Xero (ASX: XRO) shares rallied 6% on its first-half fiscal 2027 results. Adjusted EBITDA grew 23% on a pro forma basis, which assumes the company also owned Melio in the prior year. Pro forma revenue increased 22% in constant currency. The company also announced a NZD 1 billion buyback.

Why it matters: First-half earnings are tracking our full-year estimate. It expects to achieve a pro forma ‘Rule of 40’ score in fiscal 2027, one year earlier than previously guided. Fiscal 2028 revenue guidance is now 10% higher than previously, helped by foreign exchange. We lift our fiscal 2028 EPS estimate by 20%.

  • Based on current subscriber growth trends, the guidance implies the company intends to continue significantly hiking prices. We find this puzzling, as the company is already seeing higher customer churn and is reversing its strategy of effectively lowering prices just last year.
  • We forecast it will fall short of fiscal 2028 guidance. Alternatively, we think it would face significant slowing growth soon thereafter, as price hikes are increasingly coming at the expense of conversion of new customers and the retention of existing customers.

The bottom line: We maintain our fair value estimate for narrow-moat Xero of $100 per share. Shares have fallen 60% from their peak, driven by concerns around disruption from artificial intelligence and the acquisition of Melio. Shares screen as materially undervalued.

  • Despite the continued price hikes against the backdrop of customer pushback, we think the market is underestimating the value of the ANZ segment, as group profits are weighed down by expansion into the highly competitive US.

Coming up: We will actively monitor churn for signs it is hiking prices too much, especially in ANZ. Churn hasn’t been at current levels since 2016. Moreover, churn should have been moderating on a secular basis, as mature customers have become a larger part of the business.

Xero not done with raising prices just yet

We expect Xero’s near- and medium-term strategic focus to revolve around rationalizing its areas of investment, especially against a backdrop of normalizing demand for business software.

After the onset of the covid-19 pandemic, new business creation levels spiked while business failure rates plummeted, which we believe provided a temporary tailwind for business software.

In response to this tailwind, Xero nearly quadrupled its total expenditure on product design and development. However, we see little evidence of returns on these investments. Xero today operates mostly in the same markets as it did a decade ago. Therefore, we believe investments in country-specific adaptations of its products do little to explain the 10-fold increase in total expenditure on product design and development over the period. We also don’t see compelling evidence of returns on investment into new features and functionalities. New Zealand, Xero’s most mature market, should reflect increased average revenue per user if new features and functionalities are valued by customers. Instead, the New Zealand market has only seen low-single-digit growth in ARPU over the past decade, primarily due to price hikes in recent years, leading us to believe Xero’s small and midsize enterprise customers value simplicity, not features and functionalities.

Xero’s investments in sales and marketing in its international markets have also seen diminishing returns since the onset of the pandemic. Xero’s international customer acquisition costs, per subscriber, have grown by over 50% since the onset of the pandemic and are three times greater than those in its Australia and New Zealand markets. Although the lifetime value per international subscriber is still three times CAC, and CAC payback remains under two years, Xero’s overseas expansions have seen differing degrees of success over the past decade. Whereas Xero has successfully made inroads into the United Kingdom—where we estimate it is capturing around a third of new businesses created—in the United States, we don’t see similar success in the US, where behemoth Intuit reigns. We don’t expect the Melio acquisition to unlock this opportunity.

Bulls say

  • Xero holds a dominant market position in Australia and New Zealand, where its business is supported by network effects.
  • Xero has successfully made inroads into the UK, where it is capturing around a third of new businesses being created.
  • Under new leadership, Xero has renewed focus on fiscal discipline.

Bears say

  • Xero’s customer base of SMEs is low-quality, due to the segment’s inherently high business failure rates. This will require constant spending on sales and marketing to replenish churned customers.
  • Xero has been unsuccessful at making inroads into the US.
  • Xero has a chequered history regarding fiscal discipline, especially in product design and development.