ESG funds don't underperform - but nor do they outperform |
Tweet | ![]() |
<p><strong>Emma Rapaport: </strong>Hello, and welcome to Morningstar. I'm Emma Rapaport. Sustainable investing is one of the fastest growing trends in the asset management industry. Here with us to talk about whether or not ESG funds are delivering for investors is Tim Murphy. He is a Director in our Manager Research team and the chief architect of Morningstar's model ETF portfolios.</p>
<p>Tim, thanks very much for joining us today.</p>
<p><strong>Tim Murphy: </strong>Good morning, Emma.</p>
<p><strong>Rapaport: </strong>Tim, I think it's fair to say that ESG funds have, in general, outperformed particularly during the pandemic. Could you discuss why these funds have outperformed and whether or not that you've continued to see outperformance in the last six months or so?</p>
<p><strong>Murphy: </strong>Yeah. So, there have been a range of outcomes from ESG-tilted funds. And so, we <a href="https://www.morningstar.com.au/funds/article/esg-investments-improve-performance-or-do/215834">certainly sought to write a paper and explore what is the empirical evidence around some of these hypotheses and views that are out there</a>. Certainly, there were definitely through the course of 2020 themes like technology and healthcare did very well, which have tended to have higher exposure from ESG-tilted funds. But equally, this year or probably since late 2020 we've seen a rebound in commodity prices, fossil fuels in particular, coal prices hitting all-time highs more recently. So, of course, the opposite of that has been true in 2021.</p>
<p>But when we're thinking about performance in assessing funds, we're always thinking about things over the long term. And so, we recently wrote a paper looking to explore the empirical evidence over longer three and five-year periods for ESG funds, because a lot of these shorter-term things tend to wash out over longer term. And so, what we did was look at the performance of global equity funds available for Australian equity investors, how have they done both on a return and a risk spectrum relative to broad market indices and peer groups. And what we found was certainly over five years no discernible difference on average to the broader market. Some funds are higher return and higher risk, some funds were lower return and lower risk. Over a short a three-year time period, where we've got a more meaningful sample size given there has been a lot of growth in products in recent years, the performance is slightly better on average. So, the encouraging thing that we took out of that is that you're not necessarily giving up anything by having a tilted ESG portfolio. Certainly, there's been one viewpoint among investors out there is if you're restricting part of my investable universe, then that should limit my opportunities, and by inference limit my returns. But what we've seen to-date doesn't support material outperformance but doesn't support materially different underperformance either.</p>
<p><strong>Rapaport: </strong>So, you'd say it's better said that narrative of having to accept underperformance to invest in line with your values is dead?</p>
<p><strong>Murphy: </strong>Certainly, the evidence doesn't support that today. I think, like anything, there's a range of different ways of approaching ESG investing. And so, that's certainly we're having detailed data and tools to analyze the different approaches is really, really important because we are seeing a range of different funds come to market that all have ESG or sustainable in the name, but actually have very, very different ways of doing that under the hood. And so, that's certainly what a lot of our research aims to identify and seek out. But certainly, when looking at across a broad sample set, on average, we're able to conclude that investors that want to or increasingly want to align their investment portfolios with their own values, pressing that through ESG funds, they haven't had to necessarily give up any performance or take a higher risk to do that.</p>
<p><strong>Rapaport: </strong>So, Tim, for the funds that have the – the ESG funds that have outperformed on a three to five-year basis, your suggestion is that their outperformance isn't anything to do with unnecessarily preferencing ESG-friendly or ESG-risk-less stocks. It's more to do with their general investing acumen or the other things that you would rate and review a fund on?</p>
<p><strong>Murphy: </strong>Yeah, for sure. I think it's difficult to conclude that ESG in isolation would be the reason why any fund has outperformed over a given period in most circumstances, and certainly over the periods that we've looked at most recently. What we do as part of our day-to-day work, and certainly what it brought to life in this research paper we've written is look at some of the underlying sector and factor exposures that are typical of ESG funds. And certainly, looking at it on a lot of different factor basis, they're looking at the exposure of these funds to factors like yield, like momentum, like value, like quality, a lot of these sort of traditional metrics that people would analyze and make investment decisions based on. But most of those factors on average – some are higher, some are lower. There isn't a discernible difference. But there was one exception to that which was quality factor. So, the vast majority of ESG funds tend to be overweight the quality factor. So, what does that mean? It means tend to favor funds that rank well on metrics like return on equity. So, they have higher than average return on equity. They'll have lower than average debt. And if you think about that, that is quite intuitive when you think about the characteristics of an ESG-aligned fund, the fact that it would have those characteristics makes intuitive sense, right? So, quality stocks as a factor certainly have outperformed the broader global equity market over the last five years. And so, certainly, we think that that's playing a role in helping some of the funds here that have outperformed within this sample set over the time period.</p>
<p><strong>Rapaport: </strong>Tim, you've just done this big review of funds and the way that they manage ESG risk. Is there anything that you would like to see in this industry that's still young and is still growing that you would like to see change?</p>
<p><strong>Murphy: </strong>I think we need to see better articulation of the ESG characteristics from different fund managers. So, as I mentioned earlier, there's lots and lots of funds coming to market that have ESG or sustainable in their name, but actually sort of articulating that under the hood with objective data to verify that, that's certainly of increasing importance, a scenario, we spend a lot of time doing to help differentiate as part of our analysis. I'd say there's a couple of fund managers that are good at that, but on average I think that's an area where a lot of funds and ETF providers offering products in this space could definitely improve to help investors understand in more detail which particular ESG characteristic their investment offering really tilts toward or provides you greater exposure to and could therefore help you make that decision if you're trying to align your portfolio to a particular value. Because I guess that's the other thing with ESG investing is that different issues are more or less important to different individuals. It's very individualized topic. So, things like tobacco manufacturing, lots of people in Australia care about that. You go to Europe, for instance, less so. Things like fossil fuel production – again, you get differing attitudes from different investors on that, obviously topical one at the moment given how high the coal prices have jumped most recently. So, being able to individualize portfolios or make individual decisions based on those particular values we think is increasingly important.</p>
<p><strong>Rapaport: </strong>Yeah. So, if you had to describe the range of what people or what managers are making transparent is that everything from just saying, you know, we consider ESG risk to putting on their website exactly where within their portfolio they think that they're reducing their carbon risk, or they're reducing their risk of social issues. What's the range of sort of transparency you're looking at?</p>
<p><strong>Murphy: </strong>Yeah. So, I mean, basic things from what sectors do we exclude? I mean, that's the very most basic thing we've seen in ESG investing. So, being easy to identify this fund excludes tobacco, controversial weapons, fossil fuel production or whatever other particular exclusions it may have in place so that investors can easily identify that. As I said, some are good at doing that, some less so. And certainly, at Morningstar, we sort of capture that data to help investors be able to filter on those sorts of issues. But then, from an impact of positive perspective, really looking to identify not only how does the process look for stocks exposed to a particular theme, but then how does their portfolio measure, how do you quantify that versus a broad index fund for instance so that it's very clear and easy for investors to understand if you buy our fund instead of broad index funds, you get that lower carbon exposure depending on your metric, lower exposures to fossil fuels, lower exposures to weapons or bad labor practices.</p>
<p><strong>Rapaport: </strong>So, if an investor is considering integrating ESG into their portfolio, they're considering some ESG funds, what are some of the things that they should look for in a top-performing fund?</p>
<p><strong>Murphy: </strong>Yeah. So, there are things to consider. First of all, I mean, even ignoring performance, you want to think about what are your values that you're wanting to align to, and make sure that you're narrowing your focus to funds or ETFs that have similar values to that, first and foremost, if that's what's driving your decision. Once you've got a list of funds that meets those criteria, then obviously you want to look for funds that have a longer-term focus, that have detailed – in an active fund, a detailed thought-out process and a skilled team behind what they do. If it is a more sort of rules-based or passive offering, then do the rules of that makes sense, have they stood the test of time, has that index been around for a while or was that index created last week because someone thought they could build an idea that an ETF provider would make (indiscernible). So, I think there's lots of long-term versus short-term decisions to think about when selecting investments and really trying to look past a lot of that short-term noise.</p>
<p><strong>Rapaport: </strong>Great. Thank you very much for joining us today.</p>
<p><strong>Murphy: </strong>Thanks Emma.</p>

19/05/2022 Local investors were spooked after US retail giants Target and Walmart plummeted overnight as rising prices hit margins and inventory.

19/05/2022 On his recent visit to Australia, Morningstar's global chief investment officer Dan Kemp talks investing narratives, confronting the growing list of reasons to be concerned about markets and sustainable investing.

19/05/2022 Worries about inflation’s toll on earnings sparks Wednesday’s 4% plunge, but stocks are now far undervalued.

18/05/2022 One of the big themes of the year has been the value comeback. What is behind this resurgence after a pretty dismal period, and should your portfolio be tilting in its direction?

11/05/2022 Here's what investors who are worried about a recession should consider today.

11/05/2022 Morningstar analysts have identified TPG telecom as the most undervalued telecom stocks in the ASX 200 detailing multiple catalysts for earnings recovery and growth.

29/04/2022 Exclusive: Hermitage Capital Management CEO Bill Browder talks Putin, Russia, and the next six months for Ukraine

28/04/2022 Inflation, rising interest rates, geopolitical risks, and other things to keep your eye on.

27/04/2022 Morningstar's analyst talks about the Buffett's recent deals, what the stock is worth, and whether Berkshire will pay a dividend any time soon.

31/03/2022 Supply disruptions following Russia's invasion of Ukraine are forcing analysts to consider the possibility elevated prices persist.

30/03/2022 Rising interest rates, strong economic growth and cheaper valuations are driving banking stocks ahead of the broader market.

28/03/2022 Where are entertainment and streaming services headed?

24/03/2022 Problems in global supply chains are an opportunity for WiseTech as its logistics company customers move to replace old software.

23/03/2022 Markets focused on floods and bushfires are missing how insurers are cutting costs, doing more digitally and are looking down the barrel of a lift in investment income.

17/03/2022 Morningstar Investment Management's global CIO Dan Kemp explains why well-intentioned investors desperate for peace in Europe are making dangerous market calls

15/03/2022 Knowledge of the local market, strong branding and a growing subscription service should see the undervalued retailer retain market share in the rapidly growing online sales category, says Roy Van Keulen.

08/03/2022 Higher inflation, rising interest rates and booming commodity markets are driving a major rotation away from the post-pandemic winners, says Tim Murphy, Morningstar director of manager selection.

03/03/2022 Regulators are likely to be less lenient now the buy-now-pay-later sector is part of the fabric of Australian payments.

23/02/2022 Strong commodity prices, cheap valuations and a head start on interest rate hikes means emerging markets are set for strength, says Dr. Joseph Lai of Ox Capital.

23/02/2022 A belligerent speech from a president signalled the start of the latest phase of Russian agression last night, causing markets to wobble and investors to wonder.

15/02/2022 In an extended interview, Morningstar's Peter Warnes discusses the bear market in US technology stocks, interest rates and growth and his approach to investing outside the US and Australia.

13/02/2022 Morningstar equity analyst Shaun Ler explains why he see valuation upside high for MFG even as shares lose steam.

31/01/2022 The Chinese lunar year is almost over, and what a ride it's been. Morningstar speaks to JPMorgan Asset Management strategist Mike Bell about what's ahead.

23/01/2022 Christine Benz discusses how investors should handle the turmoil, whatever the life stage.

18/01/2022 Empty shelves will negatively impact supermarkets in the second half of fiscal 2022 but the impact on long-term earnings is minimal, says Morningstar analyst Johannes Faul.

17/01/2022 Bank earnings, house prices and China risk: Our experts and analysts discuss what they've got their eyes on in 2022.

24/12/2021 Our experts and analysts weigh in on what mattered for investors last year.

21/12/2021 New products, lower fees and a portfolio of undervalued stocks set to help the fund manager right the ship.

10/12/2021 And how does it match up against gold?

10/12/2021 Australian miners to be among the last standing as coal use fades.

08/12/2021 Rebalancing your portfolio is one of those beneficial habits that’s easy to let slide. But year-end is an ideal time to check how your portfolio is tracking against your target asset allocation.

03/12/2021 The gold-rated fund manager shares three ideas with long-term potential.

01/12/2021 Long-term investor sees opportunities where businesses are moving towards a zero-carbon future faster than governments.

30/11/2021 To understand your fund, get to know its underlying index.

29/11/2021 These companies are set to profit from the move to clean energy, says Lazard.

24/11/2021 The results of the COP26 climate summit suggest coal demand is likely to persist for longer than expected.

17/11/2021 And how investors can protect their portfolios.

08/11/2021 Morningstar thinks these moaty companies will remain resilient in the face of inflation and ongoing supply chain challenges.

05/11/2021 Morningstar maintains fair value despite a fall in margins and slower progress on cost reductions.

19/10/2021 These new US-listed exchange-traded funds will invest in bitcoin futures, not bitcoin itself.

15/10/2021 The ESG outperformance narrative is flawed, new research shows.

06/10/2021 Investors may need to hold more growth assets over the coming years, says Morningstar's Jody Fitzgerald.

01/10/2021 And how G8 Education and Link Administration are positioned for long-term success.

30/09/2021 What Reporting Season August 2021 told investors about the health of the financials sector.

28/09/2021 a2 milk is an opportunity to be greedy when others are fearful.

23/09/2021 Covid's winners and losers are returning to their prior trajectories.

21/09/2021 Sequence-of-returns risk matters for both retirees and savers. Here's why.

20/09/2021 Analysts expect the sector to recover to pre-Covid trading levels once borders reopen.

15/09/2021 Rising customer deposits and access to cheap funding helped Australia's banks stave off net interest margin pressure, but analysts see warning signs.

14/09/2021 Morningstar's Hortense Bioy on how to spot greenwashing and how to avoid it.

13/09/2021 Utilities and infrastructure names battle the impact of covid as private equity and pension funds circle.

10/09/2021 Hydrocarbons poised for a comeback.

09/09/2021 Providers have lifted prices after years of a debilitating chase for subscribers at all costs , says Morningstar's Brian Han.

08/09/2021 What shorting ETFs means for long-term investors.

07/09/2021 Morningstar senior analyst Grant Slade says Brambles secular growth trend is intact despite nearterm headwinds. He discusses results from the building and construction materials sector.

03/09/2021 Miners bask in the glow of iron ore prices while bargains remain in coal.

23/08/2021 Post-merger Woodside would be well positioned to deliver on the value we've seen for a long time, say Morningstar analysts.

16/08/2021 But the sector lacks uniformity, says Morningstar's Christopher Franz.

11/08/2021 Higher wholesale electricity prices bode well for AGL, according to Morningstar senior equities analyst Adrian Atkins.

11/08/2021 Morningstar FundInvestor editor Russ Kinnel describes some direct and indirect hedges for inflation protection.

10/08/2021 Copper and iron ore have benefited materially from China’s stimulus and the developed world recovery. But Morningstar analyst Mat Hodge see these benefit as transitory.

05/08/2021 We believe the transaction has a high chance of succeeding.

03/08/2021 The industry still has significant growth potential.

03/08/2021 Is one of the biggest sponsors of the Olympics positioned for an all-electric future?

23/07/2021 Morningstar's Lex Hall talks micro-cap stock picks with Carlos Gil, chief investment officer at Microequities Asset Management.

22/07/2021 Mornngstar's Lex Hall catches up with Carlos Gil, chief investment officer at Microequities Asset Management.

21/07/2021 The head of Australian small and mid-cap stocks at First Sentier Investors has her eye on ARB, Breville and IDP Education.

20/07/2021 The strong performances of global stock markets in 2020–21 are unlikely to be repeated in the coming year says Morningstar's Peter Warnes.

12/07/2021 Morningstar equity analysts warn that equities remain overvalued despite Australia's strong economic recovery.

08/07/2021 Private equity is an exciting area for investors, with lots of hotly-tipped stocks. But there are risks to be aware of, says Pitchbook analyst Dylan Cox.

08/07/2021 Warryn Robertson is looking at French infrastructure, retail pharmacy and tax services.

06/07/2021 Australia's largest banks have excess capital because they cut dividends, were more conservative on lending, divested assets and raised equity last year. Morningstar's Nathan Zaia thinks most of it should be returned to shareholders.

02/07/2021 PEXA burst onto the ASX this week in the biggest float since 2019. Morningstar's Gareth James gives his take on the company's future growth prospects.

30/06/2021 Iron ore prices have been on a tear, boosting the profits of Australia's top miners. How did we get here and is the only way up? Lex Hall sits down with Morningstar's Mat Hodge.

28/06/2021 Morningstar has recently initiated coverage of a food delivery app and a consumer finance product.

24/06/2021 Meeting the deluge of demand is the biggest task for US companies, says Bell Asset Management's Ned Bell.

22/06/2021 Are there still opportunities in the biotech sector now the covid-19 vaccine roll out is underway? We ask International Biotechnology Trust manager Ailsa Craig

21/06/2021 Morningstar's director of Asia equity research is confident the e-commerce giant will bounce back.

18/06/2021 A wide moat and attractive dividend potential are among the key takeaways of Woolworth's decision to demerge from the liquor and hospitality group.

15/06/2021 Lazard Asset Management's Warryn Robertson explains how companies in the Global Equity Franchise fund have adjusted to covid, and assesses the threat of rising inflation.

11/06/2021 Magellan's Craig Wright tells Emma Rapaport why it is leading the charge in the active ETF arena and how its global equity product works.

10/06/2021 Callum Burns of ICE Investors explains his conviction in pharmaceutical distributor Ebos, PSC Insurance Group, and elite sports analytics provider Catapult.

09/06/2021 Callum Burns explains how ICE Investors identifies companies with original products and sticky customer bases.

08/06/2021 They’re building an empire.

07/06/2021 A year ago the oil price went negative. How have oil giants handled the past 12 months and what's the outlook from here? Morningstar analyst Allen Good explains.

04/06/2021 As the investment world goes crazy for crypto, Morningstar Investment Management's Dan Kemp explains what to consider before putting it in your portfolio

03/06/2021 The airline sector is set to recover as international travel resumes. Morningstar analysts think Wizz Air offer the best opportunity among low-cost carriers.

28/05/2021 4D Infrastructure's Sarah Shaw outlines the investment case for Spanish multinationals Cellnex, and Iberdrola, and the potential of Mexican airports.

28/05/2021 The SEC continues to sort out its regulatory concerns.

27/05/2021 We’re raising our fair value as sales hit new highs—but investors need to put it in perspective, says Andrew Willis.

25/05/2021 Covid-19 has enhanced rather than impeded the future for global infrastructure, says Sarah Shaw of 4D Infrastructure.

24/05/2021 Tribeca's Jun Bei Liu also explains why she sees opportunity in sleep apnea specialist ResMed as well as Treasury Wine Estates.

19/05/2021 American Century Investment's Patricia Ribeiro sees growth in Chinese battery technology, biologics, and building materials in Latin America.

18/05/2021 Robotics is a fast-growing area of tech, creating opportunities in medical, logistics and life sciences sectors and much more.

18/05/2021 Square's Bitcoin purchase is more marketing than operations

10/05/2021 If Elon Musk ends up delivering, we might need to raise our fair value to US$1500 a share.

07/05/2021 Banks and resources are poised to deliver dividends, and Treasury Wine Estates and BNPL are worth a look, says Jun Bei Liu of Tribeca's Alpha Plus long/short fund.

05/05/2021 Digital banking, ecommerce and 5G are among the key trends set for rapid growth, says Patricia Ribeiro of American Century Investments.

04/05/2021 Analysts have made changes to the fixed interest, property, cash and equity allocations of Morningstar's Model ETF Portfolios to take advantage of the current market environment. They've also refreshed some of the funds in the portfolio.

30/04/2021 The stock market and the economy are not the same. Here's why.