What I am doing with my gold allocation
Navigating uncertainty in a speculative market.
Gold is becoming a hot ticket item, evidenced by the lines outside the ABC Bullion store in Martin Place Sydney.
Presumably, these people are there to buy physical gold rather than to sell it!
Is it a boom? Is it a bubble?
I’ve owned gold for 17 years and I didn’t think I’d ever see scenes such as these. I also have friends who’ve never shown interest in gold and who are now buying the metal.
That tells you something.
I thought it would be worthwhile to recount my own journey as a holder of gold – why I bought it, why I’ve held onto it for so long, the mistakes I’ve made along the way, and what I intend to do with it now.
Why I bought gold
In May 2008, the financial world hadn’t blown up though there had been a steady flow of news coming out of the US about subprime lending bankruptcies.
I was concerned enough at the time to put a reasonable amount of my net worth into physical gold coins.
I didn’t do it on a whim. Up to that point, I’d acquired a significant degree of knowledge about the yellow metal. I’d been a resources analyst covering gold companies in Asia and the US. Later, I did freelance writing on gold for some of the world’s largest precious metal publications and websites.
I was also a keen student of history and knew that bad things happen on a regular basis – societal breakdowns, world wars, and plagues – and gold had endured.
You’ll see a lot of things written about gold and I regard most of it as bunkum.
Detractors say it’s just a speculative tool. If that’s the case, why has it lasted so long?
Others say that gold doesn’t earn anything and therefore you can’t value it. Yet, there are a lot of things that don’t earn anything but still have value. And gold has held its value through history. For instance, its value has largely kept pace with inflation in USD terms through US history.
People also point to a host of drivers for gold – that it trades inversely to the USD, that it correlates to US inflation break evens and that it is an inflation hedge. All of these have been proven wrong.
I bought gold for two reasons:
- As a store of value
- As insurance against government stupidity
My view is that gold is principally a store of value. Whereas every major currency has come and gone through time, gold has been the lone survivor.
Also, I consider it a useful hedge against government stupidity. Students of history know that every major superpower over the past 2,000 years has declined because they ended up spending more than they were earning, used excessive debt to finance the spending, and devalued their currency in the process.
Why I held onto it
It’s easy to look back in hindsight and say that I’ve been lucky to have held onto gold for as long as I have. Yet, it hasn’t always been easy.
Through the 2010s, the gold price essentially did nothing.
Source: ABC Bullion
This was a decade when stocks and bonds boomed, and gold badly trailed. Retail and institutional investors had no interest in the metal and mocked anyone who did.
I held onto the coins as a portion of my portfolio because I still regarded gold as a store of value. I also believed that government stupidity hadn’t disappeared. That while the US had saved the financial system in 2008, it also kicked a lot of its problems down the road. The same went for Europe in 2012. The subsequent zero-bound interest rates were lunacy. Then followed Covid-19 and the extraordinary spending that governments did to help economies.
The truth was I also regarded gold as a ‘set and forget’ investment, and I didn’t take much notice of its price through those years.
My attitude changed in mid-2024 as the gold price started moving much higher. I sold a decent chunk of my holdings then. It was partly to reduce the proportion of gold in my portfolio.
What I’m doing now
In coming days, I’m going to be lining up with those people at ABC bullion – to sell gold rather than buy it.
I intend to sell about half of my current holdings. The remainder will be a relatively small amount.
Why am I selling? Because it’s clear to me that gold has gone from being a store of value that few are interested in, to being an instrument for speculation that everyone is interested in.
I’m remaining a holder of gold because I still have a high degree of scepticism about current government spending, especially in the US, which is on an unsustainable path.
Lessons from the investment
My gold investment has yielded an annual return of close to 11% per annum – decent, and better than most alternatives over that period.
It’s taught me many lessons about investing, including:
- It’s important to form your own opinions on investments rather than follow those of others.
- Having solid reasons for an investment helps you hang on for the long haul.
- ‘Setting and forgetting’ is the best way to keep and hold onto an investment.
- Selling is hard. I sold too early, before euphoria really hit. But I’m not going to beat myself up about it.
- When people are lining up to buy and friends are buying, it’s probably time to sell.
While my gold investment has turned out favourably, some other investments haven’t gone as well, and I’ve documented many of those in Firstlinks previously.
If you would like to join the conversation and provide your opinion about the contents of this article, you can leave you comment on the original article on Firstlinks.
