Afterpay: buy now, regret later? |
-- |
05/09/2019
Text size 
| 
|
| Tweet |  |
<p><strong>Lex Hall: </strong>Hi, I'm Lex Hall for Morningstar and welcome to another edition of "Ask the Expert." Today's subject is Afterpay, the buy now, pay later company that's become a household name and had an incredible run since it first listed on the Australian Stock Exchange in 2017. And with me today to talk about it is Morningstar analyst, Chanaka Gunasekera, who began coverage of it this week.</p>
<p>Good day, Chanaka.</p>
<p><strong>Chanaka Gunasekera:</strong> Hi. How are you doing, Lex?</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>Good. I'm well. Thanks. Now, Afterpay listed, as I said, in June 2017 at the price of $2.95. Today, it's worth more than $32. That's a rise of 1,000%, putting it into sort of 10-bagger, that mythical 10-bagger status. Before we get into the incredible run, how does the model work? Can you just run us through that?</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera:</strong> Sure. It's a buy now, pay later model. And so, a customer would go into a merchant, say, Harvey Norman or another merchant and want to buy something. Usually, the sale price on average is about $150. They will go there, and at the point-of-sale terminal, they will get their mobile phone with the Afterpay app, get the Afterpay app downloaded, and then buy the product and initially, they will pay a 25% installment. And then over the next two weeks, they will pay 25% each two weeks until they pay off the amount. And they'll pay nothing to Afterpay if they pay on time. If they are late, they may get a late fee. But primarily, Afterpay gets paid by the merchant via a margin.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>And they've got, I think, it's 3.5 million Australians using it and about 28,000 shops they say?</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera:</strong> Yeah, they've had a rapid growth in customers as well as merchants. It's really resonating with both customers, primarily the millennium customer, the younger market. And also, because merchants are saying that their customers are buying more and transacting more frequently and by higher dollar value amounts, merchants are attracted to it as well.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>Because it allows them to move more stock as well?</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera:</strong> Correct. Yes.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>And it's a modern form of laybuy, something that's been around for a long time, right?</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera:</strong> Yeah, sort of digital form of laybuy, except for the fact that you get the product straightaway.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>OK. And part of the growth is tied to their expansion overseas, I understand?</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera:</strong> Yes, the US and the UK are probably going to be their near-term growth drivers. They've been in the US for about a little bit over a year now and they've had significant growth. Their growth in the US, finance sales growth, has been at a faster rate than they experienced here in Australia.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>OK.</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera:</strong> Initial results in the UK. – they've been in the UK for about 15 weeks, or a little bit more, and they're growing clients strongly there as well. So, the initial – it's only early days, of course, in the UK, but its growth is strong there as well.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>And just to give you an idea of the growth, its growth trajectory, it's $2.2 billion in financed sales in 2018. That's more than doubled to $5.5 billion in financed sales in 2019. And fiscal 2022, they're aiming for…?</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera:</strong> $20 billion plus.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>$20 billion plus. That's a pretty, pretty…</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera:</strong> Massive growth. Yes, exactly. And that's why it's getting a lot of traction by investors I suspect.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>OK. Let's get to your valuation. It's over $32 today. You've got at $22. It's a 2-Star stock.</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera: </strong>Yes.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>What are your reasons for it being overvalued like that?</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera: </strong>We think it's going to experience significant finance sales growth. However, there's some material business risk it also faces. I think first of all is near term there's going to be some more direct competition towards buy now, pay later product. You're seeing that in organisations like FlexiGroup. They're introducing two new buy now, pay later products, which are likely to compete directly with Afterpay's. You're seeing overseas companies like Klarna, the Commonwealth Bank recently invested US$100 million in Klarna.</p>
<p>And then, more recently, in the last few days, Latitude teaming up with Harvey Norman to introduce another buy now, pay later product, and they're going to compete very heavily on the merchant fees. So, those are near-term risks. And also, they rely heavily on the equity and debt markets to find strong sales growth. Now, they've got support from the equity market, primarily because they've been growing so strongly. But obviously, if they don't meet growth expectations, then that could be a risk. And also, because they're growing customers, retail customers, rapidly, they're also seeing a fair bit of scrutiny regulators, the most recent being AUSTRAC, which has asked them to appoint an auditor to look at their – any money laundering and risk management processes. So, that's a report that's going to be announced very shortly.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>OK. And what's Afterpay doing to sort of combat those rivals? I understand it's in a tie-up with Visa.</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera: </strong>Yeah. It announced only very recently that in the US they've signed an agreement with Visa. They haven't really provided much detail about that yet. It was only announced a few weeks ago at their earnings announcement. So, there's very scant detail on that. In relation to competition, what they're trying to do now is grow scale rapidly. And so, what they're focusing on is the enterprise, the larger merchants who have more customers. Now, the problem with that is that those large merchants, they could charge those merchants a lower fee. So, it's probably less than 3 per cent, whereas the small to medium businesses, they can charge a higher fee, 4 per cent plus. So, yeah.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>Right. And just getting back to that merchant fee and the tie-up between the Latitude and Harvey Norman, I think you were saying that they're aiming to sort of take on Afterpay by charging a very low fee.</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera: </strong>Correct. Yes. Very small amounts, very low indeed. And so, in fact, I think it's going to be free for a period of time. So, they are competing very strongly with that. The other thing, the difference with – it's only just been announced, but the difference from what I can read is that also they're going to be subject to Consumer Credit Code, and so they're going to provide more credit checks than Afterpay is providing currently.</p>
<p><strong>Hall: </strong>And despite this astronomical growth, they're still not making a profit as far as I understand.</p>
<p><strong>Gunasekera: </strong>Correct. Yeah, they made a loss this year as well. And so, we expect they'll make a loss – sorry – made a loss in 2019, last financial year, and then, I suspect they'll make a loss this financial year as well and be profitable in the following financial year.</p>
'Then we got hit with the equivalent of a war'15/06/2021 Lazard Asset Management's Warryn Robertson explains how companies in the Global Equity Franchise fund have adjusted to covid, and assesses the threat of rising inflation.
Understanding Magellan's active ETF strategy11/06/2021 Magellan's Craig Wright tells Emma Rapaport why it is leading the charge in the active ETF arena and how its global equity product works.
3 off-the-radar small caps10/06/2021 Callum Burns of ICE Investors explains his conviction in pharmaceutical distributor Ebos, PSC Insurance Group, and elite sports analytics provider Catapult.
Small cap gems and how to find them09/06/2021 Callum Burns explains how ICE Investors identifies companies with original products and sticky customer bases.
Stock of the Week: Salesforce.com08/06/2021 They’re building an empire.
3 oil stocks we still like07/06/2021 A year ago the oil price went negative. How have oil giants handled the past 12 months and what's the outlook from here? Morningstar analyst Allen Good explains.
Considering crypto? Here's what to think about04/06/2021 As the investment world goes crazy for crypto, Morningstar Investment Management's Dan Kemp explains what to consider before putting it in your portfolio
Why we like Wizz Air03/06/2021 The airline sector is set to recover as international travel resumes. Morningstar analysts think Wizz Air offer the best opportunity among low-cost carriers.
3 global infrastructure picks28/05/2021 4D Infrastructure's Sarah Shaw outlines the investment case for Spanish multinationals Cellnex, and Iberdrola, and the potential of Mexican airports.
Are crypto ETFs coming?28/05/2021 The SEC continues to sort out its regulatory concerns.
Stock of the Week: Apple27/05/2021 We’re raising our fair value as sales hit new highs—but investors need to put it in perspective, says Andrew Willis.
Opportunities in global infrastructure25/05/2021 Covid-19 has enhanced rather than impeded the future for global infrastructure, says Sarah Shaw of 4D Infrastructure.
Tribeca's eye for Domain24/05/2021 Tribeca's Jun Bei Liu also explains why she sees opportunity in sleep apnea specialist ResMed as well as Treasury Wine Estates.
Stocks for emerging markets19/05/2021 American Century Investment's Patricia Ribeiro sees growth in Chinese battery technology, biologics, and building materials in Latin America.
2 stocks for the rise of the robots18/05/2021 Robotics is a fast-growing area of tech, creating opportunities in medical, logistics and life sciences sectors and much more.
Square: Stock of the week18/05/2021 Square's Bitcoin purchase is more marketing than operations
Tesla: Stock of the week10/05/2021 If Elon Musk ends up delivering, we might need to raise our fair value to US$1500 a share.
Why Tribeca's so upbeat on stocks07/05/2021 Banks and resources are poised to deliver dividends, and Treasury Wine Estates and BNPL are worth a look, says Jun Bei Liu of Tribeca's Alpha Plus long/short fund.
Looking for value in emerging markets05/05/2021 Digital banking, ecommerce and 5G are among the key trends set for rapid growth, says Patricia Ribeiro of American Century Investments.
Cash slashed, Aussie equities up: Why Morningstar updates Model ETF portfolios04/05/2021 Analysts have made changes to the fixed interest, property, cash and equity allocations of Morningstar's Model ETF Portfolios to take advantage of the current market environment. They've also refreshed some of the funds in the portfolio.
Investing basics: Explaining the disconnect between the stock market and the economy30/04/2021 The stock market and the economy are not the same. Here's why.
Why deforestation matters for investors23/04/2021 EARTH DAY 2021: Why should investors care about deforestation and how can it can be taken into account within an investment portfolio?
The silent killer: How to prepare your portfolio for inflation21/04/2021 Do investors need to worry about inflation, and how do you prep your portfolio to protect you from it? Morningstar Investment Management's Dan Kemp explains.
ESG investing is about more than feeling good: Morningstar equity research20/04/2021 Values-based investing is ultimately up to the investor.
2 US wide-moat stocks to buy on a dip16/04/2021 Amazon.com and ServiceNow are looking increasingly attractive.
Fidelity's Kate Howitt names her 3 top stocks for 202115/04/2021 Investment tips from Australian equities fund manager Kate Howitt.
Back to basics: What is income investing?14/04/2021 What is income investing, why is it important and which investors should focus on it? Morningstar Investment Management's Dan Kemp has the answers.
Hunting for pockets of value in an overheated market: Morningstar13/04/2021 Morningstar equity strategist Gareth James discusses the great value rotation, why he believes the Australian share market is overvalued and where opportunities still lie for hungry investors.
Vaccine rollout drives energy's rise12/04/2021 But the sector's current tailwinds are likely unsustainable, so investors should prioritise high-quality businesses with stable balance sheets, says Morningstar's Dave Meats.
Finding value with Kate Howitt08/04/2021 Kate Howitt oversees Fidelity’s Australian Opportunities fund. She discusses her investing approach, the outlook and where she sees value.
Investing for millennials07/04/2021 Goldman Sachs's Laura Destribats talks about the millennial investment trend, and why tech and experiences are so important to this generation.
What if I want to buy Bitcoin?06/04/2021 Remember that the returns on speculative assets like Bitcoin are high risk
EGG, SGF, ZBRA: Foraging for the unloved gems01/04/2021 Steve Johnson explains why Forager Funds Management has bought and held Enero, SG Fleet and Zebra Technologies and why they're poised for further growth.
Why the 'covid spending economy' will flourish30/03/2021 Forager's Steve Johnson explains why he's bullish on consumer spending, enterprise software companies, and why he has cashed in on big names like Uber.
Proteomics set for growth, says Kardinia29/03/2021 Kristiaan Rehder explains why the West Australian biotech is among the top performers in the Bennelong Kardinia Capital Absolute Return Fund.
Should you be worried about inflation?26/03/2021 And how to make inflation "personal."
Crypto what?25/03/2021 The how, what, and why of cryptocurrency.
The long and short of an absolute return fund24/03/2021 An absolute return fund aims to seek returns in all weather. Kristiaan Rehder from Bennelong Kardinia Capital explains how.
3 dividend-paying real estate stocks for your watchlist23/03/2021 Diversified portfolios, strong balance sheets and healthy payouts. Grant Berry singles out three big contributors to the SG Hiscock Property Income Fund.
AREITs in the time of covid22/03/2021 SG Hiscock's Grant Berry explains how real estate was affected by the pandemic, how property stocks coped, and the chase for income in an evolving retail landscape.
Have we reached peak video gaming?19/03/2021 Video gaming has soared under lockdown, can this sector keep growing post-covid? Morningstar analyst Neil Macker takes a look.
Myer: five stars and poised for the rebound18/03/2021 The retail giant's strong balance sheet will help it navigate the shift to online shopping and capitalise on the return to normal life, says Morningstar's Johannes Faul.
Deliveroo IPO: what you need to know10/03/2021 Ahead of Deliveroo's IPO, Morningstar analyst Ioannis Pontikis looks at the outlook for the business, its valuation and concerns about gig workers.
2 stocks for the e-learning boom08/03/2021 E-learning has become the norm for young students and university-goers across the world. Morningstar analyst Michael Field looks at whether the trend is here to stay.
February Reporting Season Wrap Up with Peter Warnes: Webinar04/03/2021 Special guest Peter Warnes, our head of equities research, joins the Morningstar Foundations of Investing Webinar series to give his unique take on February Reporting Season and answer subscriber questions.
One year after the market crash, through the ETF lens03/03/2021 The growth and adoption of exchange-traded funds has only accelerated as a result of the latest market crisis.
Brighter picture for big four banks01/03/2021 Morningstar's Nathan Zaia on the outlook for the banks, dividend payouts and the move by the Bank of Queensland to acquire ME Bank.
One year on: lessons learned from the 2020 bear market25/02/2021 The biggest takeaway from that period is not to panic when the market tumbles.
What if...I want to buy a gold ETF?23/02/2021 From ETFs backed by bullion to miners with more upside potential - here's how to get yourself some gold.
'Full return to normal in 2021'23/02/2021 If the US is to stage a recovery by mid-year, it will need the consumer services sector to fire, says Morningstar's head of economic research Preston Caldwell.
Google, Facebook versus Aussie news stocks19/02/2021 Morningstar's Brian Han weighs up News Corp's deal with Google and examines the effect of Facebook's decision to block content from Australian media outlets.
Global real estate as a store of value18/02/2021 Quay Global Investors' Chris Bedingfield explains how self-storage, data centres and industrial property can offer diversification and growth.
Spotting the 'covid winners'16/02/2021 Uniti Group and Nextdc are among the companies that SG Hiscock's Hamish Tadgell says have flourished during the pandemic.
The transition from hope to growth15/02/2021 Hamish Tadgell of SG Hiscock explains the portfolio changes he’s made in a bid to capitalise on the shift.
The future of the US economy10/02/2021 Which pandemic-related trends have already passed, and which ones might be around the corner?
GameStop frenzy is history repeating05/02/2021 The battle between the Reddit army and hedge funds is nothing new—the question is will regulators be willing to step in, says Morningstar's John Rekenthaler.
Who are the fast fashion winners?03/02/2021 Competition is fierce for fast fashion retailers such as Asos, H&M, Zalando and Inditex. Morningstar analyst Jelena Sokolova takes a look at the sector.
Can your portfolio withstand volatile times?01/02/2021 Volatility can be around any corner, says Morningstar director of personal finance Christine Benz.
How much equity exposure is too much in retirement?28/01/2021 Retirees require stocks' growth potential, but they need a cash and bond buffer, too.
Key trends for China investors27/01/2021 Rebecca Jiang, manager of the JPMorgan China Growth & Income Trust, looks at why Chinese stocks soared in 2020 and whether the trend can continue.
Redpoint's 3 top picks in industrials25/01/2021 Redpoint's chief executive and portfolio manager Max Cappetta tells Lex Hall why he's got his eye on JB Hi-Fi, Goodman and Reliance Worldwide in 2021.
Looking for growth and income among industrials21/01/2021 Redpoint CEO and portfolio manager Max Cappetta looks at the dividend potential of large-cap names, the resilience of Qantas, and the local tech landscape.
What we expect from oil prices19/01/2021 Stocks still look cheap across all subsectors, especially oilfield services and refining, says Morningstar analyst Dave Meats.
What’s app-ening: investing from your phone19/01/2021 What are the rewards and risks of using this technology?
A Democrat clean sweep and corporate America15/01/2021 Morningstar's head of policy research Aron Szapiro explains what sort of changes a Biden government will make and how they will affect company valuations.
3 stocks for climate transition14/01/2021 Freight-rail, building temperature efficiency, and carmaking are among the sectors Aviva Investors' Jaime Ramos Martin has his eye on.
The outlook for dividends13/01/2021 Dividend investors had a hard time in 2020, but Morningstar analyst Dan Lefkovitz think the outlook is brighter for the year ahead.
3 themes for fund investors in 202111/01/2021 Morningstar Investment Management's Dan Kemp reveals the three investment themes on his mind for the year ahead.
What next for oil and gas companies?06/01/2021 Morningstar equity analyst Allen Good looks at the prospects for oil and gas giants in the year ahead.
China outlook 202105/01/2021 China had a strong year after a rocky start, but can it continue—and what does a US President Biden mean for the region? Morningstar analyst Lorraine Tan explains.
Tech, travel and trends for 202104/01/2021 Morningstar equity director Alex Morozov considers the outlook for tech, travel and beyond for the year ahead.
Money and investment lessons of 202001/01/2021 How to plan for things you can't plan.
Morningstar Year in Review 202025/12/2020 2020: we look back at the highs and lows of an unprecedented year in financial markets and explore the themes shaping 2021.
Are music streaming companies a big hit with investors?22/12/2020 Music streaming companies have seen stellar growth in user numbers. We ask Morningstar equity analyst Neil Macker if the trend can continue.
What Tesla's inclusion in the S&P 500 means for investors21/12/2020 While it stands as the largest addition in the index's history, this likely won't impact everyday investors all that much.
Peter Warnes and the 2021 Forecast18/12/2020 Will there be opportunities to deploy cash in the new year? Will there be a reprieve from covid? And what will the incoming Biden administration mean for markets?
Investing in the climate transition18/12/2020 Companies that specialise in solar, building efficiency and renewables underpin Aviva Investors' Climate Transition Global Equity Fund, says Jaime Ramos Martin.
Why does liquidity matter?16/12/2020 Why does liquidity matter to investors, and how can it affect your returns? Morningstar equities director Tom Whitelaw explains.
Introducing the Morningstar Capital Allocation Rating14/12/2020 Learn what we look for when rating a company.
Incorporating ESG into our equity research process14/12/2020 Morningstar's new approach unpacks the environmental, social and governance risks that companies face.
Tagliaferro: yield ideas for your portfolio10/12/2020 Industrial companies typically generate better cash flows and can offer a steady income stream, says the IML founder.
Anton Tagliaferro on value versus growth09/12/2020 The lofty valuations of Tesla and Afterpay typify the effervescence and speculation in the market, says the IML founder.
Can car companies be ESG investments?08/12/2020 Car makers may not be an obvious investment choice for ESG-conscious investors, but Morningstar analyst Tancrede Fulop says some of the largest companies score highly in some measures such as safety and human capital.
The US and China under president-elect Biden07/12/2020 Janus Henderson's Matt Peron considers how the relationship between the US and China will evolve under a President Biden.
Investing basics: what is active and passive investing?04/12/2020 What is active investing, and what is passive investing? We're at the whiteboard to explain the pros and cons of each
Why we still like Treasury Wine04/12/2020 Treasury Wine Estates remains an undervalued stock in spite of China's demand-destroying tariff on Australian wine. Morningstar director of equity research Adam Fleck explains why.
What is gold worth?03/12/2020 And do any other assets currently compare?
Why now is the time for ESG investing02/12/2020 We're at an inflection point in ESG investing, says Sustainalytics founder Michael Jantzi. Here's why.
10 stocks retail investors bought in covid sell-off01/12/2020 Beaten-down travel stocks and BNPL providers featured heavily, says nabtrade’s Gemma Dale.
How retail investors seized on covid sell-off30/11/2020 Many people were waiting for the opportunity to buy shares at historic discounts, says nabtrade’s Gemma Dale.
AMP: difficulties now, but dividends later27/11/2020 The 171-year-old wealth manager has had its scandals but there's merit to its turnaround strategy and the quality of its other assets, says Morningstar's Shaun Ler.
'Be careful using buy now pay later'27/11/2020 BNPL products such as Zip Co help boost consumer spending but they come with risks and are overvalued, says Morningstar analyst Shaun Ler.
Hamish Douglass: Winners and losers in the covid era26/11/2020 The Magellan co-founder argues the ecommerce acceleration is here to stay and ponders the effect it will have on other sectors such as travel and commercial real estate.
A 'wonderful hunting ground'25/11/2020 Greg Dean of Cambridge Global Asset Management explains why the consumer services sector has yielded healthy returns.
Hamish Douglass and big tech25/11/2020 Magellan's co-founder explains which tech behemoth the Magellan Global Fund no longer owns, why one was too tricky to value, and why regulation is no threat.
Hamish Douglass: 'We're lucky this pandemic hit when it did'24/11/2020 Magellan's co-founder on why 2020 resembles 2000 and why covid-19 is a dry run for something that could be much worse without proper planning.
Should you beef up your exposure to meat processors?23/11/2020 Their shares have gotten hammered this year. Are they opportunities or value traps?
What is the Morningstar ESG Commitment level?20/11/2020 Our new rating highlights the degree to which a fund or asset manager considers environmental, social, and governance issues.
What's driving the flows into ESG funds19/11/2020 Morningstar's Grant Kennaway explains why sustainable funds are increasingly popular and why they're performing well.
Too much upside baked into Bunnings: Morningstar17/11/2020 Morningstar director of equity research Johannes Faul looks at home improvement retailer Bunnings.