Morningstar Investor users sign in here.

Retirement

Is there really a better mousetrap for retirement income?

A new concept in risk pooling is interesting but pricey.


Figuring out how much you can safely spend during retirement has often been described as the most difficult problem in financial planning.

Prior to retirement coming up with how much you need to save is also a challenge. We have a four step process for pre-retirees to follow.

If you take out too much from a portfolio to support retirement spending, you run the risk of running out of assets later in life, especially if you’re fortunate enough to enjoy a long life span.

If you take out too little, you might miss out on some of the fruits of a lifetime of savings, such as travel, dining out, gifting money to charity or family members, or spending more on leisure activities.

A US based asset manager has launched a new attempt to solve this problem. LifeX, a brand-new series of funds from Stone Ridge Asset Management, promises to solve this problem by offering steady monthly payouts up until an individual reaches age 100—about 10 to 12 years beyond the average life expectancy for a person currently aged 65. These funds are interesting and novel in some respects but probably too pricey to truly revolutionize the retirement-income industry.

The mechanics

The LifeX funds are similar to annuities in some ways but are structured as open-end mutual funds. Each fund is targeted to a specific age and gender cohort, with birth years currently ranging from 1948 to 1963. Each age and gender cohort is available in two versions: a standard one with flat payouts and an inflation-adjusted version with payouts adjusted annually based on the Consumer Price Index.

Investors can buy and sell each fund at net asset value up until age 80, at which point each fund will convert to a closed-end format with no liquidity. Shareholders continue to receive monthly payments up until the age cohort reaches 100, at which point the funds are liquidated, with proceeds distributed to any shareholders still alive at that point. There are no payments or account proceeds made after a shareholder’s death.

The advantages

The structure of these new funds is clever in that it provides a new way of pooling longevity risk. In contrast to an annuity, which transfers longevity risk to the insurance company, the funds are structured to mutualize longevity risk across each group of shareholders in the same age and gender cohort.

This structure is similar to a tontine, an investment vehicle that was popular in Europe in the 1700s and 1800s but has fallen out of favor partly because of its unsavory reputation. (Essentially, tontines allow surviving shareholders to benefit from the death of other shareholders in the same pool.)

Offering risk pooling in a mutual fund format has other advantages, as well. Shareholders (working with an advisor) can simply purchase the funds in a regular brokerage account instead of filling out confusing and time-consuming applications for annuities offered by insurance companies. And in contrast to annuities, which typically offer no liquidity after purchase, shareholders purchasing the funds can redeem shares at NAV up until age 80.
It’s also difficult to find fixed annuities with inflation protection; those that do offer it typically come with a flat inflation adjustment rather than one indexed to the CPI.

The drawbacks

The LifeX funds have one obvious drawback: a 1% expense ratio. Given that their underlying holdings are simple portfolios made up of Treasury bonds or Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities, it’s tough to justify a fee that high, in my opinion.

The funds aren’t simply index funds as there are embedded actuarial estimates (provided by New York Life) for each fund in the lineup. Even so, 1% is still a steep price tag, especially because it’s structured as a unified management fee that doesn’t change in percentage terms over time.

As a result, the payout levels don’t look all that compelling. As of early February 2024, a 62-year-old male could purchase shares of LifeX Income Fund 1962M for $19.55 per share, which translates into an annual payout rate of 5.1%. A single-life fixed annuity for a person of the same age and gender currently offers an annual payout rate of 7.0%. Fixed annuities not only offer higher payouts but are also guaranteed by the issuing insurance company.

Finally, the LifeX funds are only sold through financial advisors, which means that most shareholders will pay an additional layer of asset-based fees. A LifeX spokesperson confirmed that the financial advisors the firm has met with are generally planning to include these funds in their asset totals when calculating asset-based fees.

Conclusion

There is a clear need for better retirement-income solutions. More people than ever will be transitioning into retirement in the coming years. The existing options for retirement income are often complex and difficult to understand, making them less widely used than they could be. The LifeX funds are a partial solution to this problem, but further work is still needed.



© 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Neither Morningstar, its affiliates, nor the content providers guarantee the data or content contained herein to be accurate, complete or timely nor will they have any liability for its use or distribution. This report has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or New Zealand wholesale clients of Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc. Any general advice has been provided without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide at www.morningstar.com.au/s/fsg.pdf. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Our publications, ratings and products should be viewed as an additional investment resource, not as your sole source of information. Morningstar’s full research reports are the source of any Morningstar Ratings and are available from Morningstar or your adviser. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a financial adviser. Some material is copyright and published under licence from ASX Operations Pty Ltd ACN 004 523 782.

More from Morningstar
The transition to retirement
Retirement
The transition to retirement
Even the best retirement plans require revision when confronted by the uncertainties of life
How much does it really cost to run an SMSF?
Retirement
How much does it really cost to run an SMSF?
Guidance from ASIC previously stated that balances above $500,000 allowed the flat fee administration to make sense. Research now calls for a...
How to get a 0% tax rate on super sooner
Retirement
How to get a 0% tax rate on super sooner
Savvy investors can use a Transition-to-Retirement account to increase retirement savings and save on tax. 
What if you don’t have enough to retire?
Retirement
What if you don’t have enough to retire?
4 steps to stretch your retirement savings. 
The 4% rule explained
Retirement
The 4% rule explained
The safe withdrawal rate is one of the most important components in retirement planning but many people don’t understand the basis of the...
Why you shouldn't wait until 35 to take your super seriously
Retirement
Why you shouldn't wait until 35 to take your super seriously
A recent Rainmaker study concludes that the best time to start taking super seriously is in your mid-thirties. I don't agree.