Is active or passive better in bond investing? |
Tweet | ![]() |
<p><strong>Christine Benz</strong>: Hi, I'm Christine Benz for Morningstar.com. Do active bond fund managers actually exhibit skill, or have they simply made profitable bets on risky areas? Joining me to discuss some research on that topic is Alex Bryan. He is director of passive strategies research for Morningstar in North America.</p>
<p>Alex, thank you so much for being here.</p>
<p><strong>Alex Bryan</strong>: Thank you for having me.</p>
<p><strong>Benz</strong>: Alex, let's start with a basic question. A lot of investors compare their active, say, intermediate-term bond fund with the Bloomberg Barclays Aggregate Index. But that's maybe not such a great benchmark for comparison, right?</p>
<p><strong>Bryan</strong>: That's right. The Bloomberg Barclays Aggregate Bond Index, otherwise known as the Agg, weights its holdings based on market value. What that does is it tilts it pretty heavily toward low-yielding US Treasury securities as well as agency mortgage-backed securities.</p>
<p>Those two areas of the market actually account for about two thirds of the Agg Index. If you think about the way that most active bond managers in the intermediate-term bond category invest, they tend to take a bit more credit risk as a way of earning higher returns. The benchmark isn't necessarily representing the waters where active managers are fishing.</p>
<p><strong>Benz</strong>: You did some research where you attempted to look at what kind of risk-taking is going on. You mentioned that overweight in credit is one of the common ways that active managers try to get ahead. But let's talk about how you were systematic in assessing where the active fund managers were taking risks.</p>
<p><strong>Bryan</strong>: What I did was I looked at the performance of all active managers in the Morningstar intermediate-term bond category. I tried to explain their performance as a function of a few different common types of risk exposures that they might take.</p>
<p>For example, looking at credit risk and interest-rate risk to see if those types of common sources of risk could explain the returns that we see active managers earning over time. <br />What I found was that in fact active managers did tend to take a bit more credit and interest-rate risk over the last 10 and 15 years than the Barclays Aggregate Bond Index as you would expect.</p>
<p>Now, they have dialed down their interest-rate risk a bit over the last five years as you might expect as a lot of managers are concerned about rising rates, but they still have a pretty big structural overweight to credit risk. They are not necessarily taking the same types of risk that the benchmark is.</p>
<p><strong>Benz</strong>: Your idea, your goal, in doing this research was to assess whether active bond fund managers have actually exhibited skill, or have they simply made profitable bets on risky areas that paid off well for them. What was your overall conclusion?</p>
<p><strong>Bryan</strong>: If you look at the performance of active managers against the Barclays Aggregate Bond Index, their performance has actually not been that bad. It's actually been an easier benchmark to beat than most broad equity market indexes.</p>
<p>For example, if you look over the last decade or so, about 47 per cent of all active managers that existed as of May of 2008, went on to survive and beat the index. Now, if you control for the risk using the model that I've built, that outperformance rate falls from 47 per cent to about 35 per cent.</p>
<p>There are a lot of managers out there that did exhibit some skill, but that number of managers is actually smaller than the number of managers who were able to beat the benchmark.</p>
<p>Because a lot of managers who beat the benchmark did so with very consistent structural overweights to credit risk, and that's not necessarily skill; that's just taking on more risk. Sometimes, that pays off as it has over the last decade, but it may not always pay off.</p>
<p>The more important point is that if I want to structural overweight to credit, I can get that more cheaply with an ETF that overweights riskier areas of the bond market such as corporate bonds, for example.</p>
<p><strong>Benz</strong>: When you look at this research, who does it say to you in terms of the counsel that you would provide to investors who are attempting to decide--should I just buy some sort of a bond market index fund and call it a day, or should I buy an active bond fund?</p>
<p><strong>Bryan</strong>: Starting out with the broad index fund for exposure to bonds is not a bad starting point. It tends to be less risky than what you get most active bond managers. If you are looking for a more defensive way of diversifying away from equities, something like the Bloomberg Barclays Aggregate Bond Index is not a bad starting point.</p>
<p>Now, that being said, if you are looking to do a little bit better in terms overall returns or performance, there are active managers out there that do have skill. But it's important to go beyond just looking at their track record, because a lot of the returns can from risk-taking.</p>
<p>Like I said, that doesn't always pay off. It's important to look at the types of risks that your active manager is taking and assess whether or not the manager is actually providing some value-add beyond just taking greater credit or interest-rate risk.</p>
<p>One way that I would advise investors who are considering an active manager to go about screening these managers is look for managers who have a decent track record, but who also have a positive Morningstar Analyst Rating, who have a positive process pillar rating.</p>
<p>We are looking for managers that have a differentiated way of investing where they are able to generate higher returns not just from risk-taking but doing things that you can't replicate on your own through lower-cost index options.</p>
<p>You can be successful either with an active fund or with an index fund, but if you are going to hire an active manager, you really need to pay attention to the types of risks that you are getting and make sure that the manager is not just loading up on risks that have paid off well over the last five years or so.</p>
<p><strong>Benz</strong>: Right. And of course, keeping an eye on costs is important if you are going with an active fund, too.</p>
<p><strong>Bryan</strong>: Exactly, yes. Costs absolutely still matter here. Even if you are able to identify a skilled manager, if the price of the fund is too high, you may end up giving away all of your excess returns. It's very important to look for low-cost funds. Those tend to give you a better chance of success.</p>
<p><strong>Benz</strong>: I know in previous research we found a correlation with higher costs and greater risk-taking?</p>
<p><strong>Bryan</strong>: Yes, that's actually not surprising because in order to make up that expense ratio you'd have to earn higher returns. One of the easiest ways to do that is to take more risk because over time that tends to work out but not always.</p>
<p><strong>Benz</strong>: Thank you so much for being here. Great research.</p>
<p><strong>Bryan</strong>: Thank you for having me.</p>
<p><strong>Benz</strong>: Thanks for watching. I'm Christine Benz for Morningstar.com.</p>

04/07/2022 Rebalancing, tax-loss selling, and buying on the dip are among the productive moves to consider.

04/07/2022 Growth jitters and the possiblity of reduced iron ore demand in China have swiped the heavyweight banking and resources sectors.

01/07/2022 Morningstar equity analyst Jon Mills explains royalty rate hikes and how the changes impact Australian miners.

29/06/2022 Firetrail's head of investment strategy talks through his global equity picks in the sustainable space.

28/06/2022 While the benefits of the current model are modest, a demerger won't deliver shareholders an automatic win, says Morningstar equity analyst Nathan Zaia.

24/06/2022 "I think over the next sort of, three, six, nine months, we're going to see some pretty good opportunities emerge, and I think investors who are well prepared will be able to take advantage of that."

23/06/2022 Policy will continue to fuel short-term price movements but the long-term fundamentals for Australia's biggest export look shaky.

17/06/2022 The founder of Investors Mutual is cool on Australia's banking giants.

15/06/2022 Faster interest rate hikes from the Reserve Bank have markets worried about bad debts, says Morningstar banking analyst Nathan Zaia.

14/06/2022 Highly likely investors are on the cusp of an era of permanently higher rates that should favour "real-world companies", says Andrew Clifford, co-chief investment officer at Platinum Asset Management.

14/06/2022 Build cash and prepare for opportunistic nibbles at companies such as Aurizon, Wesfarmers and James Hardie, says Morningstar's head of equity research.

10/06/2022 We haven't seen the bottom of the bear market yet, says Morningstar's head of equity research.

01/06/2022 Earnings growth remains market leading for wide moat stocks like Alphabet, Meta Platforms and Amazon.

30/05/2022 Labor looks set to proceed incrementally and existing producers such as Whitehaven Coal could even benefit should more radical policy be proposed.

25/05/2022 The Nobel prize winner who cameo'd alongside Selena Gomez in Hollywood hit The Big Short discusses the latest developments in behavioural economics.

19/05/2022 Local investors were spooked after US retail giants Target and Walmart plummeted overnight as rising prices hit margins and inventory.

19/05/2022 On his recent visit to Australia, Morningstar's global chief investment officer Dan Kemp talks investing narratives, confronting the growing list of reasons to be concerned about markets and sustainable investing.

19/05/2022 Worries about inflation’s toll on earnings sparks Wednesday’s 4% plunge, but stocks are now far undervalued.

18/05/2022 One of the big themes of the year has been the value comeback. What is behind this resurgence after a pretty dismal period, and should your portfolio be tilting in its direction?

11/05/2022 Here's what investors who are worried about a recession should consider today.

11/05/2022 Morningstar analysts have identified TPG telecom as the most undervalued telecom stocks in the ASX 200 detailing multiple catalysts for earnings recovery and growth.

29/04/2022 Exclusive: Hermitage Capital Management CEO Bill Browder talks Putin, Russia, and the next six months for Ukraine

28/04/2022 Inflation, rising interest rates, geopolitical risks, and other things to keep your eye on.

27/04/2022 Morningstar's analyst talks about the Buffett's recent deals, what the stock is worth, and whether Berkshire will pay a dividend any time soon.

31/03/2022 Supply disruptions following Russia's invasion of Ukraine are forcing analysts to consider the possibility elevated prices persist.

30/03/2022 Rising interest rates, strong economic growth and cheaper valuations are driving banking stocks ahead of the broader market.

28/03/2022 Where are entertainment and streaming services headed?

24/03/2022 Problems in global supply chains are an opportunity for WiseTech as its logistics company customers move to replace old software.

23/03/2022 Markets focused on floods and bushfires are missing how insurers are cutting costs, doing more digitally and are looking down the barrel of a lift in investment income.

17/03/2022 Morningstar Investment Management's global CIO Dan Kemp explains why well-intentioned investors desperate for peace in Europe are making dangerous market calls

15/03/2022 Knowledge of the local market, strong branding and a growing subscription service should see the undervalued retailer retain market share in the rapidly growing online sales category, says Roy Van Keulen.

08/03/2022 Higher inflation, rising interest rates and booming commodity markets are driving a major rotation away from the post-pandemic winners, says Tim Murphy, Morningstar director of manager selection.

03/03/2022 Regulators are likely to be less lenient now the buy-now-pay-later sector is part of the fabric of Australian payments.

23/02/2022 Strong commodity prices, cheap valuations and a head start on interest rate hikes means emerging markets are set for strength, says Dr. Joseph Lai of Ox Capital.

23/02/2022 A belligerent speech from a president signalled the start of the latest phase of Russian agression last night, causing markets to wobble and investors to wonder.

15/02/2022 In an extended interview, Morningstar's Peter Warnes discusses the bear market in US technology stocks, interest rates and growth and his approach to investing outside the US and Australia.

13/02/2022 Morningstar equity analyst Shaun Ler explains why he see valuation upside high for MFG even as shares lose steam.

31/01/2022 The Chinese lunar year is almost over, and what a ride it's been. Morningstar speaks to JPMorgan Asset Management strategist Mike Bell about what's ahead.

23/01/2022 Christine Benz discusses how investors should handle the turmoil, whatever the life stage.

18/01/2022 Empty shelves will negatively impact supermarkets in the second half of fiscal 2022 but the impact on long-term earnings is minimal, says Morningstar analyst Johannes Faul.

17/01/2022 Bank earnings, house prices and China risk: Our experts and analysts discuss what they've got their eyes on in 2022.

24/12/2021 Our experts and analysts weigh in on what mattered for investors last year.

21/12/2021 New products, lower fees and a portfolio of undervalued stocks set to help the fund manager right the ship.

10/12/2021 And how does it match up against gold?

10/12/2021 Australian miners to be among the last standing as coal use fades.

08/12/2021 Rebalancing your portfolio is one of those beneficial habits that’s easy to let slide. But year-end is an ideal time to check how your portfolio is tracking against your target asset allocation.

03/12/2021 The gold-rated fund manager shares three ideas with long-term potential.

01/12/2021 Long-term investor sees opportunities where businesses are moving towards a zero-carbon future faster than governments.

30/11/2021 To understand your fund, get to know its underlying index.

29/11/2021 These companies are set to profit from the move to clean energy, says Lazard.

24/11/2021 The results of the COP26 climate summit suggest coal demand is likely to persist for longer than expected.

17/11/2021 And how investors can protect their portfolios.

08/11/2021 Morningstar thinks these moaty companies will remain resilient in the face of inflation and ongoing supply chain challenges.

05/11/2021 Morningstar maintains fair value despite a fall in margins and slower progress on cost reductions.

19/10/2021 These new US-listed exchange-traded funds will invest in bitcoin futures, not bitcoin itself.

15/10/2021 The ESG outperformance narrative is flawed, new research shows.

06/10/2021 Investors may need to hold more growth assets over the coming years, says Morningstar's Jody Fitzgerald.

01/10/2021 And how G8 Education and Link Administration are positioned for long-term success.

30/09/2021 What Reporting Season August 2021 told investors about the health of the financials sector.

28/09/2021 a2 milk is an opportunity to be greedy when others are fearful.

23/09/2021 Covid's winners and losers are returning to their prior trajectories.

21/09/2021 Sequence-of-returns risk matters for both retirees and savers. Here's why.

20/09/2021 Analysts expect the sector to recover to pre-Covid trading levels once borders reopen.

15/09/2021 Rising customer deposits and access to cheap funding helped Australia's banks stave off net interest margin pressure, but analysts see warning signs.

14/09/2021 Morningstar's Hortense Bioy on how to spot greenwashing and how to avoid it.

13/09/2021 Utilities and infrastructure names battle the impact of covid as private equity and pension funds circle.

10/09/2021 Hydrocarbons poised for a comeback.

09/09/2021 Providers have lifted prices after years of a debilitating chase for subscribers at all costs , says Morningstar's Brian Han.

08/09/2021 What shorting ETFs means for long-term investors.

07/09/2021 Morningstar senior analyst Grant Slade says Brambles secular growth trend is intact despite nearterm headwinds. He discusses results from the building and construction materials sector.

03/09/2021 Miners bask in the glow of iron ore prices while bargains remain in coal.

23/08/2021 Post-merger Woodside would be well positioned to deliver on the value we've seen for a long time, say Morningstar analysts.

16/08/2021 But the sector lacks uniformity, says Morningstar's Christopher Franz.

11/08/2021 Higher wholesale electricity prices bode well for AGL, according to Morningstar senior equities analyst Adrian Atkins.

11/08/2021 Morningstar FundInvestor editor Russ Kinnel describes some direct and indirect hedges for inflation protection.

10/08/2021 Copper and iron ore have benefited materially from China’s stimulus and the developed world recovery. But Morningstar analyst Mat Hodge see these benefit as transitory.

05/08/2021 We believe the transaction has a high chance of succeeding.

03/08/2021 The industry still has significant growth potential.

03/08/2021 Is one of the biggest sponsors of the Olympics positioned for an all-electric future?

23/07/2021 Morningstar's Lex Hall talks micro-cap stock picks with Carlos Gil, chief investment officer at Microequities Asset Management.

22/07/2021 Mornngstar's Lex Hall catches up with Carlos Gil, chief investment officer at Microequities Asset Management.

21/07/2021 The head of Australian small and mid-cap stocks at First Sentier Investors has her eye on ARB, Breville and IDP Education.

20/07/2021 The strong performances of global stock markets in 2020–21 are unlikely to be repeated in the coming year says Morningstar's Peter Warnes.

12/07/2021 Morningstar equity analysts warn that equities remain overvalued despite Australia's strong economic recovery.

08/07/2021 Private equity is an exciting area for investors, with lots of hotly-tipped stocks. But there are risks to be aware of, says Pitchbook analyst Dylan Cox.

08/07/2021 Warryn Robertson is looking at French infrastructure, retail pharmacy and tax services.

06/07/2021 Australia's largest banks have excess capital because they cut dividends, were more conservative on lending, divested assets and raised equity last year. Morningstar's Nathan Zaia thinks most of it should be returned to shareholders.

02/07/2021 PEXA burst onto the ASX this week in the biggest float since 2019. Morningstar's Gareth James gives his take on the company's future growth prospects.

30/06/2021 Iron ore prices have been on a tear, boosting the profits of Australia's top miners. How did we get here and is the only way up? Lex Hall sits down with Morningstar's Mat Hodge.

28/06/2021 Morningstar has recently initiated coverage of a food delivery app and a consumer finance product.

24/06/2021 Meeting the deluge of demand is the biggest task for US companies, says Bell Asset Management's Ned Bell.

22/06/2021 Are there still opportunities in the biotech sector now the covid-19 vaccine roll out is underway? We ask International Biotechnology Trust manager Ailsa Craig

21/06/2021 Morningstar's director of Asia equity research is confident the e-commerce giant will bounce back.

18/06/2021 A wide moat and attractive dividend potential are among the key takeaways of Woolworth's decision to demerge from the liquor and hospitality group.

15/06/2021 Lazard Asset Management's Warryn Robertson explains how companies in the Global Equity Franchise fund have adjusted to covid, and assesses the threat of rising inflation.

11/06/2021 Magellan's Craig Wright tells Emma Rapaport why it is leading the charge in the active ETF arena and how its global equity product works.

10/06/2021 Callum Burns of ICE Investors explains his conviction in pharmaceutical distributor Ebos, PSC Insurance Group, and elite sports analytics provider Catapult.

09/06/2021 Callum Burns explains how ICE Investors identifies companies with original products and sticky customer bases.

08/06/2021 They’re building an empire.

07/06/2021 A year ago the oil price went negative. How have oil giants handled the past 12 months and what's the outlook from here? Morningstar analyst Allen Good explains.