Car dealership tie-up a potential win

--  |   15/05/2019 Text size  Decrease  Increase   |  
email_fwd
<p><strong>Lex Hall:</strong> Hi, I'm Lex Hall, and welcome to the Morningstar series, "Ask the Expert." Today, I'm joined by Morningstar equity analyst Daniel Ragonese and we are here to talk about the mooted merger between Australia's two biggest car leaders, AP Eagers and Automotive Holdings Group. We're going to talk to Dan and why he thinks there's upside in this deal.</p> <p>Dan, g&rsquo;day.</p> <p><strong>Daniel Ragonese:</strong> Thanks for having me.</p> <p><strong>Hall: </strong>My pleasure. Now, before we look at the deal, let's look at the context in which it's taking place. It comes at a time when car sales have been pretty sluggish for the past year and dealership revenues have been under pressure. What do you put the falling car sales down to?</p> <p><strong>Ragonese: </strong>Yeah. So, it has been a challenging 12 months for new vehicle sales, obviously, declining during that period. Look, there's a couple of things behind it, but the main driver in my opinion is really that the declining residential property prices. And the consequence that's having is that negative wealth effect. So, what you're seeing is the average consumer a lot less confident and less likely to go out and purchase big-ticket items such as a new vehicle.</p> <p><strong>Hall: </strong>Because they think the value of their assets, in this case property, is falling and they feel less wealthy?</p> <p><strong>Ragonese: </strong>Just feeling less wealthy in general and less optimistic about things. But at the same time, this is something that in my view is not a structural issue. It's a cyclical issue and we are already starting to see that property market, the rate of decline starting to slow. So, we think as that market stabilises over the next 12 months that new vehicle sales should do the same and eventually start recovering. So, longer-term, we don't have any concern.</p> <p><strong>Hall: </strong>OK. Timing of the deal: do you see any significance in that?</p> <p><strong>Ragonese: </strong>Yeah. Look, it's come at an interesting time. I think obviously the challenges that the industry is going through, both regarding the declining vehicle sales but also from a regulatory standpoint, there's been some reform there, which has impacted them. Of the two firms, Automotive Holdings has really felt the brunt of that. And I think that was reflected in the share price prior to this deal.</p> <p><strong>Hall: </strong>I'll just jump in there and ask you about regulatory reform. What are you talking about there in specific?</p> <p><strong>Ragonese: </strong>Yeah. So, ASIC &ndash; the whole car dealership industry has been through a major review and basically ASIC has restricted the amount of commission that they can earn on the sale of finance and insurance products. And that was where the dealers were able to make a lot of their margins. So, obviously, that change weighing on their margins and consequently the share price as well. So, yeah, I mean, from AP Eagers&rsquo; standpoint, I think it definitely can be seen as an opportunistic deal in terms of timing.</p> <p><strong>Hall: </strong>Let's look at the deal itself, Dan. AP Eagers had a 29 per cent stake in Automotive Holdings Group and last month made a move to acquire AHG. You reckon that the deal will go ahead, and you see upside for both parties. What are the advantages of two companies like this coming together do you think?</p> <p><strong>Ragonese: </strong>Yeah. Look, I think, the deal is likely to go ahead. And from the company's perspectives, there's a lot of benefit for both parties. The first and the obvious one is by coming together they are going to be able to generate some cost savings. So, at this point, the companies have already called out $13.5 million per year in cost savings. I think that's conservative and I think there's upside potential to those numbers. So, this is the first thing.</p> <p>Secondly is, obviously, the merged entity is going to be much more diverse on both the regional and the brand perspective and that should help smooth out some of the volatility with vehicle sales. And also, I think coming together and becoming a larger group, they are going to have quite a strong balance sheet. So, it's very well placed to continue taking market share, particularly as the market eventually starts to recover.</p> <p><strong>Hall: </strong>OK. But it's yet to go ahead, of course. What do you think is standing in the way of the deal, if anything?</p> <p><strong>Ragonese: </strong>Yeah. Look, in my opinion, it's likely to go ahead. Shareholder support has been quite strong. I think the main [point] outstanding at the moment is probably the ACCC, which is yet to rule on this. But in my opinion, this shouldn't be a major hurdle, particularly as the two firms are concentrated in quite different areas. So, Automotive Holdings is very much exposed to Western Australia whereas AP Eagers is heavily concentrated towards the East Coast. So, there's not a huge amount of overlap there. And in addition, the market is still very highly fragmented. So, on a combined basis, these firms are likely to represent maybe around 12 to 13 per cent of the total industry. So, still a lot of competition around.</p> <p><strong>Hall: </strong>And finally, Dan, I note in your report that you're still pretty upbeat on these companies. If the deal doesn't go ahead, they are both worth investing in obviously?</p> <p><strong>Ragonese: </strong>Yeah. Look, if the deal was to fall through, my fair values would revert to their standalone values prior to the merger being announced. But at the same time, I'm still being quite positive, particularly on Automotive Holdings which I've seen a lot of opportunity for upside, both in terms of revenue and recapturing a lot of that margin that they have lost in recent years. So, yeah, still quite positive longer term.</p>

Video Archive...

How to avoid dividend cuts
27/03/2020  A wave of companies are expected to cut their dividends amid the coronavirus crisis. Morningstar's Dan Lefkovitz explains how to spot a firm that could its pay out.
Healthcare stocks still defensive, says Morningstar
26/03/2020  Respiratory specialist Fisher & Paykel Healthcare is among stocks now enticingly priced as the coronavirus hits markets and the Aussie dollar.
Cheap or nasty? Seven, Nine and Telstra
24/03/2020  A stock that’s heavily sold down isn’t always a screaming buy, as proven by this comparison of debt and other fundamentals among these well-loved companies.
Mining stocks offer price opportunity, dividend threat
20/03/2020  OZ Minerals, South32 and Iluka are among miners dipping into buy territory amid the coronavirus selloff but dividends are at risk, says Morningstar’s Mat Hodge.
Market, economic implications amid latest virus news
20/03/2020  Karen Andersen and Preston Caldwell give us their latest perspectives on healthcare and energy.
'The long-term bounceback will be strong'
17/03/2020  The coronavirus fallout is hurting but there should be a treatment by year end and the rebound will be strong, says Morningstar director of equities Johannes Faul. 
Taking control in time of corona
17/03/2020  In this timely Morningstar panel discussion, but Christine Benz and Andrew Lill provide  concrete tips on how curb your losses and put your money to use.
The importance of staying invested in volatile times
16/03/2020  Don't flee the market in a panic, but rather embrace the turmoil as an investment opportunity—you'll be better off in the long run.
‘A modest sell-off, not a panic’: Douglass on coronavirus fallout
14/03/2020  The Magellan co-founder insists now is not the time to ditch stocks for cash nor to buy bargains, and global businesses won’t turn their backs on China.
Avoid panic-selling: Douglass calls for calm
12/03/2020  Share market speculation is almost always a bad idea, and panic-selling stocks on coronavirus fears is an example of just that, warns Magellan boss.
Coronavirus and the market: our take
11/03/2020  We offer three takeaways and advice on staying true to your goals.
Hits and misses aplenty in first half 2020 - Part 2
10/03/2020  Consumer stock Breville and listed property firm Charter Hall were among the highest gainers after delivering results, while Mayne Pharma and Seven West saw the sharpest falls.
Hits and misses aplenty in first half 2020 - Part 1
09/03/2020  The interim reporting season served up a lesson in why investors shouldn't rely too heavily on company forecasts, says Morningstar's Peter Warnes
The best diversifiers for your equity portfolio
05/03/2020  Christine Benz discusses how to protect your portfolio from a stock-market sell-off.
Green bonds offer another side to ESG investing
05/03/2020  Investors are largely unaware of the role fixed income can play in expressing their views on social, environmental and governance issues.
ETF investing for the new decade: 4 trends to watch
02/03/2020  In only a decade, the value of Australia's ETF market has risen by almost 2000 per cent.
The new medical device company to watch
28/02/2020  Spray-on skin maker Avita Medical has a chance of becoming the new standard in burns treatment, says Morningstar's Nicolette Quinn. 
Helping financial advisers help investors
27/02/2020  Financial advice can deliver value but we must do a better job of showing what that is and measuring it, says Morningstar chief executive Kunal Kapoor.
'ESG is about building a portfolio for outperformance'
26/02/2020  Morningstar CEO Kunal Kapoor explains the importance of ESG investing and why it's not simply a matter of avoiding guns, smokes and booze.
Volatility is here to stay - here's what to do
25/02/2020  Morningstar's director of personal finance Christine Benz explains how investors - young and old - should navigate how the coronavirus, the US election and frothy stock prices.
Why mining dividends are a flash in the pan
24/02/2020  A near-record dividend payout from BHP reflects high iron ore prices and miners flush with cash, but these conditions won’t continue long-term, says Morningstar’s Mat Hodge.
The case for emerging market debt
20/02/2020  Lazard Asset Management's Arif Joshi demystifies emerging market debt and explains why it can offer excess yields.
Telstra faces Vodafone-TPG tie-up
18/02/2020  Morningstar equity analyst Brian Han reckons the Vodafone-TPG is a 75pc chance of proceeding but says there's a risk of overestimating its effect on Telstra.
CBA result puts dividend fears to bed, NAB on track
14/02/2020  Despite a profit dip there are many positives for CBA, including growth in mortgages and deposits and a strong balance sheet, says Morningstar equity analyst Nathan Zaia.
Doubts over James Hardie's bullish outlook
14/02/2020  The building materials supplier's long-term North American market share forecast is too ambitious, says Grant Slade 
Could Coronavirus hit China's luxury boom?
12/02/2020  Morningstar analyst Jelena Sokolova looks at the potential impact of the coronavirus on the luxury goods sector.
4 healthcare stocks attractive on valuation and ESG risk
10/02/2020  Morningstar's Karen Andersen explains how environmental, social and governance issues affect Big Pharma and biotech companies.
Coal case: why Whitehaven is a Best Idea
07/02/2020  Lower costs, higher prices, and demand from Asia: key reasons why the miner's shares are going cheap, says Morningstar director of equity research Mathew Hodge.
Two of Morningstar's Best Ideas
04/02/2020  Morningstar's Adam Fleck explains how his team decides on which names to recommend and reveals a stock that is trading at a 30 per cent discount to its fair value estimate.
Behind Morningstar's Global Best Ideas list
03/02/2020  A margin of safety and high analyst conviction are just two of the criteria behind this monthly selection of stocks for your watchlist, says Morningstar's Adam Fleck.
Morningstar's tribute to Jack Bogle
29/01/2020  There has never been anyone who has given more to investors and taken less in return than Jack Bogle.
Kraft Heinz on the comeback trail
23/01/2020  As the faltering firm works toward a turnaround, patient investors should consider its undervalued shares.
3 foodie stock picks
21/01/2020  Sarasin's Jeneiv Shah looks at three stocks across the food chain, including one company trying to stop cows from burping.
Morningstar's predictions for 2020
16/01/2020  A contraction in housing starts; advances in electric vehicle technology; Trump re-election; a rate cut; and another tough year for banks - just some of what's expected.
3 European stock picks for 2020
14/01/2020  Unloved cable companies and property firms provide some of the best opportunities in Europe, says T. Rowe Price's Dean Tenerelli. 
Best of 2019: Why Iluka is bucking the mining company trend
09/01/2020  In May 2019, Morningstar's Mat Hodge explained why this rare earths company provides a different exposure to consumer materials, and has a clear path to revenue growth.
Best of 2019: how to pick stocks like Warren Buffett
08/01/2020  In this Best of 2019 video, Morningstar director of investor education Karen Wallace reveals how Warren Buffet benefited from sniffing out companies with competitive advantages.
Best of 2019: Coles, Woolies and shareholders face tough facts
07/01/2020  In 2019, we checked in with retail analyst Johannes Faul who explained how margin pressures affected supermarket giants Woolworths and Coles, and how the market reacted.
Best of 2019 videos: Warnes' downturn warning for investors
06/01/2020  In our look back at 2019, Morningstar head of equity research Peter Warnes identifies the performers of this earning season and issues a warning to investors of what action to take as uncertainty builds.
Morningstar year in review 2019
23/12/2019  Morningstar analysts look back at a year marked by a plunge in interest rates, shocks for the banking sector, China's vast appetite for iron ore, and the Coalition's upset election win.
What lies ahead for ASX, global markets in 2020 - Part 2
19/12/2019  Tension between big business, government and the Reserve Bank will spill into the new year and Australia's banks will likely remain under pressure.
What lies ahead for ASX, global markets in 2020 - Part 1
18/12/2019  The record stock market returns of 2019 are unlikely to be repeated next year or any time soon, says Morningstar’s Peter Warnes.
3 top picks: medical tech, bank and telco
16/12/2019  US President Trump’s trade war with China is a telco tailwind for Ericsson, says Fidelity’s Amit Lodha, who also likes medical technology firm Boston Scientific and Indian bank Kotak Mahindra.
Investors hunting for 'Switzerland'
13/12/2019  Investors are scrambling for safety as geopolitical tensions fuel the hunt for investable countries and ideas, says Fidelity’s global portfolio manager Amit Lodha.
Don’t abandon stocks amid rising market risk
11/12/2019  Low interest rates and a generally gloomy investment outlook magnifies the importance of picking quality, defensive companies for your portfolio, says Investors Mutual’s Hugh Giddy.
Where in the world can stock investors find value?
06/12/2019  US stocks hold only sparse opportunities for investors but parts of emerging Asia such as Korea and Japan are attractive, says Morningstar’s Daniel Needham.
Euro small caps among Bell’s top picks
05/12/2019  Global small- and mid-cap stocks still hold appeal for this manager, including Spanish airline booking and luxury goods companies Amadeus and Moncler.
Investors too bullish on Coles and Woolies, says Morningstar
04/12/2019  Australia’s biggest supermarkets are successfully defending their turf but high profit margins are ancient history, says Morningstar’s Johannes Faul.
Staying on budget over the holidays
03/12/2019  You might overspend because of “wealth effect”, or to keep up with the Joneses, but Morningstar’s Christine Benz has some ideas on how to not go over your budget.
Nine’s Stan holds high ground in streaming battle
29/11/2019  The local content strength of Nine-owned streaming video service Stan means it should prevail even as Disney+ launches locally alongside Netflix and other invaders, says Morningstar’s Brian Han.
Earnings bright side for Westpac
28/11/2019  Westpac has endured one of the most torrid weeks in its 200-year history but there's an upside, says Morningstar banking analyst Nathan Zaia.
How to find quality at a reasonable price
28/11/2019  Bell Asset Management's chief investment officer Ned Bell explains the principles of 'QARP' investing and singles out three companies that meet the criteria.
Taking the pulse at the Morningstar Individual Investor Conference
27/11/2019  Emma Rapaport taps conference goers for their thoughts on record low interest rates, stock opportunities, diversification and the merits of active management.
Dollar cost averaging doesn't work
25/11/2019  Investing a bit at a time is a bad idea, and buying the dip is an unnecessary risk, recent Morningstar research finds.
Banks, whistleblowers and the Hayne inquiry
19/11/2019  Investigative journalist and author Adele Ferguson discusses the banking royal commission outcome and whether shareholders should have a bigger role in policing their behaviour.
Paradigm shift is coming, says Warnes
14/11/2019  Unprecedented money printing and record low rates haven't worked and a 'paradigm shift' is afoot, argues Morningstar's Peter Warnes. 
Morningstar launches its first active ETF
12/11/2019  The head of Morningstar Investment Management Australia, Matt Wacher, reveals how the new International Shares Active ETF uses a quality- and value-led strategy to find opportunities in several global and emerging markets.
Understanding Morningstar Sustainability Ratings
12/11/2019  A Morningstar Sustainability Rating for funds helps investors make comparisons across industries and better understand and manage total ESG risk in their investments.
Should the home affect Age Pension eligibility?
11/11/2019  Whether the family home should be part of the Age Pension asset test continues to stir debate in Australia as do broader issues around retirement and superannuation, explains Graham Hand.
How to sort the winners from the also-rans
08/11/2019  Forget chasing the daily vagaries of the market and focus instead on stocks that will shine in their individual sectors, says Fidelity's Kate Howitt. 
Winds are shifting in US power generation market
06/11/2019  Natural gas and renewable energy, particularly solar and wind, will battle for top spot in the power generation stakes, says Morningstar's Charles Fishman.
There’s more to running an SMSF than paperwork and penalties
04/11/2019  Complexity has long been a bugbear of SMSF trustees, for whom the administrative burden is a necessary evil, but changes are afoot to help reduce the hassle, says Vanguard’s Robin Bowerman.
Investment opportunities abound in electric vehicles
31/10/2019  Morningstar equity analyst Seth Goldstein identifies his top picks in supply chain and ancillary industries.
Hamish Douglass: China is the opportunity of the next 20 years
30/10/2019  Magellan Financial Group's chief stockpicker on how to play the political risk of a runaway China, why 'tech' is a misleading word and why the future is bright for cloud computing.
Platinum's guide to playing politics
29/10/2019  Platinum Asset Management's Andrew Clifford on how to find overlooked opportunities and why demand for cars and computers will persist despite trade war tensions.
Why you should look on the bright side
25/10/2019  AMP Capital economist Shane Oliver explains why the sweep of history favours the optimists and why confidence is the key to successful investing. 
Why the Morningstar Individual Investor Conference matters
24/10/2019  Jamie Wickham explains the aims of the Morningstar Individual Investor Conference and identifies the issues that are front of mind for investors and self-funded retirees.
I don't agree with Trump on much, except US Treasuries
23/10/2019  The days of 8 per cent yields are gone but there are bond opportunities to be found in the US and Japan, says M&G's Jim Leaviss.
Where's the recession?
11/10/2019  RBC's Eric Lascelles helps us make sense of the mixed signals in the market today.
Weighing up the Latitude IPO
09/10/2019  High leverage and exposure to lower credit quality are among the reasons why Morningstar analyst Nathan Zaia recommends investors sidestep the Latitude Financial Group float. 
3 stocks with global ambitions
03/10/2019  JPMorgan Global Growth and Income Trust manager Tim Woodhouse picks a drinks firm with a celebrity twist, a European company with global reach and a US insurance giant
History doesn't repeat, but it rhymes
01/10/2019  Lower for longer interest rates, slowing economic growth and a paucity of yield opportunities are nothing new for this seasoned professional Australian stocks investor.
Navigating the risks in credit allocation
27/09/2019  In a lower-for-longer world, understanding the liquidity risks in credit becomes even more vital, says Charlie Jamieson of JCB.
How to position for a trade war stalemate
27/09/2019  Magellan Asset Management's Vihari Ross reveals how the investment powerhouse is positioning for more prolonged trade tensions between China and the US.
Women still lag men in retirement saving. Why?
26/09/2019  Judith Ward from T. Rowe Price reveals which cohorts need to pay more attention to what's happening with their assets - and what they can do.
Can bond yields really predict recession?
18/09/2019  Morningstar Investment Management's Dan Kemp looks at yield-curve inversion and cautions that it may not be a reliable indicator of what's in store for the economy.
Investors are in the eye of the storm
17/09/2019  Markets have weathered the worst of US-China trade tensions, says PineBridge Investments MD Michael Kelly, who also explains why shifting trade patterns aren't all bad news.
Ranking the value opportunities across asset classes
16/09/2019  Cbus chief investment officer Kristian Fok gives Morningstar's Aman Ramrakha his take on the state of global equities, infrastructure and alternatives.
Scaling the emerging markets landscape
12/09/2019  Lazard Asset Management's Rohit Chopra gives his take on the trade war, what he looks for in companies and where some bright spots lie.
Trade war will outlast Trump, warns Lazard
11/09/2019  The world is underestimating the US-China trade war and it will endure beyond the Trump administration, warns Lazard Asset Management's head of US equity Ron Temple.
What happens if everyone indexes?
09/09/2019  Morningstar's director of passive strategies research Alex Bryan discusses some possible consequences.
Afterpay: buy now, regret later?
05/09/2019  The buy now, pay later platform has had an incredible run but new rivals are closing in, says Morningstar's Chanaka Gunasekera. 
Retirees: avoid these traps in turbulent markets
04/09/2019  Recent volatility provides a good reason for retirees to check up on their portfolios--but don't overdo it.
Cheat codes to win at video game investing
03/09/2019  If the thought of spending hours on a video game isn’t appealing, you could always invest in e-sport stocks.
FAANG risks and picking the new consumer staple
28/08/2019  Ariel Investments portfolio manager Rupal Bhansali explains why the market is underestimating the risks to FAANGs and why telco stocks are attractive today.
Downturn is coming: Warnes' warning for investors
27/08/2019  Morningstar head of equity research Peter Warnes identifies the performers of this earning season and issues a warning to investors of what action to take as uncertainty builds.
Are we heading for recession?
26/08/2019  Morningstar Investment Management's Dan Kemp talks inverted bond yield curves and whether a recession is on the cards.
What record low bond yields mean for investors
15/08/2019  A record low for Australia's 10-year bond yield, which last week dipped below 1 per cent, may prompt a change in some investors' fixed-income portfolio positioning, says Brad Bugg.
Looking back at the banks and the best CEOs
15/08/2019  In this Ask the Expert special, David Ellis reflects on his time covering the banking sector, how lenders began to but profits before customers, and why he rates Gail Kelly so highly. 
Examining CBA's 'messy' result
14/08/2019  Morningstar's David Ellis explains why CBA delivered such a 'messy' result and why the home loan book of Australia's largest lender is a strength, not a weakness. 
Pharma, biotech most undervalued US healthcare industries
12/08/2019  These industries are the most undervalued in the US healthcare sector, owing to potential drug pricing reforms coming out of Washington.
Why investment trusts use gearing
08/08/2019  The AIC's Annabel Brodie-Smith talks to Morningstar's Holly Black about the risks and rewards of borrowing for investment trusts.
2 global stocks with investor upside
06/08/2019  Industrial supplier Ingersoll Rand and telco infrastructure company American Tower hold solid investor appeal, explains Alphinity's Jonas Palmqvist.
Change is in the air for global stocks
05/08/2019  Consumer cyclical stocks may tick upward in the coming months, though earnings downgrades still outnumber upgrades for now, says global equity portfolio manager Jonas Palmqvist.
2 US stocks to harness the "green rush"
30/07/2019  With cannabis' popularity already growing, widening legalisation will further catalyse demand.
Iron ore prices won’t stay high for long, warns Morningstar
24/07/2019  Miners Iluka and Oz Minerals still hold upside potential, even as investor optimism on iron ore prices is over-done and coal producers  emerge as greater value, explains Morningstar’s Mat Hodge.  
Harley Davidson too slow at winning new customers
23/07/2019  Morningstar has slashed its fair value estimate for Harley Davidson, as the iconic motorcycle manufacturer's core customer base declines faster than it can target new buyers.
CBA to put bad year behind it
19/07/2019  The Commonwealth Bank has better times ahead, says Morningstar's David Ellis, who predicts a strong recovery in earnings, which will flow through to modestly higher dividends.
AMP dismay is well-founded, says Morningstar
17/07/2019  AMP appears to be stuck with its life insurance business after regulators scuttled the sale, which is likely to further restrict the group’s struggling wealth management operations.
Looking at Amazon's future beyond Prime Day
16/07/2019  In the midst of Amazon's annual Prime Day, which ends on 16 August US-time, Morningstar looks at the online behemoth's long-term plans.