‘Just buy the S&P 500′ is advice many new investors hear. An ETF that tracks the index offers a straightforward way to invest in the largest US companies, without picking individual stocks.

The cheapest ETF may seem like an obvious starting point, yet ETFs tracking the same index can differ in ways fees don’t show. Morningstar also rates them differently. Three of the four ETFs track the S&P 500, giving larger companies more weight. The fourth holds the same companies but aims to spread its investment equally across them.

In this article we compare how four ASX-listed S&P 500 ETFs are built and how their costs, weighting and ratings differ. The comparison excludes currency hedged ETFs, so returns also reflect movements in the Australian dollar against the US dollar. It does not recommend a particular ETF.

What is the S&P 500?

The S&P 500 tracks 500 leading US companies, covering about 80% of the US stock market by value. Rather than automatically including the 500 largest businesses, a committee selects companies that meet requirements including profitability and liquidity.

Once selected, companies are weighted by float-adjusted market capitalisation, giving larger businesses more influence over returns. The iShares S&P 500 ETF (ASX: IVV), State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF (ASX: SPY) and newer Vanguard S&P 500 US Shares Index ETF (ASX: V500) all follow this approach.

Betashares S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (ASX: QUS) holds the same companies but gives each a roughly equal share of the portfolio. Every quarter, it resets each company’s weight to approximately 0.2%, allowing the weights to move with share prices between rebalances. Although these providers invest in the same companies, how much they hold in each can lead to different returns.

How do the four ETFs compare?

The table shows each ETF’s Medalist Rating, benchmark, 10-year index return and fee.

IVVSPYV500QUS
Launch date10 October 200713 October 2014 4 March 202617 December 2014
Medalist RatingGoldGoldNot ratedNeutral
Benchmark stated by the issuerS&P 500 Net TR Index (AUD)S&P 500 IndexS&P 500 Net Total Return AUD IndexS&P 500 Equal Weight Index
10-year return a year15.78%15.78%15.78%12.71%
Fee0.04%0.09%0.07%0.29%
WeightingMarket valueMarket valueMarket valueEqual
Category indexMSCI USA NR AUDMSCI USA NR AUDMSCI USA NR AUDMSCI USA NR AUD

Data as of 31 October 2026. Source: Morningstar

The Medalist Rating is Morningstar’s forward-looking assessment of an investment’s expected performance after fees, on a scale from Gold to Negative.

Gold means our analysts expect an ETF to add value over the long term, while Neutral means they do not expect it to outperform its category. We use the category index as a benchmark for this assessment. This is different from the index the ETF tracks.

IVV, SPY and V500 track the S&P 500, so the table shows the index’s 10-year net total return in Australian dollars rather than each ETF’s return. This assumes dividends are reinvested after withholding tax. IVV’s own 10-year return is excluded because its benchmark changed from gross to net of withholding tax when the fund was restructured in September 2018. Our analysts note that S&P 500 ETFs generally charge low fees, allowing them to capture nearly all of the index’s return.

QUS adopted its current equal-weight strategy on 18 December 2020, so its 10-year return includes a period when it followed a different approach. The table therefore uses the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index’s return to show how equal weighting performed over the full period.

Over the 10 years to the end of October 2026, this index returned 12.71% a year before fees, about 3 percentage points less than the standard S&P 500. Equal weighting gives the largest companies less influence over returns. This can hold back performance when those companies outperform the rest of the index, but help when they underperform.

How does weighting change the investment?

In the market-weighted ETFs, the largest companies carry the most weight. At 31 October 2026, the 10 largest holdings made up about 37% of SPY.

QUS relies less on the S&P 500’s largest companies. Every quarter, it trims holdings that have risen above their target weights and adds to those below them. That can cushion returns when the biggest companies struggle, but it also limits the ETF’s gains when those companies keep pulling ahead.

As that money is spread across the other holdings, smaller companies within the index gain more influence over returns. They are not small-cap stocks in the usual sense, but the change in weighting means QUS can perform differently from the standard S&P 500 despite owning the same companies.

Maintaining those equal weights also requires more trading, adding costs that reduce what investors keep. Our analysts weigh these costs and the risks of greater exposure to smaller companies against the diversification benefit, which helps explain QUS’s Neutral Medalist Rating.

Start with the exposure

All four ETFs own the same 500 companies, yet they do not behave the same way. IVV, SPY and V500 let the largest companies drive returns, while QUS spreads the weight more evenly and carries higher costs for doing so.

The first decision is therefore about weighting: whether to follow the market’s weights or reduce reliance on its biggest companies. Investors who prefer market weighting have three options here, with fees, track records and ratings helping distinguish them.

These three ETFs have almost identical holdings. Fees range from 0.04% to 0.09%, or $4 to $9 a year on $10,000 invested, while track records range from 19 years for IVV to about eight months for V500. IVV and SPY have Gold Medalist Ratings; V500 is not yet rated. QUS charges 0.29%, or $29 a year on $10,000, and carries a Neutral rating.

Whichever approach investors choose, it should suit their time horizon and tolerance for risk. For long-term investors, the focus should be on choosing an approach they can stick with through market ups and downs, rather than trying to time their entry and exit.

Subscribe to get Morningstar insights in your inbox