Welcome to my column, Young & Invested, where I discuss personal finance and investing for Gen Z and Millennials.

This column aims to be a resource for young investors navigating an ever changing financial, political and social landscape as they try to build wealth. Tune in every Thursday for the latest edition.

Edition 85

Every investment is ultimately an expression of a belief.

According to the latest Class Annual Benchmark Report, the VanEck MSCI International Quality ETF (QUAL) remains one of the most widely held ETFs in Australian self-managed super funds.

Despite being the sixth-largest ETF on the ASX, QUAL ranks as the third-most held in SMSF portfolios. That suggests self-directed investors have embraced QUAL to a far greater extent than the broader investing public.

What is it about this ETF that continues to resonate with some of Australia’s most engaged investors?

Understanding quality investing

Academics have long theorised that there are a set of characteristics or ‘factors’ that help explain why certain companies outperform. These include things like the size of a company, its current valuation and relative quality.

The quality factor loosely refers to companies with higher return on equity, low debt and stable earnings. This is based on the idea that companies that consistently generate profits without excessive leverage have historically rewarded investors. In his book The Intelligent Investor, BenjaminGraham argued that financially robust companies were also better positioned to survive downturns.

VanEck MSCI International Quality ETF QUAL

  • Morningstar Medalist Rating: Bronze
  • Morningstar Category: Equity World Large Blend
  • Total Cost Ratio: 0.40% (Prospective)
  • Assets under management: 9.5 Bil (AUD)

Unpacking the index

The method in which a fund implements a quality factor varies widely. In this case, QUAL ETF tracks the MSCI World ex Australia Quality Index through a full replication approach. This means that it physically holds all the underlying securities of its target index in the exact same proportions.

The fund’s benchmark is derived from its parent MSCI World ex Australia Index, which features large and mid-cap stocks across 22 developed countries. The strategy starts by ranking all companies in the parent universe using a quality score. This score gives equal weight to three key measures: return on equity, debt-to-equity ratio and earnings-per-share (EPS) growth over the previous five years.

Then, from an initial universe of around 1,200 companies, the 300 highest-ranked stocks are selected. Notably, the methodology doesn’t impose any country or sector constraints, however individual holdings are capped at 5% of the portfolio.

What does the resulting portfolio look like?

The focus on quality naturally leads the portfolio to look quite different from the broader market.

With just 300 holdings selected from an investable universe of ~1,200 companies, QUAL takes a far more selective approach than a traditional index fund. This results in sector exposures that differ significantly.

Technology is the fund’s largest overweight position. Companies such as Microsoft have generated extraordinary returns on capital while carrying relatively little debt. As a consequence, the quality screen often ends up looking like a bet on the tech sector.

On the other hand, financial services are underrepresented relative to the broader market. Their high-leverage business models often struggle with quality screens, as selection criteria aren’t great at capturing industry nuances.

Stock-level diversification has been decent, with top ten holdings accounting for ~30% of assets over the medium term. Interestingly, the methodology has resulted in the exclusion of market heavyweights like Tesla and Amazon, which have often fallen outside the portfolio despite their prominence.

Our analyst notes that the portfolio has naturally shown a strong tilt towards companies that possess economic moats. More than three-quarters of QUAL’s holdings have a wide economic moat, meaning most of the portfolio’s constituents enjoy structural advantages that help protect their profits from competitors. Notably, that’s around 25% higher than the average global equity fund and benchmark.

Performance and costs

It’s tempting to attribute the fund’s success entirely to the quality factor, but a significant portion of QUAL’s outperformance has coincided with exposure to large US tech companies. In the decade to November 2026, the fund delivered 15.5% annually, comfortably outperforming both the parent index and category average.

Like all factor strategies, performance has varied across market environments. Stocks with quality traits are expected to be more resilient during distressed markets and high-volatility conditions.

During the February to March period in 2020, both the broader market and the average category peer declined by 8.0% and 13.0% respectively, whilst QUAL lost just 2.5%. Of course, quality investing is not a guaranteed path to outperformance. The same resilience was not observed in the 2022 bear market due to the heavy concentration in the tech sector.

More recently, the fund has ranked in the lower half of its peer group as investors have begun to reassess expectations around AI growth prospects.

Investors may turn to quality funds for very different reasons. Some may seek outperformance and use it to express a conviction that the quality factor will reward long-term investors. Others may be close to drawing down on their portfolios and quality can appear to offer a lower-volatility, capital-preserving approach to global equities. The obvious issue is that these two objectives don’t necessarily align.

Despite relative portfolio resilience, QUAL has historically been slightly more volatile than both its benchmark and the broader global equity category. This is because its quality screens have consistently favoured large tech companies that tend to experience significant share-price swings. Ultimately, the lesson for investors is that quality and defensiveness are not the same thing. Although QUAL has owned better businesses than the average index fund, it has not translated into smoother returns.

Index-tracking factor ETFs occupy a middle ground between active and passive investing. Like passive funds, they aim to replicate an underlying benchmark. However, they overlay a rules-based selection process to determine which companies best reflect relevant factors. In this way, they aim to combine the cost efficiency of passive investing with some of the return-enhancing objectives that are traditionally associated with active management.

QUAL carries a total cost ratio (prospective) of 0.40% per year. That places it in the second-cheapest quintile of its peers, where the median fee is 0.85% per year. While QUAL’s fee is significantly cheaper than most actively managed global equity funds, it is also over double the cost of its ‘truly passive’ counterpart VGS ETF, which lacks the quality overlay. The decision ultimately comes down to whether investors believe the quality screen adds enough value to justify the additional fee.

Concluding thoughts

I think QUAL’s popularity among SMSF investors is fairly intuitive. The fund offers broad global exposure to companies with strong profitability and balance sheets while also demonstrating a history of outperforming peers in the category. Arguably, that is an easier proposition to get behind than simply buying the market. It also avoids some of the pitfalls associated with active management, where investors have to rely on a manager’s ability to consistently make the right calls.

There is also behavioural appeal in the idea of owning profitable businesses with durable competitive advantages, particularly for those approaching retirement. During periods of market stress, it can be easier to stick with as opposed to owning a broad basket of companies indiscriminately.

But I don’t think we should mistake QUAL for a defensive strategy. Given the quality screen has historically led to overweight tech exposure, there have been several periods where the fund’s volatility has been elevated relative to the broader market.

If you’re simply seeking the cheapest possible fund for global equity exposure, there’s a good chance the vanilla alternative VGS is a more sensible choice.

Get Morningstar’s insights in your inbox