Morningstar Investor users sign in here.

Funds

Most active managers underperform, again: S&P

Aussie small cap managers are among the few who can consistently beat the index.

Mentioned: Magellan Global Open Class (15699), Hyperion Small Growth Companies (4242), Platinum International Fund (4505), Domino's Pizza Enterprises Ltd (DMP), Fisher & Paykel Healthcare Corp Ltd (FPH), WiseTech Global Ltd (WTC), Xero Ltd (XRO)


Few things in life are certain: Death, taxes and active manager underperformance. So no surprise when the latest edition of S&P’s SPIVA scorecard showed most active managers lagged their indexes in FY 2021.

Fifty-nine per cent of active managers in Australian and international equities underperformed their index on a risk adjusted basis in FY 2021, according to the report published Monday. That falls to half for mid-and-small-cap managers. Aussie bond managers were a bright spot, with two thirds beating their index.

The S&P SPIVA Australia scorecard compares the performance of 1,545 Australian funds against their benchmarks. It's part of a series of reports going back to 2002 in the US. 

The report chronicles years of underperformance. In the five years since 2016, roughly 80% of Aussie equity and international equity managers underperformed their indexes. Two thirds of bond managers lagged their index.

Over the ten years since 2011, only 7% of international equity managers beat the index.

Add to this research from S&P showing that most active managers can’t consistently repeat outperformance, and one is led to ask why their clients remain invested.

Part of the reason is fees, says Morningstar manager research analyst Ed Huynh. Underperformance is not just an inability to pick stocks, but also the fees active managers charge. While retail investors must pay up, institutional clients can use their size to lower fees and capture more of the return.

“Big institutional clients like AustralianSuper can get access to active managers for much lower fees than retail investors would pay,” he says.

For example, bronze-rated Platinum International Fund trailed the index by 3.99% in 2020. A third of that was the 1.35% management fee. Gold-rated Magellan Global Open Class trailed the index by 1.04% in 2017, in part thanks to the 1.35% management fee.

Of the five categories covered by the report, international equity managers have the worst average performance versus their indexes.

Since 2011, the S&P Developed Ex-Australia LargeMidCap index returned 15.31% annualised, versus 13.26% for international equity managers. From $10,000 invested in 2011, that’s the difference between $42,000 and $35,000 today.

The data suggests many active managers struggle to capitalise on downturns. On a three-year basis, which includes the covid crash, about three-quarters of Australian and international equity underperformed.

Aussie mid-small cap managers are an exception

The banner for active management is left to Australian mid-and-small-cap managers.

Half of mid-and-small-cap managers beat their index in FY 2021. The ratio is relatively consistent over time, with 47% outperforming over 3-years, 43% over 10 years and 48% over 15 years.

If investors pick the right manager, the difference in returns is significant. Where the S&P/ASX Mid-Small index returned 9% over the last ten years, the average fund pulled in 11% on an asset-weighted basis.

The difference is due to Australia’s smaller size, says Morningstar manager research analyst Chris Tate. Less companies mean the index is smaller and less diversified.

“You’ve got a narrower market where there is a lot of junk in the domestic index,” he says, “It’s easier to outperform.”

Tate says this is less the case when it comes to international small caps because the coverage universe is far larger.

There are 195 companies in the S&P/ASX Small Ordinaries. The S&P Global SmallCap has 9231.

In the Australian small cap space, Morningstar likes the gold-rated Hyperion Small Growth Companies fund.

In the year to 31 August, the fund returned 38.86%, beating its index by 9.78%. Over a 5-year period it returned 17.31%, beating the index by 5.87%.

The top four holdings were Dominos Pizza (ASX: DMP), Xero (ASX: XRO), WiseTech Global (ASX: WTC) and Fisher & Payker Healthcare (ASX: FPH) as of 31 August.



© 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Neither Morningstar, its affiliates, nor the content providers guarantee the data or content contained herein to be accurate, complete or timely nor will they have any liability for its use or distribution. This report has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or New Zealand wholesale clients of Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc. Any general advice has been provided without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide at www.morningstar.com.au/s/fsg.pdf. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Our publications, ratings and products should be viewed as an additional investment resource, not as your sole source of information. Morningstar’s full research reports are the source of any Morningstar Ratings and are available from Morningstar or your adviser. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a financial adviser. Some material is copyright and published under licence from ASX Operations Pty Ltd ACN 004 523 782.

More from Morningstar
Is your index fund tracking the right index? Here’s what to look for
Funds
Is your index fund tracking the right index? Here’s what to look for
Understanding these 6 qualities of the best indexes can help investors choose among thousands of index funds.
Listed Investment Companies monthly performance: January 2024
Funds
Listed Investment Companies monthly performance: January 2024
The Morningstar LIC monthly report provides a snapshot of ASX-listed LICs, and whether they are trading at a premium or a discount to their net...
KiwiSaver Survey | December Quarter 2023
Funds
KiwiSaver Survey | December Quarter 2023
KiwiSaver assets increased, owing significantly to market movements, ending the quarter at NZD 104 billion, up around NZD 8 billion for the quarter.
Should ESG investing be criminalized?
Funds
Should ESG investing be criminalized?
The question, regrettably, is not a joke.
Thornhill on shares for investment income in retirement
Funds
Thornhill on shares for investment income in retirement
The dream of many investors is to be able to live off the dividend income from their shares. There is a relatively simple way to do this though it...