Are value stocks due for a comeback? |
Tweet | ![]() |
<p><strong>Christine Benz:</strong> Hi, I'm Christine Benz for Morningstar.com. Value investing has massively underperformed growth over the past decade. Joining me to discuss the perils and promise of this investment style, as well as to share a few value-leaning exchange-traded fund picks is Alex Bryan. He's Morningstar's director of passive strategies research in North America.</p>
<p>Alex, thank you for being here.</p>
<p><strong>Alex Bryan:</strong> Thank you for having me.</p>
<p><strong>Benz:</strong> Alex, let's start by talking about the basic thesis behind value investing and why people think that it should work over time.</p>
<p><strong>Bryan:</strong> Value investing is all about buying stocks that are trading at low valuations, low multiples of things like earnings, book value, and sales. It's based on the premise that stocks that are trading cheap should offer higher expected returns than stocks that are trading at higher valuations. That could either be because stocks that are trading at low valuations might be mispriced, investors might be overly pessimistic about those firms prospects, or investors might require higher expected returns to hold those companies as compensation for their higher perceived risk. But in either case, there's this expectation that low valuation should be predictive of future returns.</p>
<p><strong>Benz:</strong> Let's talk about the sources of the underperformance over the past decade or even longer. Of course it's a complicated question, but can you unpack some of the main variables that have been hindering value stocks' performance?</p>
<p><strong>Bryan:</strong> Value stocks have gone through a really rough stretch depending on which index you look at. They've all pretty much been out of favour for the past 10-plus years, and there's a few factors that are contributing to that. Number one, the valuation spread between value and growth stocks has increased considerably over the past decade. Value stocks are by definition going to trade at lower valuations than growth stocks, but that gap has only become bigger over the past decade, and that's a big part of why value stocks have underperformed. The second piece is the sector biases that are inherent in a lot of value strategies. Typically value-oriented indexes tend to overweight sectors like energy and financial services, and those have been particularly challenged areas of the market over the past decade, due to the decline in oil prices and the challenging interest-rate environment that we've had. They also tend to be underweight stronger-performing sectors like technology and healthcare, so those sector biases have taken a bite out of performance. Thirdly, a lot of growth stocks have exceeded the market's expectations as they've carved and deepened their economic moats over the past decade. So companies like Amazon and Netflix really, I think, have blown a lot of investors away. Even though a lot of people had high hopes for those companies 10 years ago, they've more than delivered on those expectations. So I think it's a combination of different factors, but anyway you look at it, value stocks have had a rough go of it.</p>
<p><strong>Benz:</strong> Is there any reason to believe that the future will be different than the past?</p>
<p><strong>Bryan:</strong> I think so. The valuation gap between value and growth stocks can't increase indefinitely. People have been saying that for a long time, but there comes a point when the valuation spread just can't grow any further, so I think that's something to keep in mind. You can't just look at the last 10 years and extrapolate that out indefinitely. But I think more importantly, the fundamental case for value investing really hasn't changed. While the valuations that we observed, based on things like price/book and price/earnings, may not necessarily be indicative of how a stock is trading relative to its intrinsic value, which we can't see, low valuations are still predictive of future expected returns. The lower valuations are today, the higher expected returns tend to be. And that's partially because you get more for your money when you a pay a lower valuation for a stock. Your dividend yields tend to be higher. You tend to get a higher buyback yield off of companies that are trading at lower valuations, and those are the fundamental areas of value creation. That's the cash flow that you're getting for the money that you're paying for those companies.</p>
<p>At the end of the day, the fundamental case for value investing really hasn't changed. And I think it's important to keep in mind that valuation spreads between value and growth stocks really can't continue to widen out indefinitely. I think while value stocks should offer higher expected returns than the market, that doesn't necessarily mean that they're always going to outperform. Just like we expect stocks to offer higher returns than bonds, there's decade-long stretches when stocks underperformed bonds. The risk is real. This is not a free lunch. If you're not comfortable experiencing these potentially lengthy stretches of underperformance, you should probably just invest in a broadly diversified market-cap-weighted index fund and not tilt into value stocks. But I think if you have the fortitude to stick with it, value investing will reward investors over the long term.</p>
<p><strong>Benz:</strong> Let's talk about some ETFs that you like for investors who maybe do want to play a resurgence potentially in value stocks. One strategy that you like is iShares MSCI Edge USA Value Factor ETF. Let's talk about why you think that strategy is attractive.</p>
<p><strong>Bryan:</strong> This fund takes a sector-relative approach to stock selection. It's basically targeting stocks that are cheap relative to their sector peers, so it's looking at tech companies and comparing them against other tech companies, looking at banks, comparing them against other banks. And I think the sector-relative approach to stock selection makes a lot of sense when it comes to value investing, because there are important differences in companies across different sectors where you start to lose some information if you compare an energy stock against a tech stock, just because their balance sheets are very different, their business models are quite different. I think looking within each sector for value helps improve comparability of valuations. It also helps mitigate unintended sector tilts that you get with a traditional value strategy. With a fund like this, you're not going to get a big overweighting in energy, or a big overweighting in financial services. It's going to give you sector weightings that look a lot like the market. And I think that's really important, because most of the value from value investing has come from stock selection, not necessarily the sector biases that come along with value investing.</p>
<p><strong>Benz:</strong> For investors who are maybe even more contrarian and want to play a deeply unloved part of the market, Vanguard Small-Cap Value ETF is one that you like. Why do you like that one?</p>
<p><strong>Bryan:</strong> Historically, value investing has tended to work the best among the smaller stocks. I think there's a few reasons for that. One, small-cap stocks are less widely followed than large-cap companies. So there might be a greater potential for mispricing, and more stocks in that area of the market could become undervalued. Those stocks are also riskier, so they might offer some compensation for that risk. But if you're comfortable with those risks, I think this is a really good way to get exposure to this area of the market. This Vanguard fund basically targets stocks that represent the cheaper half of the U.S. small-cap market, and weights them based on market capitalization. So what you end up getting is a very well-diversified portfolio that really gives you targeted exposure to this area of the market that has been beaten up quite a bit. And I think if value has a comeback, this particular fund will be one of the better performers out there. This is also one of the cheapest small-value funds available. And as we all know, low fees are one of the best predictors of future performance.</p>
<p><strong>Benz:</strong> Alex, it's always great to get your insights. Thank you so much for being here.</p>
<p><strong>Bryan:</strong> Thank you for having me.</p>
<p><strong>Benz:</strong> Thanks for watching. I'm Christine Benz for Morningstar.com.</p>

27/01/2021 Rebecca Jiang, manager of the JPMorgan China Growth & Income Trust, looks at why Chinese stocks soared in 2020 and whether the trend can continue.

25/01/2021 Redpoint's chief executive and portfolio manager Max Cappetta tells Lex Hall why he's got his eye on JB Hi-Fi, Goodman and Reliance Worldwide in 2021.

21/01/2021 Redpoint CEO and portfolio manager Max Cappetta looks at the dividend potential of large-cap names, the resilience of Qantas, and the local tech landscape.

19/01/2021 Stocks still look cheap across all subsectors, especially oilfield services and refining, says Morningstar analyst Dave Meats.

19/01/2021 What are the rewards and risks of using this technology?

15/01/2021 Morningstar's head of policy research Aron Szapiro explains what sort of changes a Biden government will make and how they will affect company valuations.

14/01/2021 Freight-rail, building temperature efficiency, and carmaking are among the sectors Aviva Investors' Jaime Ramos Martin has his eye on.

13/01/2021 Dividend investors had a hard time in 2020, but Morningstar analyst Dan Lefkovitz think the outlook is brighter for the year ahead.

11/01/2021 Morningstar Investment Management's Dan Kemp reveals the three investment themes on his mind for the year ahead.

06/01/2021 Morningstar equity analyst Allen Good looks at the prospects for oil and gas giants in the year ahead.

05/01/2021 China had a strong year after a rocky start, but can it continue—and what does a US President Biden mean for the region? Morningstar analyst Lorraine Tan explains.

04/01/2021 Morningstar equity director Alex Morozov considers the outlook for tech, travel and beyond for the year ahead.

01/01/2021 How to plan for things you can't plan.

25/12/2020 2020: we look back at the highs and lows of an unprecedented year in financial markets and explore the themes shaping 2021.

22/12/2020 Music streaming companies have seen stellar growth in user numbers. We ask Morningstar equity analyst Neil Macker if the trend can continue.

21/12/2020 While it stands as the largest addition in the index's history, this likely won't impact everyday investors all that much.

18/12/2020 Will there be opportunities to deploy cash in the new year? Will there be a reprieve from covid? And what will the incoming Biden administration mean for markets?

18/12/2020 Companies that specialise in solar, building efficiency and renewables underpin Aviva Investors' Climate Transition Global Equity Fund, says Jaime Ramos Martin.

16/12/2020 Why does liquidity matter to investors, and how can it affect your returns? Morningstar equities director Tom Whitelaw explains.

14/12/2020 Learn what we look for when rating a company.

14/12/2020 Morningstar's new approach unpacks the environmental, social and governance risks that companies face.

10/12/2020 Industrial companies typically generate better cash flows and can offer a steady income stream, says the IML founder.

09/12/2020 The lofty valuations of Tesla and Afterpay typify the effervescence and speculation in the market, says the IML founder.

08/12/2020 Car makers may not be an obvious investment choice for ESG-conscious investors, but Morningstar analyst Tancrede Fulop says some of the largest companies score highly in some measures such as safety and human capital.

07/12/2020 Janus Henderson's Matt Peron considers how the relationship between the US and China will evolve under a President Biden.

04/12/2020 What is active investing, and what is passive investing? We're at the whiteboard to explain the pros and cons of each

04/12/2020 Treasury Wine Estates remains an undervalued stock in spite of China's demand-destroying tariff on Australian wine. Morningstar director of equity research Adam Fleck explains why.

03/12/2020 And do any other assets currently compare?

02/12/2020 We're at an inflection point in ESG investing, says Sustainalytics founder Michael Jantzi. Here's why.

01/12/2020 Beaten-down travel stocks and BNPL providers featured heavily, says nabtrade’s Gemma Dale.

30/11/2020 Many people were waiting for the opportunity to buy shares at historic discounts, says nabtrade’s Gemma Dale.

27/11/2020 The 171-year-old wealth manager has had its scandals but there's merit to its turnaround strategy and the quality of its other assets, says Morningstar's Shaun Ler.

27/11/2020 BNPL products such as Zip Co help boost consumer spending but they come with risks and are overvalued, says Morningstar analyst Shaun Ler.

26/11/2020 The Magellan co-founder argues the ecommerce acceleration is here to stay and ponders the effect it will have on other sectors such as travel and commercial real estate.

25/11/2020 Greg Dean of Cambridge Global Asset Management explains why the consumer services sector has yielded healthy returns.

25/11/2020 Magellan's co-founder explains which tech behemoth the Magellan Global Fund no longer owns, why one was too tricky to value, and why regulation is no threat.

24/11/2020 Magellan's co-founder on why 2020 resembles 2000 and why covid-19 is a dry run for something that could be much worse without proper planning.

23/11/2020 Their shares have gotten hammered this year. Are they opportunities or value traps?

20/11/2020 Our new rating highlights the degree to which a fund or asset manager considers environmental, social, and governance issues.

19/11/2020 Morningstar's Grant Kennaway explains why sustainable funds are increasingly popular and why they're performing well.

17/11/2020 Morningstar director of equity research Johannes Faul looks at home improvement retailer Bunnings.

16/11/2020 From climate change to workers' rights, ESG is a big part of the investing world. We're at the Morningstar whiteboard board to explain what it means and why it matters.

12/11/2020 We're not out of the woods yet, says our head of equity research, as he looks for safety in businesses we can't live without and shies away from the banks.

11/11/2020 Perhaps it is time to have exposure to this economic powerhouse and its 1.4 billion population, says Morningstar's Peter Warnes.

10/11/2020 What happens when you buy something when your bank card? Morningstar analyst Niklas Kammer explains which companies are benefiting from your transaction.

09/11/2020 With travel bans and economic lockdowns, the luxury sector has been hit hard in 2020. But there are still opportunities, says Morningstar analyst Jelena Sokolova.

05/11/2020 A discussion of taxes, stimulus, regulation, and the likely market reaction as results from the 2020 poll come in.

03/11/2020 Why you should resist the urge to make predictions when there's a disconnect between the economy and security prices.

02/11/2020 Etoro analyst Josh Gilbert shares his thoughts on Beyond Meat and two other companies making inroads into the plant-based meat sector.

30/10/2020 The Magellan rainmaker explains why he doubts the Republican leader will prevail and why investors should brace for volatility—and ignore it.

29/10/2020 The market for plant-based meat is worth $14bn today and is expected to grow massively, says eToro's Josh Gilbert.

28/10/2020 Morningstar equity analyst Johannes Faul explores the flipside to the surge in growth in online sales.

22/10/2020 China and Hong Kong have been a happy hunting ground, says Longlead Capital Partners' co-founder Andrew West, who singles out tech, pharmaceuticals and power tools.

22/10/2020 These names stand to benefit from a resumption of leisure travel - and are all trading below our fair value estimates.

20/10/2020 Morningstar's Mark Preskett looks at three reasons why bonds are an important tool in your investment portfolio.

19/10/2020 A bigger stake in the online conveyancer PEXA could be the key to increasing Link Administration's revenue, says Morningstar's Gareth James.

16/10/2020 Longlead Capital Partners co-founder Andrew West reveals how his Asia-focused fund managed to make gains during the historic covid-19 sell-off.

16/10/2020 The investment board is back with an explainer on why you might invest in bonds.

13/10/2020 How to handle this decision—even when it is made for you.

12/10/2020 Nick Griffin of Munro Partners reveals why and where he sees opportunities in renewable energy, diagnostics and software.

09/10/2020 Take stock of your spending to determine if inflation is an issue for you.

09/10/2020 Morningstar analyst Chelsey Tam explains why investors are excited about the flotation of Ant Group and why it's different from Alibaba.

06/10/2020 Companies that address the growing demand for decarbonisation will have a 20-year growth opportunity, says Nick Griffin of Munro Partners.

30/09/2020 EXCLUSIVE EXTRACT: Morningstar's Mat Hodge and Lex Hall talk to the CEO of the independent producer and exporter about the company's fortunes and its future.

30/09/2020 Slow and steady wins the financial race.

29/09/2020 American Century Investments' low-turnover strategy invests in companies developing vaccines, treatments for neuro-cognitive diseases and innovations in telemedicine.

25/09/2020 By 2050, almost 20 per cent of the global population will be over 65 and demand for healthcare will climb, says Michael Li of American Century Investments.

22/09/2020 The destruction of an indigenous cave shelter was unforgiveable but there are other reasons why the iron ore heavyweight is overvalued.

21/09/2020 Morningstar equity analyst Kristoffer Inton on the outlook for the seven producers under coverage.

18/09/2020 Morningstar's Seth Goldstein singles out three undervalued stocks that span the entire electric vehicle supply chain.

18/09/2020 The bumps and bruises of election time may tempt you to shift your portfolio strategy.

17/09/2020 UK-based Premier Miton's Simon Evan-Cook says the tech rally of 2020 is reminiscent of the dotcom boom, but inflation could be a bigger threat.

16/09/2020 By 2025, the cost of batteries and manufacturing will fall and EV functionality will improve, says Morningstar's Seth Goldstein.

11/09/2020 Estimating the length of your retirement with personalized information will help you save the correct amount.

09/09/2020 Morningstar's Chelsey Tam reveals which stocks and sectors have shone—and which have underwhelmed.

28/08/2020 Products, services, what is what in the world of finance—and how to look out for yourself

24/08/2020 A raft of companies have cut their dividends this year, leaving income investors concerned. But Morningstar's Dan Lefkovitz says there are still plenty of options out there.

18/08/2020 DNR Capital's chief investment officer Jamie Nicol profiles some of the top ten holdings in his Australian Equities High Conviction fund.

17/08/2020 Morningstar's Brian Han explains why he has trimmed his fair value estimate for Australia's dominant telco and the future of its dividend payout.

14/08/2020 DNR Capital's Jamie Nicol reveals how his Australian Equities High Conviction fund finds quality businesses that will endure difficult conditions.

13/08/2020 Put your money to work if you're looking for financial freedom.

10/08/2020 Learn how to picture your goals so you can better reach them.

05/08/2020 Morningstar's Gareth James identifies three sector names trading at attractive discounts in an increasingly 'essential' sector.

05/08/2020 Reports of the strategy's demise are greatly exaggerated, says Morningstar's Christine Benz.

04/08/2020 Investors may assume a fund's yield to determine how much income it will pay, but it's not always so simple, warns Morningstar analyst Rajesh Yadav.

03/08/2020 It depends on your expectations and timeframe. Look at bonds as being portfolio stabilisers—sources of cash flow you can draw on when your equities are down, says Christine Benz.

28/07/2020 When utility stocks plunged during the onset of the pandemic Lazard Asset Management's Warryn Robertson knew it was time to jump in.

24/07/2020 Lazard Asset Management's Warryn Robertson looks at how the pandemic has affected toll roads and airports and what the future of travel holds.

23/07/2020 Morningstar analyst Tancrede Fulop singles out a few companies that have performed well and also led the way in looking after staff.

21/07/2020 New stock-pickers are prone to lose money. Are the lessons worth the price? We ask Morningstar's Christine Benz.

20/07/2020 Elevated iron ore prices have lifted mining company earnings to eye-watering levels but this doesn't make them income stocks, says Morningstar's Mat Hodge.

17/07/2020 Local miners should deliver stellar fiscal 2020 results but such outperformance is unlikely to last, says Morningstar’s Mat Hodge.

17/07/2020 --

16/07/2020 How to make some upgrades during this down time.

16/07/2020 Covid-19 has made the intended public offering impossible, says Morningstar's Andrew Willis.

15/07/2020 JPMorgan's Nicholas Weindling talks opportunities in Japan and reveals the stock that has been his largest holding for almost a decade

15/07/2020 The asset class has a habit of outperforming but Morningstar's Ross MacMillan sees signs of a bubble.

13/07/2020 Rachel Winter of UK fund manager Killik & Co talks payments, social media and investing in her monthly stock pick round-up

09/07/2020 And what we expect to see moving forward.

07/07/2020 Large growth maintains its supremacy in the Morningstar Style Box during a volatile first half for mutual funds.