traps to avoid.
Cooper, super and SMSFs
--  Understanding the Cooper review's proposed changes to our super and SMSFs.
The changing role of fixed interest
21/09/2010  An inevitable rise in global bond yields may expose investors to negative returns - unless they prepare now.
Super's good, bad and the ugly
23/09/2010  We're not doing ourselves any favours by clinging to a lump-sum mentality when it comes to super.
Planning your DIY super in 2012
23/01/2012  Having the right plan is critical if trustees are to navigate the big changes to concessional caps this year.
Time to get out of cash?
01/09/2011  SMSFs have boosted their cash allocations but is it time to diversify into other asset classes?
All you need to know about SMSFs
31/03/2011  Grant Abbott discusses what attendees can expect at the upcoming Morningstar SMSF Trustee Strategy Day.
Death's effect on SMSF borrowings
06/10/2010  The death of an SMSF member has significant consequences when a gearing strategy is in place.
Lump sums have merit too
28/09/2010  Considering an income stream in retirement? Don't ignore lump sums.
Property acquisitions using gearing
22/09/2010  A look at some of the finer points about using limited recourse loans to purchase property within super funds.
5 ways SMSFs may become non-complying
13/09/2010  Becoming non-complying is one of the worst things that can happen to your fund. So avoid it.
Extra pay needs extra planning
31/05/2010  Extra pay, windfalls and bonuses are great but good planning can make it better.
Art for SMSFs' sake
31/08/2010  Artwork and collectables back on the table for SMSF investors.
Emerging trends in SMSFs
04/08/2010  SPAA chair Sharyn Long shares her knowledge of what SMSFs are up to at the moment.
Tax tips for SMSFs in FY10/11
19/07/2010  SPAA chair Sharyn Long shares her knowledge of what SMSFs are up to at the moment.
Getting SMSF taxes ready
--  We’ve put a line under FY09/10 but how do we best prepare our taxes for the year.
Putting that extra into super
--  Andrew Proebstl, chief executive of legalsuper tells us how the fund encouraged record voluntary contributions from members
Super no shelter for fraud
--  --
Do SMSFs seek advice?
--  SMSF members like control but do they eschew advice?
Super changes and SMSFs
--  Super has been tinkered with yet again but what are the implications for SMSFs?
Beware capital gains tax on SMSF rollovers
--  Certain activities in running a self managed super fund can trigger capital gains tax liabilities.
Avoid horrific penalties
--  The ATO is focused on excess contributions in SMSFs.
Insurance gets built-in for longer living
--  Lifetime income guarantee funds make sure your money won’t run out.
ETFs for easy diversification: pioneer
--  ETF pioneer Jim Ross of State Street Global Advisers explains why these products are gaining popularity.
Hefty tax for exceeding caps
--  What to do if you exceed the superannuation contribution caps.
Actuaries measure risks of ageing
--  The actuaries’ role in determining risks and helping governments formulate economic policy.
Penalties for your SMSF's poor report
--  SPAA chair Sharyn Long talks about the auditor contravention report and how SMSF trustees can best deal with them.
Ensuring your auditor is qualified
--  SPAA accredited auditors have now become approved auditors under the SIS Act.
Making the nest egg last the distance
--  --
Keep your super in the family
--  Is your SMSF for the whole family? Grant Abbott discusses if you should have insurance or other products included.
Penalties for your SMSF’s poor report
--  SPAA chair Sharyn Long talks about the auditor contravention report and how SMSF trustees can best deal with them.
New TPD insurance regulations
--  --
SMSF Reserves
--  --
Will your SMSF pass these tests?
--  How Australian is your SMSF? Dire consequences await those funds that fail to meet requirements.
SMSFs and gearing
--  SMSF expert Grant Abbott talks to Darin Tyson-Chan some of the basic facts surrounding the use of borrowing in an SMSF.
Binding death benefit nominations
--  SMSF Strategies principal Grant Abbott discusses the merits of having a binding death benefit nomination within an SMSF with Darin Tyson-Chan.
The SMSF in-house asset rule
--  Darin Tyson-Chan speaks to SMSF Strategies principal Grant Abbott about the amended in-house assets rule for SMSFs
Divorce and your SMSF - what you need to know
--  Breaking up is hard to do, especially without a contingency plan in your SMSF for divorce.
Trustee responsibility (pt 1)
--  Trustees often trip over the law with SMSFs, lawyer Peter Townsend warns in the first of this two-part interview.
Trustee responsibility (pt 2)
--  The second part of this SMSF discussion provides tips for trustees
Not too late for super tweaks
--  Tax time is over but tax planning around super need not be. Clearview's Dante De Gori explains
Maximum earnings and super contributions
--  Salary sacrificing? Understanding the 10 per cent maximum earnings rule is a must.
Could ETFs benefit your super?
--  What you need to know about Exchange Traded Funds and retirement savings
SMSFs and gearing
--  Administrative considerations with Andrew Biviano and Darin Tyson-Chan
Trustee Education
--  Liz Westover gives her recommended changes to superannuation trustee skill and knowledge.