The Global X Semiconductor ETF (ASX: SEMI) fell almost 10% on Thursday, November 5, capping a month in which it lost nearly 30%. Even after accounting for July’s A$2.85 distribution, the ETF is down about 28% from its June peak, after a partial rebound.

Global X Semiconductor ETF (ASX: SEMI)

  • Total Cost Ratio: 0.45%
  • Assets under management: A$825 million
  • Morningstar Category: Equity Global Technology
  • Morningstar Category Index: MSCI World Ex Australia NR AUD

If you own a Nasdaq or global index fund, or international shares through your super, you probably hold many of the same stocks. Index funds buy companies in proportion to their size, and AI chipmakers such as Nvidia (NASDAQ: NVDA) and Broadcom (NASDAQ: AVGO) are now among the largest companies in the world. In the popular Betashares Nasdaq 100 ETF (ASX: NDQ), about 27% of the money sat in companies SEMI also holds as of 6 November. Whether these stocks are worth their price has implications for investors well beyond those who own SEMI.

While Morningstar does not rate SEMI itself, our analysts value 26 of its 30 holdings, representing 98% of the portfolio. Weighted by their position sizes, those companies trade about 33% below our fair value estimates.

What does ‘about 33%’ below fair value measure?

Each company we cover has a fair value estimate. Divide its share price by that estimate and you get its price-to-fair-value ratio; below 1.0 means the shares trade under our analysts’ estimate. Weighting those ratios by each holding’s size in SEMI gives 0.67 for the ETF. On 6 November the ratio reached 0.63, near its lowest level since 2022, as the chart below shows.

SEMI Price to FV

Valuations can shift quickly. The median chipmaker our analysts cover traded about 25% above fair value at the end of June and about 17% below by early September.

What happened to the price?

SEMI peaked at A$47.49 on 22 June, after the Morningstar Global Semiconductors Index had gained nearly 61% for the year. Memory stocks had run furthest ahead: the median reached 2.27 times our analysts’ fair values, even as they expected new supply to push the cycle down from 2029. The reversal was sharp. SK hynix (KRX: 000660) fell a record 15% on 13 July, while Micron (NASDAQ: MU) and Samsung (KRX: 005930) lost about a third from their late-June highs by early August.

SEMI recovered to A$40.65 on 5 October, then fell 29.7% over the next month as investors questioned the returns on data center spending and how it would be funded. The chart below accounts for July’s distribution; excluding it makes the decline from the peak look like 40%, overstating holders’ losses.

SEMI performance chart

The sell-off deepened on 5 November after US midterm elections raised fears of data center restrictions. Texas governor-elect Gina Hinojosa had campaigned on a temporary halt, and voters backed limits in nearly all 41 local measures.

That day, the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index fell about 12%, Nvidia 9.3% and SEMI 9.8%. The potential disruption remains uncertain: Goldman Sachs estimates states likely to impose restrictions hold 45% of planned US capacity, while UBS sees 30% of expected 2028 additions at risk.

Since then, SEMI has recovered part of that loss.

Our analysts take a longer-term view. They expect sustained hyperscaler spending and the AI chip industry to sell everything it can produce in 2026 and 2027, before growth slows later in the decade. That outlook underpins the fair values behind the 33% discount.

What do our analysts see in these chip stocks?

SEMI holds 30 stocks, but its five largest positions account for about half the fund. Our analysts expect AI demand to lift earnings at several of SEMI’s largest holdings, underpinning fair value estimates well above current prices.

  • Nvidia (8.8% of the fund) trades at 0.62 times our US$250 fair value estimate, which assumes data center sales almost double in fiscal 2027. Our analysts cut that estimate from US$310 on 12 November after Jensen Huang resigned.
  • TSMC (TWSE: 2330; 11.3%) trades at 0.64 times fair value. It manufactures chips for Nvidia and AMD (NASDAQ: AMD), benefiting from the same AI spending.
  • Broadcom (11.9%) trades at 0.51 times fair value, the largest discount of the three. Our analysts consider its forecast of US$115 billion in fiscal 2027 AI chip sales cautious.

Memory chip makers account for about 23% of the fund and, as a group, trade at 0.69 times fair value. But their individual valuations vary considerably:

  • Micron (9.2%; 1.03) trades almost exactly at our US$700 fair value estimate, so it contributes little to the overall discount.
  • SK Hynix (5.6%; 0.51) trades at about half our fair value estimate, despite the caution built into our analyst’s assessment. It has no economic moat, meaning no durable competitive advantage, and a Very High uncertainty rating. Our analyst also expects memory prices to fall from 2029, weighing on the valuation.
  • Samsung Electronics (7.6%; 0.63) also trades well below our fair value estimate.

Our analysts left their fair value estimates for Nvidia, TSMC and Micron unchanged after November 5, so the widening discounts in those stocks reflected falling prices rather than higher valuations. They later cut Nvidia’s to US$250 on 12 November; TSMC’s and Micron’s are unchanged. The chart below shows where each of SEMI’s ten largest holdings trades relative to fair value.

SEMI top Holding November 16

What does this mean for investors?

Our analysts rate 88% of the covered weight as High or Very High fair value uncertainty, which means there is a large variety of potential outcomes.

Valuation levels will also change over time, as the prospects for the companies fluctuate and our analysts reassess their estimates. For long-term investors, valuation is one of several considerations in making investment decisions, alongside how a particular investment fits your goals, tax consequences and transaction costs.

How we calculated the ETF’s fair value estimate

Holdings and prices are as of 16 November 2026. This analysis uses Morningstar analyst fair value estimates, which are available for 26 of SEMI’s 30 holdings (98.1% of the ETF by weight). The other four holdings (ASE Technology (TWSE: 3711), Samsung Electro-Mechanics (KRX: 009150), UMC (TWSE: 2303) and Astera Labs (NASDAQ: ALAB), 1.8%) and cash are excluded.

Fund price/fair value divides the market value of the covered holdings by their value at our analysts’ fair value estimates, so each company counts in proportion to its weight in the fund.

TermMeaning
Morningstar economic moat ratingCompanies our analysts believe have a sustainable competitive advantage. A wide moat rating denotes a company our analyst believes will maintain a competitive advantage for 20 years with narrow moat ratings indicating 10 years.
None: no advantage, or one that will fade quickly.
Fair value estimateOur analysts’ estimate of the long-term fair value of a share.
Price/fair valueShare price divided by fair value estimate. A price to fair value below one indicates our analyst believes the share is trading at a discount to its fair value, a price to fair value of 1 indicates a fairly valued share and a price to fair value above 1 indicates a share trading at a premium to its fair value.

Subscribe to get Morningstar insights in your inbox