Magellan (ASX: MFG) proposes to merge with Barrenjoey, valuing the boutique bank at $1.6 billion, or 15 times Barrenjoey’s underlying net profit for calendar year 2025. The funding will come primarily from new shares issued to investors and shareholders.

Why it matters: The merger would diversify Magellan into investment banking while exposing investors to a growing but cyclical business.

  • The acquisition reduces reliance on asset management performance by adding fee-based advisory and capital markets revenue. There is also “theoretical” potential to leverage Barrenjoey’s institutional and corporate client relationships to cross-sell Magellan products and services.
  • However, investment banking’s cyclical nature also introduces risk that Barrenjoey’s normalized earnings could fall below recent results. This may add volatility rather than stabilizing the group’s earnings.

The bottom line: We ascribe 100% chance that the transaction will be successful. But we don’t think this deal is value-accretive over the long run. We calculate that it dilutes our fair value estimate by 3% to $8.65 from $8.90 for no-moat Magellan.

Big picture: Magellan’s fundamentals are weak, with the core funds management business continuing to experience earnings declines. The Barrenjoey acquisition changes the earnings mix and reactivates near-term earnings growth but does not directly address structural pressures.

  • We expect Magellan to suffer from net outflows in aggregate alongside declining fee margins, lower performance fees, normalizing returns from cyclical principal investments, and Barrenjoey, in the future.
  • While adding Barrenjoey can reduce reliance on asset-based fees, it does not resolve persistent net outflows or margin compression in the core funds management business (40% of the combined group revenue). Earnings stability will still depend on improving fund flows.

Magellan Financial Group’s proposed merger with Barrenjoey will modestly dilute fair value

Magellan Financial Group is an active manager of listed equities and infrastructure. The firm historically had considerable success in growing funds under management, owing to its record of outperformance all the way from 2008 to 2019, product expansion initiatives, and strong distribution capabilities. Excess cash is invested in funds, listed shares, and unlisted investments under its principal investments segment.

The firm has a fundamental, high-conviction investment approach. Its flagship global strategy has historically tilted toward consumer franchises—preferring large, developed market multinationals while avoiding commodities. FUM has historically been attracted by consistently achieving excess returns with lower volatility and drawdowns relative to peers.

Magellan’s products are well-distributed, with its funds featured across platforms. The firm also offers its products to overseas investors, such as facilitating distribution in North America through Frontier Partners.

There is a focus on targeting retail investors, with product expansion an increasingly common driver of growth. After pioneering the first active exchange-traded fund in Australia in 2015, Magellan has worked on attracting new FUM via its partnership initiatives, as well as launching its own low-cost active ETFs and maintainable strategies.

In light of Magellan’s broken streak of consistent outperformance, beginning in 2020, we believe a maintained improved record will be the precursor to stronger fund inflows and earnings improvements. While Magellan possesses a household brand, product variety, and distribution reach; the potential earnings upside from these traits will take time to manifest.

We continue to anticipate fee margin compression from industrywide fee pressure despite the firm’s stated reluctance to lower its management fees. Continued strong performance is key to maintaining margins, as future FUM growth is likely to hinge more on market movements rather than net flows, given Magellan’s maturity.

Magellan recently proposed merging with Barrenjoey to diversify earnings. But this would not address net outflows or margin pressure and increases exposure to cyclical income streams.

Bulls say

  • The scale of Magellan’s funds under management means it is still capable of maintaining earnings from the compounding of investment returns despite periodic outflows.
  • Due to structural market trends and product expansion initiatives, the prospects for Magellan’s organic FUM growth remain good, notably from investors seeking to diversify exposure to international equities or gain access to smart-beta investments.
  • Aside domestic tailwinds from superannuation, Magellan’s distribution relationships in the much larger offshore markets of the UK and the US should support growth.

Bears say

  • Most of Magellan’s earnings come from a few funds, meaning it has a high reliance on key investment personnel and the performance of its main funds. Should key people leave, or its main funds underperform for a prolonged period, outflows could be material.
  • We don’t think Magellan can restore its competitive strengths to its previous levels. Combined with a proliferation of alternatives, Magellan has matured in the global investing space, in the Australian context.
  • Its high retail fees are becoming difficult to justify in the face of competition from lower-cost passive alternatives.

Stocks

Is losing customers the pathway to success?

Undervalued ASX share on the right track.

Johannes Faul, CFA

Johannes Faul, CFA

02 March 2026

Mentioned: Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Ltd (DMP)

Domino’s Pizza’s (ASX: DMP) global network sales declined 2% in the first half of fiscal 2026. Less discounting to boost franchisee margins is reducing sales volumes. But cost-cutting and normalizing marketing spending stopped profits from declining. Underlying EBIT rose 1% to $102 million. Shares fell 11%.

Why it matters: Like-for-like sales declining by 3% in the first half is tracking below our prior estimate of flat like-for-like sales in fiscal 2026 and 2027. Sales deteriorated further in recent months. The 7% decline in like-for-like sales in the first eight weeks of the second half weighed heavily on market sentiment.

However, the result was more mixed than the steep stock price decline might suggest. Positive aspects include a strengthening balance sheet, rising franchisee profitability to three-year highs, and the conclusion of its senior leadership refresh. The new CEO starts mid-2026.

Attractive store returns are key in incentivizing store openings, the linchpin to Domino’s growth story. By removing blanket discounts and sharing cost savings with franchisees, store economics are improving, up 4% on a rolling 12-month basis.

The bottom line: We maintain our $41 fair value estimate for narrow-moat Domino’s. We lower our revenue and EBIT estimates by 4% on average over the next decade, due to 4% lower network sales. But the time value of money offsets, with only an immaterial impact on our valuation. Shares are cheap.

Turning around sales momentum is likely a multiyear exercise, but we believe the market is too pessimistic on the long-term growth opportunity. We estimate shares are pricing in only a few, if any, store openings and only moderate EBIT margin recovery.

Key stats: The risk of an equity raising or a fire sale of noncore assets is diminishing. The net leverage stands at 2.2, down from 2.6 in June 2025, and closing in on management’s target of 2.0. The unfranked dividend per share of $0.25 is 55% lower year over year.

More Resources

High Yield ASX Dividend Stocks

ASX dividend stocks with sustainable above average payouts, which are trading at discounts to o...

alt=“”

33 Undervalued ASX Stocks For 2026

Our outlook for different sectors in Australia and undervalued stock opportunities in 2026.

An illustration featuring the Morningstar Medalist Ratings in different colors.

Undervalued Mining Stocks for 2026

Morningstar screener reveals mining stocks trading at a discount to their fair value.

Losing customers is painful, but a stronger footing to grow is building

Domino’s Pizza Enterprises is the Australian master licence holder of the Domino’s Pizza brand. It also has operations in New Zealand, Japan, Singapore, Malaysia, France, Germany, Belgium, Luxembourg, Taiwan, Cambodia, and the Netherlands. The stock suits investors seeking exposure to the food and beverage sector. Management is active, importing marketing strategies from the United States, or creating new ones, and applying them to local trends in individual markets. Management has adapted to market trends by refreshing the product range, including healthier ingredients and gourmet styles, and transitioning to online ordering.

As a master franchisee, Domino’s has limited capital requirements, which means royalty payments it receives in the future should continue to be paid as partially franked dividends. This makes returns on invested capital very attractive. Brand and scale are key competitive advantages warranting a narrow economic moat rating, and future growth prospects are significant. Despite significant growth during recent years, Domino’s is by no means a mature business. Australia can still increase its store base by about one-fifth in the next few years, and European growth is much more substantial, with the potential to add two-thirds to the existing store base to around 2,200 outlets during the next decade.

Risks include a change in consumer taste for pizza as a food category and growth execution risk, particularly with differences between Australian, Asian, and European business environments. Good management can navigate these changes. McDonald’s modified its menu in response to an increasingly health-conscious society; we see this as a perfect example of a food business changing with the times.

Bulls say

Domino’s is a highly visible brand based on a successful US business model. Across Domino’s three regions, sales have increased at a CAGR of 5% over the past five years. We expect a network sales CAGR in the midsingle digits over the next five years.

The pizza market in Europe is highly fragmented, presenting a significant opportunity for Domino’s to take market share with an attractive value proposition, increased convenience to the customer, and a differentiated product offering.

The company’s large network size has positive implications for discounted supplier arrangements.

Bears say

There is a high level of competition, stemming from independent pizza stores and other quick-service restaurants.

The company might evaluate its target markets in new countries incorrectly, given the geographical distance and cultural variances.

The low-price business model may still be affected by slowing retail and discretionary spending.

Terms used in this article

Star Rating: Our one- to five-star ratings are guideposts to a broad audience and individuals must consider their own specific investment goals, risk tolerance, and several other factors. A five-star rating means our analysts think the current market price likely represents an excessively pessimistic outlook and that beyond fair risk-adjusted returns are likely over a long timeframe. A one-star rating means our analysts think the market is pricing in an excessively optimistic outlook, limiting upside potential and leaving the investor exposed to capital loss.

Fair Value: Morningstar’s Fair Value estimate results from a detailed projection of a company’s future cash flows, resulting from our analysts’ independent primary research. Price To Fair Value measures the current market price against estimated Fair Value. If a company’s stock trades at $100 and our analysts believe it is worth $200, the price to fair value ratio would be 0.5. A Price to Fair Value over 1 suggests the share is overvalued.

Moat Rating: An economic moat is a structural feature that allows a firm to sustain excess profits over a long period. Companies with a narrow moat are those we believe are more likely than not to sustain excess returns for at least a decade. For wide-moat companies, we have high confidence that excess returns will persist for 10 years and are likely to persist at least 20 years.

Get Morningstar insights in your inbox