Learn To Invest
Stocks Special Reports LICs Credit Funds ETFs Tools SMSFs
Video Archive Article Archive
News Stocks Special Reports Funds ETFs Features SMSFs Learn


Seeking (Cyber)Security in uncertain times

Mark Cash  |  31 Aug 2020Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  
Email to Friend

For investors seeking both revenue growth and relative stability, cybersecurity has been a reprieve from the uncertainty of the global pandemic.

The rise in remote working and distributed networking environments created a complex situation for security teams that we believe exposed holes in entities’ threat-prevention capabilities. Exacerbating the challenge, cyberattacks have grown exponentially in recent months, with the FBI reporting a 400 per cent increase in complaints in April versus March, as attackers hope to expose weaknesses in an organization’s business continuity strategy. Also, data privacy laws have become much more punitive with regard to security missteps, and we do not expect any leeway amid a global pandemic.

Because of the rise of remote working, adoption of cloud-based security has accelerated, and we do not expect this trend to revert after workers return to offices. Before widespread shutdowns, these security solutions were gaining momentum because of technological efficacy and proximity to where data and threats were migrating. In our view, shutdowns caused IT teams to pivot their security solutions to trusted, more nascent cloud-based versions because of the ease of deployment, management, and protection for remote individuals and resources.

Purely cloud-based cybersecurity companies CrowdStrike (CRWD), Okta (OKTA), and Zscaler (ZS) have showcased excellent results in the face of market chaos, and we expect demand to remain resilient. We believe these companies with narrow moats and positive moat trends are winners in their segments as more cloud-based solutions are adopted. However, their stocks have appreciated significantly since widespread shelter-in-place orders began early in the pandemic, and the buying opportunities we saw in March have evaporated.

We find a more attractive investment opportunity with Palo Alto Networks (PANW) and believe that investors could be overlooking how incumbent stalwarts are finding robust growth avenues as well. Important similarities between the leading incumbents and the new, rapidly growing cloud-based companies are pristine balance sheets and solid cash flow that can provide investors with security in uncertain times. In our view, Palo Alto has built out a leading security platform that covers various aspects of enterprise threat protection, including its migration of offering cloud-based alternatives to its core firewall expertise. Ensuring compliance and consistency across on-premises and cloud environments is challenging, and we believe customers will prefer Palo Alto’s holistic offering for network protection.

In addition to its robust push into cloud-based security and security for protecting cloud workloads, we view Palo Alto’s leading automation capabilities as a game changer in the long run. We expect enterprises to shift their external managed security spending toward internal automation capabilities, which we consider a critical element in helping enterprises respond to the daily deluge of alerts amid a security talent dearth. Palo Alto’s broad-based security platform provides natural up- and cross-selling opportunities, which we believe becomes a powerful margin lever in the long term.

COVID-19 amplified cloud-based security firms’ winning position

We believe the cybersecurity market is poised to grow at a high-single-digit pace in the long term. In 2020, we expect cybersecurity to grow slightly year over year and remain better insulated than overall IT demand, which should contract amid macroeconomic headwinds. However, we see a mix shift in cybersecurity spending in the near term toward cloud-based cybersecurity solutions and security products that protect cloud workloads.

Investing Compass
Listen to Morningstar Australia's Investing Compass podcast
Take a deep dive into investing concepts, with practical explanations to help you invest confidently.
Investing Compass

The adoption of cloud-based cybersecurity has been a boon to CrowdStrike, Okta, and Zscaler. These companies, leaders in their subsegments of the fragmented cybersecurity market, have significantly outpaced legacy companies through threat-protection efficacy, ease of deployment and management, and enabling secure business continuity in dispersed work environments. The pandemic forced widespread shelter-in-place orders, spurring a dramatic increase in cyberattacks attempting to prey on users outside a secure perimeter, which we believe may have been an eye-opening experience for security teams that had been reluctant to embrace the new wave of cloud-based security solutions.

Workers will eventually return to offices, but we expect the adoption of cloud-based security protection to remain in place. These solutions that protect users, devices, and data were purposely built for the rise in using cloud-based resources and the dissipation of a defined security perimeter. We expected cloud-based security to be a dominant trend in the market; we believe that COVID-19 may have accelerated the adoption of these vendors’ solutions and that this growth will be resilient.

CrowdStrike, Okta, and Zscaler excel at endpoint protection, identity and access management, and secure web gateways, respectively. All three have solidified customer switching costs as a moat source with their mission-critical solutions. Okta’s cloud network of application integrations and CrowdStrike’s crowdsourced threat-prevention cloud caused us to award both companies a network effect moat source, too. Alongside breakneck revenue growth coming from revolutionizing their respective segments, these companies showcase incredible retention metrics. We believe these companies are land-and-expand operations, whereby profuse amounts of cash are poured into developing and marketing a unique technology to land customers. Clients typically proliferate subscriptions throughout their organization, and security companies develop adjacent offerings to up- and cross-sell, helping maximize dollars per customer, expand margins, and produce sustainable excess returns over invested capital.

Other narrow-moat pure-play cybersecurity companies include Check Point Software (CHKP), Fortinet (FTNT), and Palo Alto Networks. Their network security products and tangential solutions fortified customer switching costs, in our view. Although these companies are more mature than the cloud-based companies, we still expect cloud-based security trends to provide rapid growth avenues, especially for Palo Alto and Fortinet.

Cybersecurity moats bolstered by increased remote work

CrowdStrike, Okta, and Zscaler provide mission-critical solutions to protect users and devices from the daily deluge of attacks, and replacing them could be terribly disruptive. Torrid growth as their wares become more widely accepted, combined with incredible renewal rates and land-and-expand opportunities, gives us confidence in their ability to earn excess returns on invested capital over the long haul. Equally important for investors is that we believe these companies are in the early stages of changing their subsegments, and each has an appreciable head start against incumbents and upstarts.

We also like these cybersecurity specialists’ ability to extract additional revenue per customer over time. These companies have consistently showcased dollar-based net retention levels around 120 per cent while rapidly expanding their customer bases. In our view, an impressive element of this performance is that these companies are landing more lucrative initial deal sizes with larger customers, which challenges the dollar-based retention metric over time. These cloud-based solutions are rapidly becoming more widely accepted by the industry as enterprises across all sectors and governments are finding value in their offerings, creating more potential customers to look into these new ways of performing security.

These companies have various ways to initially land a customer with their security platform approaches that allow for robust cross- and up-selling opportunities. Security platforms offer various product modules that sit under a common theme. In most cases, customers will try new security solutions within a certain team or location before rolling it out to the wider organization, and platforms allow companies to try subsets of a cybersecurity firm’s offerings before adopting multiple solutions. We believe the platform approach of selling various security modules, initially or over time, is a powerful concept that is being strongly adopted with customers since it helps alleviate the number of security tool sets that enterprises need to manage simultaneously. For the security vendors, this creates powerful customer switching costs with robust recurring revenue streams, as companies are locked into an ecosystem for mission-critical elements of their threat-prevention capabilities.

WFH here for the time being

While most workers will return to offices eventually, we do not view the rise in cloud-based security technologies as an ephemeral trend. We believe that entities have accelerated their adoption of cloud-based cybersecurity and that the demand for these solutions will be sustained. In our view, the coronavirus pandemic may have been a wakeup call for many enterprises contemplating next-generation security solutions to protect the distributed nature of today’s networks, which are already hybrid-cloud ecosystems that use a mixture of public and private clouds, on-premises, and edge location resources that dissipate what was once a well-established security perimeter. The increase in remote work made the hybrid-cloud concept that security teams were growing accustomed to protecting even further spread out. Malicious actors began crafting emails that seemed like corporate remote access policy information or healthcare updates, taking advantage of people outside a secure work perimeter.

A key tenet of adopting the offerings of pure cloud vendors, outside of technological capabilities that showcase superior threat defence, is the ease of deploying and holistically managing threats for an employee base. In our view, the simplicity of deploying such security measures in a rapidly evolving threat environment accelerated the trend of choosing these products. By only selling software subscriptions, alongside services, the cloud-based vendors enable customers to adopt these solutions quickly, without requiring employees to install or configure appliances on-premises. In our view, once installed, these solutions will stay in place as a core component of protection even after users return to the office.

We believe that enterprises’ security protocols are rapidly becoming a zero-trust environment, whereby every employee is treated like an unknown person who could be malicious. This shift in security mindset is important since the previously defined secure perimeter is dissolving. Today, corporate data and resources are freely traversing outside the perimeter, and cloud-based solutions help security teams ensure that people and data remain protected irrespective of where someone is requesting data. The traditional solution for remote access was to provide employees with a virtual private network connection. VPNs have been highly demanded to allow remote workers access to data centre resources; however, these products can provide users with too much access and are notorious for dragging down performance. While VPNs will probably not disappear from the security environment, we believe the adoption of a zero-trust security architecture has been accelerated alongside the high demand of cloud-based security to the benefit of names like CrowdStrike, Okta, and Zscaler.

Cybersecurity players 

Cybersecurity name

Source: Morningstar Premium; data as at 31 August 2020

Finding security in a downturn

Cybersecurity is a much younger industry than the traditional safe harbors investors flock to in times of uncertainty. The risk of investing in a rapidly changing environment with an influx of market entrants attempting to unseat incumbents could seem too risky compared with investing in companies with decades of operating history that have previously weathered downturns. But we believe that sentiment changed drastically during the pandemic, and various cybersecurity companies can be seen as a refuge from the uncertainty.

In our view, cybersecurity, especially via moaty companies, has become a haven for investors seeking growth and business sustainability. Pristine balance sheets flush with cash with limited, if any, obligations are supported by healthy free cash flow. The moaty companies have copious amounts of recurring and deferred revenue, creating predictability and providing comfort around business health.

The remote work effect has not broadly affected cloud-based product demand beyond potentially slowing new customer trials or customers attempting to preserve their spending because of budget constrictions. Malicious actors do not stop developing threats or attacking entities because of global uncertainty; rather, we believe these are times when threats are ramped up to expose constrained budgets and personnel. And enterprises do not have a reprieve from data privacy legislation regulating security measures and the associated steep fines for breaches and missteps.

We view global uncertainty and the heightened demand for remote work solutions as a boon to cloud-based security companies. Cybersecurity spending drivers, fuelled by protecting workers from threats and preventing internal and customer data exposures, and the associated fines for missteps, are largely insulated from other IT budget cuts that enterprises may consider, in our view. The cloud-based security demand is evident in the pure cloud-based security companies’ robust quarterly results and the strong guidance they’ve issued while the pandemic’s economic impact plays out.

Although IT budgets are likely to be slashed broadly in 2020 as companies conserve cash and delay infrastructure upgrades, we expect cybersecurity to largely be spared. While we believe the shift to the cloud is going to affect the deployment of on-premises products, we still model a recovery for critical security products like firewalls next year; however, that firewall rebound could be seen through enterprises adopting more virtual or as-a-service versions. We do not expect other on-premises products like secure email gateways or endpoint security management to fare as well and expect cloud to eventually consume the on-premises deployment options. Security for ensuring compliance and visibility into cloud-based workloads should remain a hotly demanded market, in our view, on top of the trend of enterprises demanding more cloud-delivered security products.

In addition to enterprises demanding and consuming more solutions off-premises, we believe this will drive a trend of security vendors relying on subscriptions instead of perpetual offerings. In our view, enterprises have become accustomed to consuming cloud-based resources as operating expenses and would favour this model over sizable capital expenditures. This consumption trend has no impact on the pure cloud-based security vendors, as they solely offer subscriptions. We expect the incumbent networking security vendors to gradually adjust their business models to offer subscriptions for cloud-based products but offer a choice for traditional hardware purchases. At the expense of less up-front revenue and cash flow, this creates a more recurring and predictable inflow for organizations. In our view, incumbents changing their sales model keeps customers from changing vendors and is the correct action for long-term business sustainability.



is a Morningstar equity analyst.

© 2022 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Neither Morningstar, its affiliates, nor the content providers guarantee the data or content contained herein to be accurate, complete or timely nor will they have any liability for its use or distribution. This information is to be used for personal, non-commercial purposes only. No reproduction is permitted without the prior written consent of Morningstar. Any general advice or 'regulated financial advice' under New Zealand law has been prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), or its Authorised Representatives, and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. For more information, refer to our Financial Services Guide (AU) and Financial Advice Provider Disclosure Statement (NZ). Our publications, ratings and products should be viewed as an additional investment resource, not as your sole source of information. Morningstar’s full research reports are the source of any Morningstar Ratings and are available from Morningstar or your adviser. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product's future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a licensed financial adviser. Some material is copyright and published under licence from ASX Operations Pty Ltd ACN 004 523 782. The article is current as at date of publication.

Email To Friend