Vanguard is adapting to stiff competition
Advice, high-conviction active, and private equity are three big initiatives.
Vanguard is still the world’s largest retail mutual fund family, but it has had to adapt to stiff challenges to its hegemony. If trends persist, for example, BlackRock and its iShares ETF business in 2021 will take in more new money than Vanguard’s US funds for the second year in a row.
Nearly five decades ago, Vanguard was the disrupter, adopting a direct-to-investor sales model and launching the first retail index fund. To keep from becoming the disrupted, the family has embarked on several initiatives to burnish its brand and further transform the industry. Three of the biggest initiatives are offering more advice, enhancing its actively managed stock funds, and expanding access to private equity. But these efforts pose challenges for Vanguard--including staying true to its ideals.
Fees can fall only so far
Modest fees are one of those ideals, but Vanguard is no longer always the cheapest. Although it remains the progenitor of low-cost index funds and its mutual ownership structure helps it maintain the industry’s lowest average fees, Vanguard has become a victim of its own success. Its indexing revolution has worked so well that miniscule- or even no-cost broad market exposure has become a commodity product. Indeed, Fidelity ZERO funds are free to retail investors with a Fidelity brokerage account.
Vanguard’s relentless focus on cutting its own costs can’t go much further, either. Over the past decade, its asset-weighted US average expense ratio has fallen from 0.17% to 0.09%. Significant future reductions will only become more difficult, and the pace is sure to slow. Vanguard must find other ways to retain clients and attract new ones.
Making advice accessible
Vanguard has sought to differentiate itself by offering advice--ironic, because it originally had no intention of doing so. Vanguard owed its early survival not to growth in passive assets but to its 1977 decision to eliminate sales charges and sell direct, bypassing the commission-based advice structure that then predominated. In the words of founder Jack Bogle, “[W]e staked our existence on a new distribution strategy, which required independent investors to make intelligent choices.”
As assets grew and client accounts swelled and got more complicated, Bogle, to his credit, began questioning the firm’s assumption that it should not “provide custom-made investment advice and asset allocation guidance.” Then, in the 1990s, Vanguard entered the advice business.
Its early efforts were difficult to scale, and a high investment minimum made ongoing advice inaccessible to most. That changed with the respective May 2015 and May 2020 launches of Vanguard Personal Advisor Services and Vanguard Digital Advisor.
In some non-US markets, such as China, where the family recently abandoned plans to launch index funds, Vanguard is focusing on advice. Its joint venture with China’s Ant Financial to offer a mobile-based retail service had more than 1 million Chinese users a year after its April 2020 launch.
Investing in its active business
Vanguard also continues to invest in its active equities business, which will become more important as indexed options commoditize further. The strength of Vanguard’s offerings, most of which are run by multiple external subadvisors, has been their relative predictability, as Bogle himself said.
Combining several capable managers with similar but distinct styles in a low-fee fund tends to produce long-term results that exceed most peers’ and compete with benchmarks’.
Democratising private equity
Vanguard is trying to democratise yet another asset class by offering private equity. Unlike in the public market, PE investing requires an initial pledge of capital that can be called upon in whole or in part at any time within the commitment period, typically five years. Once deployed, investments are difficult to trade and their outcome often uncertain for years. Private equity investments can lead to such outsize returns that a few hits will cover up for many misses and produce results, even after hefty fees, that are competitive with if not much better than those of public equities over the same period. There is a wider range in outcomes, though, and the risk of losing money for good is higher.
Diversification is even more important in private equity, which led Vanguard to partner with private equity fund-of-funds purveyor HarbourVest in February 2020.
MORE ON THIS TOPIC: Vanguard steps further into private equity
Vanguard’s PE efforts show many hallmarks of its investor-centered ethos. The partnership’s profitability for HarbourVest doesn’t become meaningful until its fund exceeds an 8 per cent annualised hurdle rate.
Still, some of Vanguard’s PE statements read like justifications for the asset class. For example, “Vanguard expects a broadly diversified PE program with exposure to top-performing managers to outperform global equities by 350 basis points at the median” and to “meaningfully improve” a liquid portfolio’s likelihood of success “absent significant market tilts.”
A PE allocation isn’t akin to global public equities and includes market tilts. Historically, US early-stage tech, biotech, and communications services companies, clustered in Silicon Valley and Boston, have dominated the PE market. Vanguard could instead compare PE results with indexes and top-performing public equity managers with similar exposures as a better gauge of investor success.
Although Vanguard’s continued retail dominance isn’t a forgone conclusion, its relevance is almost assured. Vanguard’s three promising, albeit imperfect, initiatives suggest it is more on mission than not, striving to increase investors’ chances for success in new ways.