Consumption drives investment not the other way around

--  |   09/11/2018 Text size  Decrease  Increase   |  
<p><strong>Glenn Freeman</strong>: I'm joined today by Peter Warnes, and we're following up on his presentation at the Morningstar Individual Investor Conference. Peter, you covered a lot of ground there ranging from the broader macro-thematic things through to some of the more micro-Australian-centric topics. Now, can we just start on some of the big picture items that you're covering off there?</p> <p><strong>Peter Warnes</strong>: Yeah. Glenn, the big picture is that Economics 101's demand and supply affects all markets, and it will play itself out, and even the White House should understand that. So, from the equity market side, demand has exceeded supply for many, many years now, driven by improving fundamentals and now those fundamentals basically peaking high GDP growth, high earnings &ndash; corporate earnings growth and may look like they're starting to peak. That has been a very, very fundamental demand driver for equities.</p> <p>Overlaying that, you've had a very, very significant increase in buybacks and dividends, but more buybacks, $800 billion through the year ended August, and by the end of the year, estimated to be nearly $1 trillion.</p> <p><strong>Freeman</strong>: We've been seeing more just lately that I think just this week we've seen BHP with another $100 million buyback announced?</p> <p><strong>Warnes</strong>: Yeah. Well, the management have understood to get a better bang for your buck, you got &ndash; run for short-term, give the money back to shareholders that attracts them to the market. And so, demand &ndash; another slice of demand force, if you like, overlaying the improving fundamentals. So, that's been the enabler and sounds sustainable.</p> <p>U.S. corporate in the year, again, to August and September, they had paid out over 100% of operating earnings in buybacks and dividends, unsustainable. And then you've also had a very, very major switch from active to passive managers. That flow of funds whilst not necessarily a driver of demand, but don&rsquo;t forget when you have passive managers, they've got to be 100% invested, so they replicate the benchmark and so that cash that might have been held by an active manager as an asset allocation has gone into the market as well. So, those three demand drivers have pushed the markets to record levels. Two of them are unsustainable, the last two, the passive management and buybacks, and the fundamental drivers are starting to weaken.</p> <p><strong>Freeman</strong>: So, you're saying potentially that if, say, dividend yields for equities markets are going to decline looking forward, more than likely, does that &ndash; are bonds &ndash; these fixed income potentially going to become more attractive if yields there are going up?</p> <p>Warnes: Well, potentially, yes, Glenn, because GFC, post-GFC, investors were getting basically nothing for cash, very little for bonds because some of the interest rates were so low. And you push further and further out the risk curve to get yield. Now what will happen is that &ndash; but be careful, because don't forget, if you buy a bond, you won't take a capital loss unless you hold it to maturity. So, don't go and buy a 30-year bond because you won't be holding that to maturity. Stay short, very short; in other words, two, maybe five years, but I've been waiting a little because these bond yields are going to push up and then probably six or nine months down the track look to position yourself in a bond. But you could go in there now and nimble.</p> <p>Again, in the hybrid space, the CBA (pulls), those type of things and there will be more supply of that coming, look at those situations, particularly the ones that aren't so much equity related, more debt related and higher up in the capital structure. So, there's a couple of opportunities coming, and investors are going to get a bit more return for their money. But make sure that you have a look at the risk-adjusted rates of return, not the headline ahead of return.</p> <p><strong>Freeman</strong>: Sure. And also, just turning to the local household level, you spoke about that and how the rising costs for Australian households in tandem with the time when we are seeing flatlining wage growth, what were you saying there?</p> <p><strong>Warnes</strong>: Well, again, it's all about GDP growth. And the biggest contributor to GDP growth in Western developed economies is household consumption. Household consumption is 24x7. That's what you've got to stimulate and if you stimulate that and sustain it, then that will be a very, very major foundation stone for your GDP growth.</p> <p>At the moment, and I ask the question of the audience, how many people think the household expenses are going up at the inflation rate of 2%, and there's not one person to put a hand up. And that's the reason why this is a serious situation, because I'll say, the household consumption is so significant. So, what the government should be doing is stimulating household consumption by a meaningful cut in personal tax. It probably won't happen, but that's what should happen. Don't worry about cutting corporate tax rates and what have you. Consumption drives investment; investment has never driven consumption.</p>

Video Archive...

A blueprint for building your financial plan
22/05/2019  A new book offers straightforward advice from start to finish.
Super policy shifts and the retirement roadmap
15/11/2018  Saving for retirement is well catered-for within existing superannuation provisions, but the transition to pension mode isn’t as developed, says Vanguard’s Robin Bowerman.
Consumption drives investment not the other way around
09/11/2018  As Australia’s equity market nears its peak and share buy-backs hit unsustainable levels, investors need to also be mindful of rising interest rates and government policy, says Morningstar's Peter Warnes.
Switching up your SMSF for income
08/11/2018  There are still considerable benefits when switching your SMSF to drawdown phase, despite the complexities and potential political changes ahead, says SMSF Association’s Peter Hogan. 
SMSF paperwork crucial to avoid legal problems
02/11/2018  Recent SMSF court cases in Queensland highlight the importance of keeping your documentation in line, says lawyer Shane Ellis.
Will You Hit Your Projected Retirement Date?
03/10/2018  Many factors can impact when you can retire, so targeting a specific date to stop working may not be an ideal strategy. 
Retirement income: expectations versus reality
24/09/2018  Schroders' global head of retirement discusses how investors approaching retirement can fill the retirement income gap, and why professional advice is so important.
The importance of flexible retirement planning
14/08/2018  Building a contingency plan around when you intend to retire is better than setting a firm date ahead of time, according to a recent study from Morningstar's head of retirement research.
Why you need a retirement policy statement
25/07/2018  A document detailing your retirement plans – both in the lead-up and once you begin drawing on your savings – is a great idea, according to Morningstar's US-based director of personal finance.
VIDEO | Investors hoard cash at their peril, says JP Morgan
07/06/2018  When it comes to thinking about retirement, a survey of Hong Kong investors mirrors errors made by investors in the developed world at large: they are saving too little and relying too much on cash, says JP Morgan's Wina Appleton
Shifting laws not denting SMSF demand
01/11/2017  The advantages of a self-managed super funds continue to outweigh the negatives, even though frequent legislative changes add complexity, according to Natasha Fenech, CEO, SuperConcepts.
Superannuation not political football
19/10/2017  The politicisation of Australia's super system; greater uptake of income streams in retirement; and the policy alignment of aged care and retirement planning.
Earnings season FY17 mixed bag so far
18/08/2017  Aside from a few high-profile earnings guidance misses, large-cap stocks are doing okay as FY17 reporting season passes halfway, says AMP chief economist Shane Oliver.
Self-managed super is not Do-it-yourself
03/07/2017  There are a few common pitfalls in running a self-managed super fund that mean trustees shouldn't go it alone entirely, says BT Financial Group's head of financial literacy, Bryan Ashenden.
3 pockets of opportunity in fixed income
07/06/2017  The head of PIMCO Australia gives his views on active management in fixed income and tells us where he sees most value in this space.
No free lunch as fixed-income market shifts
07/04/2017  More difficult market conditions in a rising interest rate environment highlight the value of active management across your portfolio, says Simon Doyle, Schroders' head of fixed income and multi-asset.