4 fearless predictions for 2027 and beyond
Brian Han shares his predictions for the future and what investors can do to prepare.
What will investing look like in 2007 and beyond? Brian Han, Director of Equity Research at Morningstar joins Investing Compass to share his fearless predictions for the future of markets.
From an increasingly concentrated Australian share market and machines triggering unexpected market crashes to AI reshaping the workforce, Brian explores the forces that could fundamentally change the way we invest.
He also shares what investors can do to prepare.
You can find the full transcript below:
Shani Jayamanne: Welcome to another episode of Investing Compass. Before we begin, a quick note that the information contained in this podcast is general in nature. It does not take into consideration your personal situation, circumstances, or needs.
Mark LaMonica: Shani, we have a guest episode today, which we have not done for a while. But we’re going to look, I guess, beyond 2027. We’re going to look far out in the future today, Shani. And we’re going to do that with Brian Han, who’s never been afraid of making a bold call. He is a Director of Equity Research at Morningstar, so he covers telecommunications, companies like Telstra, media and leisure sectors across Australia and New Zealand.
Jayamanne: And he previously used to write the BRIANSTORM column where he would make his fearless predictions for the years ahead. And today is an Investing Compass exclusive. We’re bringing that tradition back. It was always one of our favorite pieces from Morningstar for the year, so we’re really excited about it.
LaMonica: An exclusive.
Jayamanne: It is.
LaMonica: We should ask him to sign a confidentiality agreement. We don’t want him sitting in the cafe talking about this.
Jayamanne: No. But this is his work, so…
LaMonica: It is. It is. Okay, so we’re going to go through some big questions facing investors. So is the Australian share market slowly shrinking? And what happens when the companies we want to invest in are increasingly taken over or moved into private hands? Could the growing role of machines and algorithms create unexpected dislocations in the market? And could the rise of artificial intelligence change the balance between white collar and blue-collar work?
Jayamanne: And we’ll also talk about why uncertainty might become a more permanent feature of investing rather than something that we can wait out. And to top it all off, Brian is making this very practical for us and wants to focus on what we as investors can do about it. So we got a lot out of this chat with Brian. We know that you will too.
LaMonica: Well, Brian, thank you for joining us on the podcast today. We are going to go through your fearless predictions, which is exciting, but first we want to get inside your brain. Now, how do you come up with this list and what are you thinking about? You’re trying to identify places the market isn’t paying enough attention to.
Brian Han: It’s not as complicated as you think, Mark. And no, I’m definitely not trying to be sensationalist to get a few clicks or to get a rise out of people. But what I am trying to do is basically articulate what’s going on bubbling under the surface or what’s nagging people behind the back of their minds. And I’m trying to figure out whether those things are cyclical or temporary or permanent or structural. And then making predictions based on whether it’s one or the other and trying to position myself or hopefully our clients to better benefit from the eventuation of either cyclical factors reverting or structural factors continuing to gain momentum.
LaMonica: Okay, let’s get into the first one. So this is something that I do think a lot of investors have seen that there are a lot of ASX companies that are being taken private, getting acquired. We’re not seeing anything replacing them, so we’re not seeing a steady stream of IPOs. And I know a lot of people are frustrated by this because companies they own, companies they like are being taken private. So I guess just maybe talk a little bit about the Australian share market, if it’s a less relevant place now to find opportunities for investors, and I guess your concern about where it might be heading.
Han: Yeah, I wouldn’t say the Australian market is becoming less relevant, but I do think the market is becoming more concentrated. And if you don’t mind, Mark, let me make a couple of observations. Observation number one, when I started in this industry 30 years ago, I think banks and resources were about 35% of the market. I think now it’s over 50%. That’s the first observation. The second observation is more recent. So just this year alone, our team has seen companies like Cleanaway, Cube, Atlas Arteria, Ingenia, the old IOOF, and also very recently Challenger. They all either have been taken over or in the process of getting taken over.
The third observation I make is this year, most of the companies listing on the ASX are resources companies. So the previous figures that I gave you, that figure, that percentage of concentration in banks and resources is just going to get worse. And my concern is that investors, Australian investors particularly, are increasingly being forced to buy and chase and load up on increasingly expensive banks and increasingly volatile resources. And that means they’re straying further and further away from the underlying fundamentals of these companies. And therein lies the risk of concentration, and unwittingly, you are breaking one of the key tenets of investment, which of course is diversification.
LaMonica: So based on this, is there something that investors should do differently? Is it diversifying internationally? I guess how do you balance out in your own portfolio that risk of a really concentrated market?
Han: Yeah, so Mark, my understanding is that a typical regulated APRA fund has about 25% of the fund allocated to Australian equities. Now, if you look at a typical Aussie retail investor, that allocation to Australian equities is probably even higher. So then you try to marry that against the reality that Australian market is only about 2% to 3% of the worldwide global market. So there is an imbalance there. And I definitely think people should think more about international investing, if for no other reason than for just sensible diversification purposes.
So that’s one thing. And also, I think there’s no shortage of information, data, and research to help you to that end in this day and age. So now some people might say, I heard that even US market is quite concentrated, and that is true. I mean, I think technology constitutes about 40% of the US market. But if you look beyond the technology sector, the alternatives are still very deep and very long in the US market. And in any case, the US market itself is only 40% of the global stock market value. So there’s plenty of places to diversify internationally, and I certainly hope that investors in Australia don’t let home bias constrain their investment options.
LaMonica: Alright, let’s move on to your second prediction. And I will say, you know, I don’t want to pick a favorite, but I do really like this one because I think you know, maybe investors are not fully aware of how much trading is being done by machines or algorithms and now AI. So you raise a concern when we were talking about this before we recorded that because there growing share of market activity is done by we’ll just call them machines and machines ultimately trading with each other a lot, that this could be a situation where the market could run into trouble. so I guess maybe first an overview of sort of what your worries are about who is trading now and what that impact is.
Han: Yeah, so my understanding is that at least 70% of the trading volume going on in the stock market is done by machines, done by high frequency trading firms, done by quant firms, and done by basically machines, as you say. And I think that percentage will probably increase even more as machines get more sophisticated and AI trading becomes more prevalent. Now, the concern I have is that in the future, I think more and more often, we may wake up one morning and find that the US NASDAQ is down 15%.
And nobody knows why, except that they point to a quant firm that did all these trades and forgot to carry the one, and then everything else started going awry. Now, in the old days, we would say that’s a fat finger syndrome. In the future, it’s more akin to machines fingering everything all over the place, and humans know nothing about it. And therein lies the risk, I think, of all these machines, and that’s why I think we’re going to have more and more of these occasional market dislocations caused by machines that people can’t really explain.
LaMonica: Now, I think an interesting point, I talked a lot about on this podcast that, I’m personally a fundamental investor. It’s what we believe in at Morningstar, it’s what your team does in your research. How do you navigate this environment if you are still focused on the fundamentals and human judgment ultimately rather than something a machine is doing? So how do you see that opportunity for investors like me, like what we believe in at Morningstar?
Han: It is difficult because the overwhelming volume that’s been dictated by these machines. But going back to your first question about potential for market dislocations because of these machine factors. I think when those dislocations do happen, instead of treating it with alarmist attitude, I think that’s where we humans can really differentiate ourselves, really add value in terms of judgment and experience. So whenever we have those dislocations, that is a chance for us for fundamentally driven people to come in and put some sanity and common sense and perhaps use fundamentals to start performing this price discovery function. And that will be based on fundamentals of the companies behind the stock prices rather than the I’s and O’s behind all these trading and machines that’s going out of control. So that’s where we think we can add value in terms of that fundamental prism.
LaMonica: Yeah, and you know, I don’t want to put words in your mouth, but I think as an investor, obviously then it would be important to understand businesses, and a great way to do that is reading the research reports that you and the team put out, but really understanding businesses, understanding how they fit in your strategy, so you can take advantage of that. Because it’s going to be harder to do if you wake up and the markets drop significantly, but if you have sort of a target list of the companies.
Han: Exactly. Exactly. And when the prices run out of control because of machine trading, you always have to come back to the grassroots. What are we trying to do here? We’re trying to buy shares in these real companies trying to make more money. So, and there is an intrinsic value to the money that they are making. So that’s the value I think that we humans can add in this increasingly machinized world.
LaMonica: Yeah. And a lot of the -- I mean, a lot of this machine trading is short term, right? You know, the goal is to make profits over the short term. You think fundamentals still over the long term are going to drive share prices.
Han: Well, Mark, I have to say that because my livelihood depends on that belief. But yes, I do feel that whenever there is market dislocation, people always resort back to what it is that we’re trying to do here. How are we trying to value this company because each company I think does have an intrinsic value, and that intrinsic value is not based on some sort of the I’s and O’s of trading machines or algorithms. It is based on cash flows ultimately.
LaMonica: Yeah, and my portfolio is based on that. So I don’t want to be working here when I’m 95. So hopefully, yes, hopefully that happens. All right. Let’s talk about one thing that I hear a lot from investors, you hear a lot from investors and this idea, and you see a lot in the media about the unprecedented times we’re living in and the unprecedented amount of uncertainty. You pick it, we can name what that is. I think what this causes a lot of investors to do is they think, well, if this is unprecedented, I’ll just wait. And when there’s more clarity, then I’ll make investment decisions. But you had an interesting point about looking back in history and trying to use this context. Do you want to go through that?
Han: Yeah, I think we tend to romanticize and reminisce with fondness about how in the old days everything was so stable and so certain. But I think hindsight is always 20-20. And when I look back, if I’m being really frank with myself, I can’t remember a time when the economy was perfect, when the geopolitical landscape was absolutely stable, when everybody was happy, nobody was complaining, and everything was hunky-dory in the stock market in the world. I don’t remember any times like that. Now, it feels like at this stage, looking back, yeah, there were times like that, but at that time, I don’t think anybody felt that way. So I think once people realize that, then this notion of I want to wait until all risks are dissipated out of the horizon, I think that’s just not realistic. And if you accept that, then I think you subscribe to the adage, the classic adage that, time in the market is much, much more important than timing the market.
LaMonica: I’m going to make some broad generalizations here, which will probably offend everybody that’s listening or watching to this.
Han: We like to do that too.
LaMonica: Exactly, exactly. But do you think that, as you age and you gain more experience, you can make a statement like you just made that you don’t remember a time where there wasn’t uncertainty in the economy. Do you think maybe if you’re younger and you don’t have that experience that you’re more apt to sit out of the market? And of course, those are the people that have the longest runway, your talk about time in the market. So what would you say, not just for young investors, but for all investors, how can they try to overcome this notion of uncertainty and actually start investing?
Han: My opinion is that there’s no magic way. And certainly young people I know they want everything now and yesterday, but there is no magic way, and listening to experts talk about their experiences and especially reading history books on the market, I think that really helps. But I think younger people probably need to think about the world in a more probabilistic way and really be realistic about what it is that they’re waiting for, if it is uncertainty that they’re scared of because as I said, there’s always been uncertainty. And if they read more history books, they’ll realize that there was no point in history where it was absolutely hunky-dory. So I think they need to realize that, and then the most important thing is invest and invest consistently and invest with a horizon beyond just the one hour.
LaMonica: All right, we’re going to move on to a little bit of a different prediction. And this is around artificial intelligence. And one of the things that we’re talking about is, your view about how the traditional relationship between what was considered blue-collar work and white-collar work has changed. So for a long time, a university degree and a professional career was the pathway to financial security. But obviously, as AI continues to develop and can do more and more, potentially that’s a risk to some of those professional jobs that have, as I said, always been that pathway. So just let’s go over this. How do you think that AI could change these long-term assumptions about the proper pathway in life?
Han: Yeah, so the thing I think about is this ever since the industrial revolution in the 1800s, I think the blue-collar workers, the labor workers, have basically borne the brunt of any mechanical or technological advancements. This AI, Mark, this seems a little bit different. This seems like they’re really going at the knowledge workers, the so-called white-collar workers. And we’re talking about people like me sitting in an air conditioned tower, clicking buttons, doing emails, creating PowerPoint charts, and just checking stuff. And now you have these AI tools. They can basically do all of that much more efficiently.
And it never chucks a city, never complains about office politics, never complains about office coffee. So in that scenario, I can’t see how you can say anything but that there is going to be a shift of balance between these white-collar workers and blue-collar workers. And I really think that has a lot of implications for a lot of things, whether it’s investment, whether it’s household spending, whether even just career choices for the young people coming through. So that’s my view. But I mean, with that question, Mark, you’re opening up a whole can of worms, and I got to say, Mark, I feel fortunate that I’m more towards the end of my career than the beginning of my career because I feel I feel quite you know, nervous for the young people with the confusion on the horizon about what they’re supposed to do in this increasingly AI centric world.
LaMonica: Okay, so yeah, as you said, this is a big can of worms, but maybe let’s just narrow this to an investing standpoint, so not necessarily people’s careers. Do you think that this has implications on investors, either the companies that could be attractive or industries that they favor, and I guess just how you think about household wealth going forward and how that’s going to impact investing.
Han: Yeah, so when it comes to investing, I think this knowledge, if AI is increasingly being involved in the investment world, the chance to differentiate yourself, I think becomes probably even more difficult going forward. And that might leave some fundamentally based investors in a lurch for sustained periods. But as we talked about before, I think there will be market dislocations whereby fundamental investors will come to the fore and perform that price discovery function. But in terms of what sectors to invest in and all that, I don’t know, to tell you the truth.
All I do know is that we will have instances where this AI hype will get a little bit of correction. And we just need to wait for those opportunities and perhaps add value in terms of our experience and judgment. But certainly I can’t sit here right now and tell our listeners that that these are the sectors that you should go in and these are the sectors that you should avoid because at the end of the day, what we fundamental analysts focus on is price relative to value. I can tell you that Firmus is worth $45 billion, but I just picked that figure out of the air because the company actually doesn’t make any profit right now. So if it does list at $45 billion, on a risk reward basis, should we subscribe to that?
Or should we let it pass? Not because it’s a bad company, but because the risk reward proposition is just not quite there. So again, it is all about that price value, the risk reward that we have to be mindful of. But in terms of predicting winners and losers in this AI world, I’m still trying to figure it out, and it is becoming more difficult.
LaMonica: Is there any scenario where most companies are winners that they’re able to either take cost out of the businesses or and obviously they need to maintain prices for that margin to go up, but is that a scenario like broad based efficiency gains or I don’t know. I guess I’m just wondering if everyone could be a winner.
Han: Everyone can be a winner, except that at the end of the day it’s a relative game. So if National Australia banks, sacks 2,500 people because they only suddenly found that they can be more efficient with a few AI machines, they might have some first mover advantage for a certain period of time, but you can bet that the three other major banks will follow suit very soon with their own restructure and more efficiency gains. So if you look over the long term, does AI give any firm a sustainable competitive advantage? That’s a harder question to ask. So and coincidentally, that’s what we spend most of our time you know trying to figure out. We’re trying to figure out, we have this methodology called a economic moat, where the firms can generate and sustain excess returns. And if everybody is getting into AI to improve efficiency, then what is your sustainable competitive advantage over the long term? That’s hard to know. And that’s I guess the secret of figuring out what to invest in.
LaMonica: Yeah, because I guess every company could respond differently if they’ve taken some costs out, they could lower prices, try to gain market share, that hurts other companies. So yeah, I guess just competition would take over again is what you’re saying.
Han: Yes. Because as you know, Mark, we’re in a dynamic world where you’re not operating in a vacuum your action creates Newton’s law in another competitor, and they’ll respond. And at the end of the day, this is the whole principle of economic moat is that at its base, no excess return can be generated in this world because we live in Adam Smith’s world, all excess return will be competed away by competition. So the secret is to finding those firms who can use AI to create a sustainable competitive advantage, whether it is we can reduce your costs with AI, but our product is so superior because of some secret sauce that we can keep on increasing the pricing power, and then you have that positive opening up and hopefully it can be sustained. But you know, those companies are very hard to find, Mark, very hard to find.
LaMonica: Alright, so gone through a number of different predictions. Do you think that there’s one that investors are not focusing on or perhaps one there’s or perhaps something that somebody should do right now in response to any of your predictions?
Han: I don’t think anybody’s not underestimating anything or not aware of any of the things that we discussed, but I think the common theme that’s gone through all our talking points today is this theme about uncertainty. And I think uncertainty is one thing that I’m very certain of that it’ll continue to go on. And if we accept that then how do we prepare? I think we should prepare to be more comfortable with being uncomfortable.
I think that’s the first thing. And once you accept that first position then it’s more about being consistent, being rational and keeping an eye on the intrinsic value of things. And basically again I come back to that adage that it is time in the market more than timing the market. And one thing I do hope people will think more about is time in the market should be coupled with diversification into perhaps international markets because right now I do feel that there is a risk of concentration in the Australian market. And then the final thing I say is yeah embrace AI see what it can do for you but please not too much at the expense of your experience and judgment.
LaMonica: Alright that is great Brian so a lot of great information for investors we really appreciate you being on the podcast. Thank you very much.
Han: Thanks Mark.
(Disclaimer: Any advice in this podcast is general advice or regulated financial advice under New Zealand law prepared by Morningstar Australasia proprietary limited and/or Morningstar Research Limited without reference to your financial objectives, situations, or needs. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and any relevant product disclosure statement before making any decision to invest. To obtain advice for your own situation, contact the financial advisor.)
Invest Your Way
A message from Mark and Shani
For the past five years, we’ve released a weekly podcast and written on morningstar.com.au to arm you with the tools to invest successfully. We’ve always strived to provide independent, thoughtful analysis, backed by the work of hundreds of researchers and professionals at Morningstar.
We’ve shared our journeys with you, and you’ve shared back. We’ve listened to what you’re after and created a companion for your investing journey – Invest Your Way. Invest Your Way is a book that focuses on the investor, instead of the investments. It is a guide to successful investing, with actionable insights and practical applications.
If anyone would like to support this project you can buy the book now. Thanks in advance!
