Few values left in global stock market

Morningstar US  |   20/03/2017 Text size  Decrease  Increase   |  

Jeremy Glaser: After an eight-year market rally it should come as no surprise that there are an increasing number of questions about if the market is overvalued and if there are any attractive pockets left.

Recently, Morningstar's global equity research directors came together in Chicago, and we had the opportunity to talk to each of them about where they see valuations today and what some of their best investment ideas are.

Michael Holt: Globally, if we aggregate the price/fair value estimates, from of all our analysts, we come up with median value of 1.04. Now this is a number that's easy to misinterpret, but the simple version is, there are far more names that are overvalued than we're seeing that are undervalued right now. So, as an investor, you have to be far more selective and make sure you're doing your homework on every name you look at.

Now this valuation is not spread equally across all the sectors. We see a couple, like basic materials and the energy sector, where it looks even more overvalued than the rest of the sector, so you have to be even more selective and do your due diligence in those areas.

Last, I'd just like to add, make sure you understand when a stock is fairly valued, what does that mean? It means that we don't see the margin of safety we'd like to have as an investor to capture that capital appreciation. However, we do expect a 3-star stock, which is fairly valued, to deliver a total return in line with the cost of equity, so there is an opportunity cost to holding cash. So, take a look at the quality of the business. See if they have economic moats and see if you're protected if, through the cyclical nature of the market. That's how you can make good investment decisions.

Elizabeth Collins: Looking at the companies and sectors that the North American equity research analysts cover, we do see a lot of companies and industries that are overvalued. In general, we think that the market is pricing in a lot of optimism and not taking into account a lot of things that could go wrong in the future. Some of the things that are being priced in are things like deficit spending, increased spending on military, infrastructure increases, higher interest rates due to higher inflation expectations and lower taxes. While all of these things would be undoubtedly good for equity valuations, there are things that would come with the cost, and these are things like gridlock in Washington, D.C. might mean that these things don't come to fruition.

Similarly, there could be increased competition. Infrastructure spending that raises commodity prices would ultimately be met with new supply that drives down commodity prices. Likewise, lower taxes that benefit companies' bottom lines should ultimately benefit consumers in the form of lower prices in the absence of strong and sustainable economic moats. Given that, we do think that the market tends to be, in general, fairly valued, though we do see some sectors that have weaker valuations. Those sectors are communication services, real estate, healthcare, and consumer cyclical.

I'd like to give you a couple of our best ideas within the undervalued sectors. First, I'd like to talk about Roche. It's a biopharmaceutical company and they also have a diagnostics business. A lot of healthcare companies are facing the threat of cost containment, but this is actually a threat that plays into the advantages of Roche. Because of their in-house diagnostic arm, they have advantages when it comes to personalized medicine, which should lower cost, all else equal. They also have competitive advantages because of their biologics and the inability of competitors to replicate those biological innovations.

Another best idea that I'd like to talk to you about is Williams-Sonoma. They do the namesake Williams-Sonoma stores, also Pottery Barn and West Elm. This is a category that isn't facing a lot of headwinds, and we do think that the company has a narrow moat thanks to the intangible asset of their brand, which helps consumers decide that their products have higher quality and are worth spending money on. And we do think that they are ahead of their competitors when it comes to things like supply chain management, consumer analytics, and e-commerce. All said, we think that the market is being overly pessimistic about both Roche and Williams-Sonoma and they're two of our top picks in undervalued sectors.

Alex Morozov: Looking across to European equities, if you just look at it from a relative perspective, compare it for example to the US stock market, you can perhaps sense that the European market is relatively undervalued relative to the US It's not necessarily how we look at things, but that from a multiple perspective, European stocks do look a little bit cheaper. There are a couple of reasons, perhaps, for that.

Well, one, probably the most important one is that the growth in Europe is weaker than the US You still have a lot of countries that perhaps are not pulling their weight. Southern Europe is still not out of the woods. There's still a lot of concern about the general growth environment in Europe, and most European companies do have a bit of an outsize exposure to Europe as a continent.

And then a second way of looking at it--perhaps this is more of a headline risk, if you will--there's still a lot of uncertainty over political environment in Europe. Last year, Brexit was a major shock to the system. A lot of UK stocks have really taken a beating, and we still have a number of major political events in Europe that could provide this additional shock.

What we try to do though, we look at the companies that can and will have this sustainable earnings power that could survive whatever shocks the system's is going to provide. So the companies with economic moats are critical. Even though the European market as a whole is probably fairly valued, stock-picking is critical for us as is the case with all the analysts at Morningstar, but in an environment where you see a lot of fairly valued, perhaps even overvalued stocks, we still have a few interesting ideas in this space.

When we look at some of the top picks that we have, it's not surprising those are the companies with economic moats. My favorite name right now--especially considering that this is in the consumer staples space and consumer staples have run quite a bit a lot of the valuations are quite stretched, so not too many ideas that we have in consumer staples--but one that we do have is actually a wide moat, InBev, the largest beer manufacturer in the world. This is the company that last year completed his acquisition of SABMiller and with that, it became by far the biggest beermaker in the world.

The company has a few issues. It's exposed to emerging markets and when you are exposed to emerging markets, you are benefiting from perhaps higher growth in those areas, but you're also much more susceptible to some of the shocks that you see with emerging markets, whether it's currency, whether it's growth volatility, etc., but ABI has a very powerful business model, both given its size, its ability to extract pricing concession from its suppliers. Right now, it's trading about a 10 per cent discount to intrinsic value. It represents a really unique opportunity to buy this wide-moat business that rarely goes on sale.

The other ideas from Europe I have are in the aviation industry. One of them is the plane manufacturer Airbus. The other one is the aviation parts manufacturing company called Safran. Airbus has a narrow economic moat. Safran has a wide economic moat. Both benefit from a transition to the narrow body planes that we're going to see over the next 10, 20 years. Both are also companies that have gone under significant transformation, their operating model. We see a lot of upside in both of those companies. We see significant potential for margin uplift, earnings growth. Most importantly, those are the companies that regardless of what happens in Europe in terms of the political turmoil, weaker than expected growth, those the companies that we're confident and comfortable with our forecast for the next 15-, 20-plus years. And that gives us confidence in our recommendation of those two wonderful businesses.

Adam Fleck: We view the Australian market as particularly overvalued right now, trading at about a 9 per cent premium to our amalgamated fair value estimates. There's really a couple of key reasons for that. In Australia, of course, the financial services industry and the materials market make up the bulk of the tradable assets. In particular, we see commodities as overvalued right now. BHP and Rio are two of the largest that we have 1- and 2-star ratings on. And really, what has happened there is we continue to expect significantly lower commodity prices, particularly those that are related to the steel industry, over the long run as China's economy slows and rebalances, leading to a sharp fall in the several years to come.

So, it's really no surprise that we see the Australian market as overvalued right now. However, we still think there are some pockets of opportunity, especially as you look outside the materials space. They're somewhat few and far in between, but I wanted to share a few with you. The first, when you really look for undervalued names, you start to see some names that perhaps are not of the highest quality. One such name might be Ten Network. This is a no-moat company that we think has poor stewardship and very high uncertainty, but nonetheless trades at a 44 per cent price/fair value ratio, a substantial discount to our fair value estimate.

This is one of three commercial TV networks in Australia. And it's come under pressure recently as the company expects negative EBITDA this year, given some of the increased competitive pressure and pressure from the advertising market more generally. However, we're supportive of management's investments in content in this business. It's already paid off with some rising market share, up to 24 per cent from 21 per cent a few years ago. We expect that to get up to about 25 per cent over the long run, and see EBITDA returning to a positive long single-digit rate, which drives our fair value estimate.

If you start to look at 4-star names, you can see some opportunities and some higher quality stocks. One would be Brambles. This is a wide-moat stock that trades at 4 stars. It is the largest, global provider of pallet and reusable plastic crate pooling services. And unlike Ten, we think Brambles has a wide economic moat, based on its global scale and cost competitiveness and cost advantage. This is a business that's been hit hard from increased competition recently. It's also seen some inventory destocking at the customer level, and e-commerce has had some negative impacts as well. However, we see the company re-investing in its pallet quality. It's done so in the past. That's typically taken 12-18 months or so, but as it does that and feels the benefit of that longer term, we don't see a threat to the company's wide economic moat. And with retail sales continuing to improve, particularly in the US where this company has a nice presence, we see the market undervaluing the name right now.

Lorraine Tan: Return of risk appetite in Asia has led to a narrowing of upside gains that we see in equities. Having said that, we still think there are a lot of buying opportunities in selective stocks. There are also areas, whereby on a midterm basis, that will still benefit from some of the key themes and developments that will continue on for the next few years.

Starting with China, we look at that. A lot of the buy calls that we had in the financials and real estate space have run up but we still like the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China. The bad news over the past few years on the potential NPLs are still probably there, but we're seeing a uptick in macro activity, particularly on the infrastructure side, that should sort of alleviate some of the pressures going on for some of the financial institutions. In this regard, we thing there's still upside potential for ICBC on a midterm basis.

The other area that we're quite keen on in terms of the China policy developments is essentially factors that involve the environmental aspect, whether it's on the clean energy side or whether it's in terms of the reform that's going on in terms of tariff pricing for a number of the utilities and activities there. The key names that we like, we have a couple of ideas here. These include one of our best ideas, which is Guangshen Railway. We think the government will need to increase tariffs to help alleviate the debt situation for the former Ministry of Railway, and that will help improve the returns that companies like Guangshen Railway will see. The company's in a nice net cash position as well, so we think that's a relatively safe bet to have in a portfolio.

Companies such as ENN Energy and Beijing Enterprises, the latter being another best idea, will also benefit from situations of continued encouragement in terms of the gas usage in China as they move away from coal. That means also more reforms in terms of gas pricing and continued growth in terms of fairly strong growth in this sector and these companies are all enjoying pretty high returns on investor capital at this stage.

Turning to Japan, Japan has had a good runup, mainly because of the yen factor. But we are actually seeing some situations of companies actually benefiting from longer term corporate restructurings that are going on. We like in particular the Mitsubishi UFJ financial group. This is a bank, the leading bank in Japan, and the reflating story will definitely benefit MUFJ, and the fact that it's also still trading below its book value means that there's still some upside potential. It's got a fairly diverse global flow of revenue and we think that will also give the bank some additional opportunities in terms of driving loan growth.

For the rest of the other Japanese stocks, we also like Murata Manufacturing. It's for a longer basis in terms of its passive components. It not only gets a benefit from what's going on in terms of what's going on in terms of the smartphone demand, which will continue to grow in terms of LTE and 5G activities, but we think its movement in terms of the more passive components for the auto industry will also drive future demand for its output.

Video Archive...

3 top themes in Asian markets
14/02/2018  Diverse themes within financial services and renewables are among the top picks for 2018 from Nikko Asset Management's Eng-Teck Tan.
Broadly positive results from Aussie financials
08/02/2018  An assessment of the latest financial results from Commonwealth Bank, NAB, AMP and Macquarie Bank from Morningstar's David Ellis.
3 companies tipped for growth
08/02/2018  These very distinct companies across gaming, healthcare and construction are among T. Rowe Price's top Australian equity picks.
How to keep cool when the market is not
06/02/2018  Steve Wendel, Morningstar's head of behavioral sciences, offers some tips for staying rational amid market volatility.
What should you do about the market slump?
05/02/2018  The US stock market had its worst day in two years on Friday, triggering Asian and European markets to sell off too--what should investors do?
Cutting through noise on rising oil price
01/02/2018  How the Brent crude price rise to almost $70 a barrel affects Morningstar's outlook for the likes of Woodside and Santos, and have investors left it too late.
Some retailers less Amazon-exposed than others
24/01/2018  Jeff Bezos’ behemoth will continue to dominate retail news in 2018, but the short-term impact on these retailers will be muted, says Morningstar’s Johannes Faul.
What this moat upgrade means for investors
16/01/2018  Morningstar's increased moat rating for this locally-based hearing aid manufacturer and distributor reflects its shifting strategy and potential for increased service revenue, says Morningstar's Chris Kallos.
Solid dividend, earnings outlook for this utility
11/01/2018  This New Zealand utility is a top pick in the sector, but as a dual-listed entity there are some things to be aware of, says Morningstar senior equity analyst, Adrian Atkins.
Why we're bearish on aluminium prices
29/12/2017  We're forecasting a decrease in demand and think the impact of capacity cuts is being overstated.
Forecast 2018: The China opportunity, and sectors to watch
21/12/2017  These sectors and companies are tipped to perform in 2018, in part driven by the shifting relationship between Australia and China -- Part 2 of 2
Forecast 2018: A correction looms, volatility returns to global markets
21/12/2017  Global markets will likely flatten in 2018, and volatility will return, says Peter Warnes, Morningstar's head of equities research Australasia -- Part 1 of 2
Will mining shares survive a commodities slump?
20/12/2017  How have mining stocks performed in 2017? And how sensitive to underlying commodity prices are the shares?
Strong investor upside in Westfield acquisition
14/12/2017  This top-100 ASX company will be part of a retail empire worth more than $90 billion if the proposed acquisition by Unibail-Rodamco proceeds.
Inside the Tatts, Tabcorp merger
08/12/2017  With the merger of these two gaming companies close to completion, Morningstar equity analyst Daniel Ragonese looks at what this means for investors.
What Domain's Fairfax split means for investors
05/12/2017  Looking under the hood of property listings business, Domain, following its separation from Fairfax, and how Morningstar views the newly ASX-listed entity.
Royal Commission no Big 4 game-changer
04/12/2017  Government's "bank-flip" decision to pursue a Royal Commission into Australia's financial sector won't affect banks' fundamental value or our positive outlook, says Morningstar's David Ellis.
The Amazon eagle has landed
23/11/2017  As the online retail behemoth touches down in Australia, Morningstar's Johannes Faul explains what it could mean for some of your best-loved stocks
Slowdown in China's GDP growth means shift for investors
24/10/2017  We expect further pressure on China's economic outlook as sources of productivity gains continue to dry up.
2 quality stock picks from Anton Tagliaferro
23/10/2017  Investors Mutual's Anton Tagliaferro looks at a couple of quality companies which he believes boast strong competitive advantages.
Wild ride in FY17 and more to come - part 2
13/09/2017  Morningstar's Peter Warnes discusses how you may want to position your portfolio in FY18, as geopolitical storms continue to rage and safe-haven assets feel the effects.
Wild ride in FY17 and more to come - part 1
12/09/2017  Cost-out remained a dominant theme for large-cap Australian companies in FY17, and looking ahead to FY18, they should be clearer on cap-ex, says Peter Warnes, Morningstar’s head of equities research – Australasia.
Upbeat Woolies result tempered by Big W
30/08/2017  Woolworths' category-topping FY17 result driven by surprisingly strong sales, even as sector faces tougher times ahead, explains Morningstar's Johannes Faul.
Coke Amatil 1H17 result leaves margin of safety
28/08/2017  A challenged earnings announcement from Coca-Cola's Australian-listed business was largely expected, but downside is already priced in and improvements are expected in FY18.
How slashed Telstra dividend affects our outlook
23/08/2017  Brian Han remains reasonably positive on the telco giant even after some disappointments in the FY17 earnings announcement.
Earnings season FY17 mixed bag so far
18/08/2017  Aside from a few high-profile earnings guidance misses, large-cap stocks are doing okay as FY17 reporting season passes halfway, says AMP chief economist Shane Oliver.
CBA's impressive FY17 result marred by AUSTRAC case
11/08/2017  A typically clean, solid and big $9.8 billion result from Commonwealth Bank of Australia was somewhat overshadowed by ongoing coverage of its alleged role in money laundering.
Rio Tinto posts mixed result for 1H17
10/08/2017  An interim result of US$3.9 billion in net profits after tax for one of the world's largest mining companies was positive but slightly weaker than expected, even alongside a record dividend, explains Morningstar's Mat Hodge.
Kerr Neilson on why global investment exposure is key
07/08/2017  There are two types of investors, regardless of market noise, imputation credits, diversification approaches and market indices, says the managing director of Platinum Asset Management.
An interview with Westpac CEO, Brian Hartzer - Part 3
20/07/2017  Insights on Australia's housing market, China's effect on domestic banks, and cyber-security readiness, in the final instalment of Brian Hartzer's interview with Morningstar's David Ellis.
Telstra won’t be blown away by headwinds
17/07/2017  While it faces what Morningstar equity analyst Brian Han describes as a whirlwind of negatives, he suggests investors shouldn’t hang up on Telstra.
An interview with Westpac CEO, Brian Hartzer - Part 2
13/07/2017  Westpac CEO Brian Hartzer joins Morningstar banking analyst David Ellis to discuss digital disruption, regulatory change and Australian banks' social license.
The home-truths of investing
12/07/2017  Look for companies that sit outside the cycle; heed the lessons of history; and remember the power of compounding, says Bennelong's Neale Goldston-Morris.
An interview with Westpac CEO, Brian Hartzer - Part 1
06/07/2017  Brian Hartzer, CEO, Westpac joins Morningstar senior analyst David Ellis to discuss his role leading Australia's oldest bank, how Westpac can continue to grow value, and its commitment to sustainability.
Budget 2017: bank levy a potential 4pc hit to big 5 profits
10/05/2017  If unable to pass on costs associated with the new levy proposed in the Budget, bank profits and dividends could dive 4 to 5 per cent, in a significant hit to shareholders and customers.
2 leisure stocks weather Cyclone Debbie, Dreamworld fallout
02/05/2017  These two companies with large theme park operations have faced significant challenges in recent times. Morningstar senior equity analyst Brian Han explains how they've fared.
Schroders stays hot on commodities, cooler on tech and defensives
01/05/2017  Long-term investors in Australian shares will continue to find value, but the time for risk-taking on more speculative plays has passed, says Martin Conlon, Schroders’ head of Australian equities.
What lies ahead for mining and materials
10/04/2017  Iron ore, coal, lithium, and uranium: some end-markets will rise and others will fall behind, says Morningstar commodities and resources analyst David Wang.
First-half 2017 earnings season insights
15/03/2017  Companies produced reasonably good results overall with only a few standouts, even as a cost-out theme dominated, says Peter Warnes, head of equities research, Morningstar.
Earnings season wrap: BHP exercises good cost control
27/02/2017  As the curtains close on the 1H17 reporting season, BHP books earnings that are slightly softer than expected, while Woolies takes market share at the expense of margins.
Earnings season wrap: Telstra feels competitive heat
17/02/2017  As the 1H17 earnings season rolls on, Wesfarmers posts a bumper profit, Newcrest restores its interim dividend, while Telstra's profit falls as it feels the heat of intense competition.
Earnings season wrap: Rio Tinto's dividend surprises
10/02/2017  Rio Tinto delivers a surprise full-year payout of US$1.70, NAB records a soft first quarter, and CIMIC posts an annual net profit in line with Morningstar's expectations.
Xero CFO gives outlook for 2017 and beyond
02/02/2017  Sankar Narayan, chief operating and financial officer of accounting software firm Xero gives his insights on the company's business model and outlook, with Morningstar analyst Gareth James adding his views.
Shifting fortunes for ANZ, more of the same for CBA in 2017
12/01/2017  Australian banks are well-positioned as they head into 2017, with ANZ moving from least profitable in 2016 to become one of the sector's top performers and CBA remaining an investor favourite.