Where ETFs fit in 4 retirement stages

--  |   27/11/2018 Text size  Decrease  Increase   |  
<p><strong>Glenn Freeman:</strong> Speaking about some of the undersold and oversold aspects of exchange-traded funds and one of those oversold aspects according to Christine Benz in Morningstar U.S. is the tradability. What are your thoughts on that?</p> <p><strong>Jonathan Shead: </strong>It's a great question. Because ETFs are used by lots of different participants in the market and it can be tempting to take a benefit for one group and assume it's a benefit for all groups. And you need to be careful doing that. So, there are market participants who actively trade ETFs quite aggressively and frequently. And under those circumstances the high level of tradability and low costs become a really strong benefit.</p> <p>I think for retirees we think that the buy and hold is probably a better way of generating that income over time. So, really, it's things like diversification and simplicity. I do think that in retirement you are also talking about a period of potentially cognitive decline. So, the more complex you make your portfolio, the more you are setting yourself up for problems later on in retirement. Plus, with an aging population you've got things like multi-generational households where your bequest motives or financial assistance may run across multiple generations.</p> <p>You are talking about a retirement that might actually be only a partial retirement. Maybe you might be doing part-time work or contracting. Maybe you might be retiring a bit later. Maybe you might be popping in and out of the workforce. And the ability to have a structure that's simple enough to be manageable but that's well-diversified and that you can keep in place for 15, 20 years without having to constantly tinker and change with it I think is the real strength of ETFs. But that speaks to a buy and hold benefit rather than a low-cost benefit from high trading.</p> <p><strong>Freeman: </strong>Sure. In a recent presentation you delivered, you were speaking about what you identify as the four stages for retirement; the accumulation, approaching retirement, active retirement and elderhood. Can you elaborate on some of the roles that ETFs play in some of those different stages?</p> <p><strong>Shead: </strong>I think those stages that we talk about first map to the kind of risk profile or income profile. So, if you think about the early stage of the savings journey, when you're perhaps up to 55-years-old, then really you want to be growth would be I think fairly well accepted advice. And then, as you start to approach retirement, you may want to make your portfolio a little bit more conservatives. ETFs are one but not the only way you can do that to shift your portfolio towards a slightly more conservative footing.</p> <p>I think when you actually reach retirement, ETFs provide a really simply way to identify that income component. So, if you think of it this way, if you were to live off just the dividends and maybe a fixed amount of your underlying account balance, so let's say, 1% of your account balance, and you were just to live off the dividends. There'd be some variability in that. Dividends do go up and down over time, but they actually don't vary that much. Even a simple strategy like that, which is easy to do with an ETF kind of structure, you'll have some variability, but most adults have spent their entire working life dealing with some level of income variability, and that's a kind of structure that can serve you really well in that active retirement component.</p> <p>We use the term active retirement because people are old but no longer frail. I'm talking about the demographic that retires but wants to go adventure tourism to Africa or wants to go bungee jumping in New Zealand or something like that. When you get to what we've called elderhood, which is, when you slow down, when you've got much more stable requirements, certainly the government's intention is that at that kind of point you may start to look at things like your more traditional term deposits or possibly annuities or those much, much more stable kind of structures.</p> <p><strong>Freeman: </strong>Now, one of the other things that you mentioned there is about using ETFs as a part of the income component. It's not something that I at least haven't thought of ETFs within that context so much mainly as an accumulation phase, but actually exchange-traded funds have been sources of distributions.</p> <p><strong>Shead: </strong>Yeah. So, exchange-traded funds, if you think about them as almost being like a cardboard box that's got hundreds of companies in it. And someone is on your behalf collecting all the dividends from those companies, bundling them up together, and then just giving you a dividend payment once a month or once a quarter. That simple kind of structure is a great way to get income from those long-term growth assets like equities without having to have all the tax and administration and investment complexities of holding hundreds and hundreds of companies.</p>

Video Archive...

Morningstar launches its first active ETF
12/11/2019  The head of Morningstar Investment Management Australia, Matt Wacher, reveals how the new International Shares Active ETF uses a quality- and value-led strategy to find opportunities in several global and emerging markets.
What happens if everyone indexes?
09/09/2019  Morningstar's director of passive strategies research Alex Bryan discusses some possible consequences.
ETFs are democratising investing, says Vanguard
23/05/2019  As exchange-traded funds that take country tilts, invest in fixed income and even provide exposure to unlisted assets take hold, there are new ways to hold a core allocation to ETFs without being overly concentrated, explains Vanguard's Axel Lomholt.
Friday fundamentals webinar: Deep dive into ETFs
15/04/2019  Emma Rapaport talks to Morningstar's Alex Prineas about exchange-traded funds and what they can offer for the Australian investor.
Strategic-Beta ETPs on the rise
21/03/2019  Strategic or smart beta exchange traded products continued to expand in 2018 and now make up 10.5 per cent of Australia's ETP market, says Morningstar associate director, manager research Alexander Prineas.
Ask the expert: Strategic beta ETFs
07/03/2019  State Street’s Thomas Reif explains smart beta exchange-traded funds, how style tilts such as value, size and low volatility work, and how such ETFs respond to higher volatility.
Index investors 'get what they don't pay for'
31/01/2019  The late Vanguard founder, Jack Bogle, was a committed believer in index investing and the Cost Matters Hypothesis, says Morningstar's Russ Kinnel.
Changes ahead for ETF investors
15/01/2019  The inclusion of mainland China shares in more indexes including S&P Global, an expanding menu of active ETFs, and the potential for more ESG-focused funds are among trends investors can expect in 2019.
Where ETFs fit in 4 retirement stages
27/11/2018  Exchange-traded funds have pros and cons depending on your investment style and other variables as you approach retirement, along with applications in the accumulation and withdrawal phases, explains State Street's Jonathan Shead.
Australian retirees lack confidence
21/11/2018  Superannuation complexities, investment risk and regulatory uncertainty mean a shortfall in confidence is understandable in our current environment, says State Street’s Jonathan Shead.
The double-edged sword of listed investments
16/11/2018  There are very good reasons for the popularity of listed investment vehicles, but some of these attributes also give rise to potential challenges, explains Morningstar’s Matthew Wilkinson.
The risks of timing factor investing
23/10/2018  Vanguard founder Jack Bogle sees a place for some factor funds but thinks trying to trade between factors is a losing proposition.
Bogle: Index funds should top investor lists
17/10/2018  Vanguard founder Jack Bogle explains the difference between long-term and speculative returns, and where he believes markets are headed over the next decade.
5 megatrends shaping the future of investing
25/09/2018  iShares' Rob Powell talks to Emma Wall about thematic investing and how megatrends are shaping global economies and stock markets.
ETF flows remain strong despite emerging market turmoil
12/09/2018  Currency volatility has rocked emerging market equity returns over the year, but ETF investors are staying the course, says Morningstar Asia director of ETF research Jackie Choy.
Are ETFs overrated?
06/09/2018  Liquidity, transparency, and tax efficiency are hallmarks of ETFs, but Ben Johnson says some of these benefits can be oversold.
Using ETFs to manage portfolio risk
12/06/2018  How active ETFs offer investors a lower-cost alternative to full active management, and are increasingly used for holistic portfolio construction, says BetaShares' Alex Vynokur.
Evolution of ETFs in investor portfolios
08/06/2018  How investors' use of exchange-traded funds is evolving, and why Blackrock hasn't yet pushed into the active side of these vehicles, according to Blackrock iShares' Jonathan Howie.
Are ETFs to blame for market volatility?
07/03/2018  Morningstar associate director of manager research Alex Prineas explains some of the complexities facing ETF investors.
3 macro themes for 2018
31/01/2018  US corporate tax cuts and slow-burning European economic growth feed BlackRock iShares' bullishness on this third market--and equities in general, explains Alex Zaika.
5 steps to decide if ETFs are for you
29/01/2018  Alex Zaika explains what goes into building an exchange-traded fund, and some of the different variables investors need to consider.
Bogle remains unimpressed with strategic beta
30/10/2017  The Vanguard founder says his long-time strategy of sticking to index funds is still the best bet.
Jack Bogle on what's next for active investing
30/10/2017  The Vanguard founder says net withdrawals have been offset by rising stock prices.
Bogle: Vanguard's size a worry
30/10/2017  Diminishing economies of scale and potential regulatory concerns limits how much bigger Vanguard should become, says founder Jack Bogle.
Bogle: Index funds the best hope for corporate governance
25/10/2017  Corporate governance should be based on long-term factors affecting the corporation, and traditional index funds are the only true, long-term investors, says Vanguard founder Jack Bogle.
Bogle: The good and the bad of ETF trading
25/10/2017  Any significant amount of trading will decrease your return relative to the market, says the Vanguard founder.
Bogle: ETF flows muddle valuation, risk picture
25/10/2017  Large swings in ETF flows make it hard to forecast valuations and are likely introducing new risks into the market, says Vanguard founder Jack Bogle.
Bogle's 'reasonable expectations' for market returns
24/10/2017  The Vanguard founder sees 4 per cent returns for stocks and 3 per cent for bonds over the next decade.