Morningstar Investor users sign in here.

Video

Bare shelves only a short-term hit to Coles and Woolies

Empty shelves will negatively impact supermarkets in the second half of fiscal 2022 but the impact on long-term earnings is minimal, says Morningstar analyst Johannes Faul. 

Mentioned: Coles Group Ltd (COL), Woolworths Group Ltd (WOW)


Emma Rapaport: Hello, and welcome to Morningstar. I'm Emma Rapaport. Joining me today is Johannes Faul. He is a Director in our Equity Research team.

Johannes, thank you very much for joining us.

Johannes Faul: Thanks so much for having me, Emma.

Rapaport: Johannes, I think you would have noticed as much as anyone else in Australia or anyone specifically in New South Wales that a lot of supermarket shelves have been bare. I'm particularly thinking about fresh fruits and vegetables, meat, things like that. So, I wanted to get your take as an analyst for both Coles and Woolworths about what this means for the stocks and for the long-term outlook of the sector. I want to first get your thoughts on – for me, this feels like it's not necessarily the same as the supermarket panic buying that we saw in early 2020, but a very different sort of shortage. Can you explain quickly why we're seeing empty shelves in our supermarkets?

Faul: Yeah, absolutely. Well, one thing that's a bit of reminiscence of back then is toilet papers is hot commodity again. Never would have thought that we'd see that again. Yeah. So, this time around, it is a bit different, as you say Emma, and what it is, is this time we're having supply chain issues. And what's happening is, a lot of people can't show up at work, or couldn't because they're isolating for whichever reason. Those supply chain issues should hopefully alleviate over the next couple of weeks. And that's also the guidance that we've been hearing out of management from Woolworths. So, we'll see those shelves a bit empty for a few more weeks, but then we should hopefully return to fuller shelves.

Rapaport: As an analyst for Coles and Woolworths, is this something that you're worried about, something that you're looking at or something you're worried about for reporting season come next month?

Faul: Yeah. So, reporting season coming next month will be the first half of 2022, and we hadn't seen the issues that we're really seeing today in January. They weren't really impacting up until maybe late December when it started. So, we haven't really had that in that first fiscal half. But for the second fiscal half of 2022, it will have an impact. And the impact that it will have is, on one side, there's a lot of demand. That's the positive side. The negative side, though, is that it's very, very disruptive. These supply chain issues are very disruptive to supermarket operations, and they're disruptive in store, but they're also disruptive on the warehousing side, on the delivery side, on the trucking side, so all through that chain, throughout value chain. And if you think about supermarkets, it's a really, really well run, well-oiled machine. It's running on very skinny profit margins. It's a problem having those inefficiencies. So, all up, on balance, this is probably a negative for the second half of fiscal 2022. But then, it's temporary. As I say, we're expecting a lot of this will be over that hump in the next couple of weeks and then things will normalize. So, it will be short and severe, but it won't impact the long term, and it won't impact our long-term outlook on earnings, and our investment thesis still stands for Woolworths and Coles.

Rapaport: Do you expect that this could lead to any sort of food inflation for the supermarket sector? Or as you say, will it be a very sort of temporary thing?

Faul: That's a really, really good question, and that's something that's more underlying and something that's happening more fundamentally than just these more severe supply chain shortages or supply shortages that we're seeing, and that's inflation. And on the inflation slide, even before this all started, we saw inflation returning. So, we are predicting, or we're estimating that inflation for the December quarter has actually returned.

So, what happened going back a few quarters is we saw a lot of food price inflation when COVID first emerged in 2020. Then in 2021, in calendar 2021, we had the last three quarters up until the September quarter, we saw food prices actually deflating, so prices being lowered. And now, for the December quarter, we're expecting Coles and Woolworths both to report food price inflation. So, that's actually already changed before the supply shortages emerged. And for this quarter, we would expect that's going to get another big boost from what we've been seeing. Longer term though, we see food price inflation here to stay, not rampant, not in the mid-single digits, but in the low-single digits and stay there pretty much with what you'd expect on like a long-term consumer price inflation or CPI.

Rapaport: Yeah. And just quickly to round out, both Woolworths and Coles are currently screening as overvalued stocks and have had a relatively difficult last month as well. Could you just quickly sum up your outlook for both stocks and why you see it both of them as not been great buys?

Faul: Yeah. Both of them, if you look at their price to earnings ratios or multiples, they're sort trading at fairly high multiples, even despite this slight correction we've seen in last few weeks, and my anticipation is that that's mainly driven by the operational challenges that we're seeing at the moment. But if you look at it more fundamentally, those high P/Es basically mean there's growth expectations in there. The market has growth expectations in terms of earnings growth for both Woolworths and Coles. And we don't see a lot of earnings growth happening, and we don't see them becoming dramatically more profitable over the next decade, and we don't see a lot of top-line growth. We expect the top-line growth, so the revenue growth for both supermarkets really to be driven by population growth, and as I just mentioned, a low-single digits CPI figure. Now, that outlook for earnings growth doesn't really warrant the current multiples they're trading on. So, all up, the supermarkets still look expensive. On a relative basis, Coles is more attractive than Woolworths. So, as an investment we would prefer Coles over Woolworths at current prices.

Rapaport: Great. Thank you so much for joining us today.

Faul: Thanks a lot, Emma.



© 2023 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Neither Morningstar, its affiliates, nor the content providers guarantee the data or content contained herein to be accurate, complete or timely nor will they have any liability for its use or distribution. This report has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or New Zealand wholesale clients of Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc. Any general advice has been provided without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide at www.morningstar.com.au/s/fsg.pdf. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Our publications, ratings and products should be viewed as an additional investment resource, not as your sole source of information. Morningstar’s full research reports are the source of any Morningstar Ratings and are available from Morningstar or your adviser. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a financial adviser. Some material is copyright and published under licence from ASX Operations Pty Ltd ACN 004 523 782.

More from Morningstar

Bank results: the winners and losers
Video

Bank results: the winners and losers

Morningstar analyst Nathan Zaia explains how the banks did and what the future holds.
How to deal with financial stress
Video

How to deal with financial stress

More high-income earners are now also experiencing financial stress. We go through practical ways to reduce it
UniSuper CIO John Pearce on why the 60/40 portfolio is far from dead
Video

UniSuper CIO John Pearce on why the 60/40 portfolio is far from dead

The $130 Billion SuperFund Manager also talks about how he sees risk, his recent investments, and why history isn’t a good guide to the future.
Incitec Pivot: explosive upside ahead?
Video

Incitec Pivot: explosive upside ahead?

Morningstar analyst Mark Taylor believes imminent growth in explosives earnings could lift sentiment.
Why Morningstar see opportunities in coal stocks
Video

Why Morningstar see opportunities in coal stocks

Analyst Jon Mills explains why he’s recently increased fair value estimates for Australian coal companies.
Is the sharp fall in ResMed's share price justified?
Video

Is the sharp fall in ResMed's share price justified?

The potential for weight loss drugs to impact the sleep apnea giant has weighed on the share price, though Morningstar analyst Shane Ponraj thinks...